Arizona Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in Arizona, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Arizona opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Are Arizona's 500-year wait-and-see period and the perpetual-trust exception in A.R.S. § 14-2901 unconstitutional under the state constitution's ban on perpetuities and entailments?
Both A.R.S. § 14-2901(A)(2) (allowing future interests to vest within 500 years) and § 14-2901(A)(3) (allowing perpetual trusts when the trustee has the power of sale and someone alive at creation can…
Can a county attorney's anti-racketeering forfeiture fund pay the outside counsel hired by the board of supervisors to review the county attorney's spending requests?
Yes. After the 2017 amendments to A.R.S. § 13-2314.03, the county board of supervisors must review and approve a county attorney's spending of money from the county anti-racketeering revolving fund (R…
Can Arizona cities still enforce noise ordinances against short-term rentals after the 2016 vacation-rental preemption law (SB 1350)?
Yes, generally-applicable city and county noise ordinances still apply to short-term and vacation rentals after the 2016 SB 1350 preemption law. The statute (A.R.S. §§ 9-500.39(B)(2), 11-269.17(B)(2))…
Can two Arizona fire districts merge their operations under a single joint authority without putting it on the ballot, and is that a disenfranchisement of voters?
Yes, the Central Arizona Fire and Medical Authority (CAFMA), formed by Central Yavapai Fire District and Chino Valley Fire District in 2015, was lawful. A.R.S. § 48-805.01 expressly allows fire distri…
Can an out-of-state call center handle property maintenance calls and rental inquiries for Arizona properties without a real estate license?
Yes, with conditions. Out-of-state call center workers handling maintenance calls (taking the call, routing the work order, dispatching emergency repair) for Arizona residential rentals are exempt fro…
Do alcohol-delivery apps (like Drizly) need an Arizona liquor license, and how do delivery and after-hours rules apply when an unlicensed app is the front end?
Five answers in one opinion. (1) An unlicensed app that 'sells' alcohol violates the 2:00-6:00 a.m. service hour ban by accepting orders during those hours, even if the alcohol is not delivered until …
Can a teacher employed by a JTED member district sit on the JTED's governing board, or is that a conflict?
The statute does not flat-out prohibit a member district's CTE teacher from serving on a JTED governing board, but the common-law doctrine of incompatibility of public offices likely does, because the…
How much can the Arizona Legislature limit or expand the powers of the Arizona Board of Regents through statute?
The Legislature has broad authority to define the Arizona Board of Regents' powers by statute, with one constitutional exception: it cannot transfer general conduct and supervision of state universiti…
Can Arizona counties keep their own voter registration databases, and can the Secretary of State pass off public records requests for voter data to the counties?
Yes, Arizona counties can run their own voter registration databases (Maricopa and Pima do), but they must transmit every piece of voter information they hold to the official statewide database in rea…
Does Arizona law let state and county officials use, maintain, and protect access to old federal R.S. 2477 roads across federal land, even when the BLM tries to close them?
Yes. The AG concluded that A.R.S. § 37-931 reaffirms broad state authority to use, access, and maintain valid R.S. 2477 rights-of-way across federal lands, though significant changes still require coo…
Are an Arizona public official's text messages and social media DMs about government business public records, even if sent on a personal phone or account?
It depends on the device. Messages on government-issued phones or accounts are public records. Messages on truly private devices and accounts are not, but officials still have an affirmative duty to r…
Does an Arizona county supervisor have to resign to apply for a Superior Court judgeship the Governor would fill by appointment?
No. The AG's informal opinion concluded that submitting an application for a gubernatorial appointment is not the same as 'offering yourself for nomination or election.' The resign-to-run statute requ…
Can Arizona registered nurse practitioners order and interpret x-rays without a separate radiation license?
Yes. The AG concluded that 'use' of x-ray equipment in the radiation statute means physically operating the machine, not ordering or interpreting images. RNPs are licensed practitioners governed by th…
When an Arizona statute requires notice 'by mail' to political party precinct committeemen, can email satisfy the requirement?
No. The AG's informal opinion concluded that 'by mail' in A.R.S. § 16-824 means delivery through the postal service. Email is treated separately throughout Arizona law, so notice by email is not enoug…
Can Arizona's Board of Technical Registration discipline a 'trained geologist' who is exempt from registration?
Mostly no. The AG concluded that 2016 amendments exempted 'trained geologists' from registration, putting them outside the Board's disciplinary jurisdiction. The Board can still investigate complaints…
If a high school district refuses to transfer credit from a charter school, can the student demand a placement test to earn that credit?
Yes. The AG concluded that once a student enrolls and asks, the high school district must offer the student a chance to demonstrate competency in a subject without taking the class. For high school ma…
What are Arizona police allowed to do under SB 1070 when they suspect someone is in the country without authorization?
The AG laid out a model policy: officers may check immigration status during a lawful stop if reasonable suspicion exists, but may not prolong the stop to do so, may not use race or ethnicity as the b…
Can a private school in Arizona allow non-police employees to carry concealed firearms on campus?
Yes. The AG concluded that neither Arizona law nor the federal Gun Free School Zones Act stops a private school from letting CCW permit holders carry concealed handguns on campus, or from securely sto…
Can an Arizona constable carry a firearm into places where civilians cannot under § 38-1113, even when the constable is off-duty and not performing official duties?
Off-duty constables generally do not get the peace-officer firearm-carry exception in A.R.S. § 38-1113. A constable's peace-officer status applies only 'in the performance of the constable's official …
When does the 60-day window protecting Arizona political signs from city removal start: 60 days before primary-election day, or 60 days before early ballots are mailed?
60 days before primary election day. The 'period commencing sixty days before a primary election' in A.R.S. § 16-1019(H) is measured from the statutorily defined primary election date in A.R.S. § 16-2…
If pending lawsuits challenge Proposition 123 as conflicting with Arizona's federal Enabling Act, can the State Board of Investment be sued personally for following Prop 123's payout rules in the meantime?
No liability. Arizona public officials must obey the law unless a court enjoins it or declares it unconstitutional. Until that happens, the State Board of Investment must follow Proposition 123's dist…
Can a single Arizona Corporation Commissioner demand that a regulated utility hand over records of its political contributions, lobbying spend, and corporate structure, including for affiliates?
An individual Commissioner may inspect a public service corporation's books, papers, and documents under § 40-241, including records of political and charitable contributions and lobbying. Affiliates …
Can Arizona DCS investigators interview a child without first getting parental consent when they're investigating a neglect report, even though the statute says 'abuse or abandonment investigation'?
Yes. Despite the statutory text using 'abuse or abandonment investigation,' the cross-references and statutory context show the legislature intended the exception to apply to all statutorily authorize…
Can a private landowner who donates a conservation easement to Arizona qualify for the federal tax deduction, given that A.R.S. § 38-511 lets the State cancel any state contract within three years?
A.R.S. § 38-511 doesn't apply to a private landowner's gratuitous conservation easement donation. Without consideration flowing back to the donor, there's no contract within the meaning of the statute…
Do the companies that run red-light and speed cameras for Arizona cities have to be licensed as private investigators?
Yes. A company that operates red-light or speed cameras for an Arizona city is securing evidence for civil or criminal cases, which falls within A.R.S. § 32-2401(16)(b)'s definition of 'private invest…
After the NFPA withdrew its 2013 Code 1124 for fireworks safety, did Arizona still need to adopt that withdrawn version under § 36-1609, and is the resulting state rule still valid?
Yes, the rule was required and remains valid. The 2013 amendment to A.R.S. § 36-1609(A) directed the State Fire Marshal to adopt NFPA 1124 (2013 edition). Under Arizona's incorporation-by-reference do…
Can a county board of supervisors take cartography and property-title staff away from the elected county assessor and put them in a department reporting to the board?
No. Cartography and property-title functions are necessary for an Arizona county assessor to perform her constitutional and statutory duties: identifying, mapping, and assigning ownership to all taxab…
Can chiropractors in Arizona advertise that they offer 'physiotherapy' or 'physical therapy,' or are those terms reserved for licensed physical therapists?
No exemption. Under A.R.S. § 32-2042(C) and (D), nobody in Arizona, including chiropractors, may use the words 'physical therapy', 'physiotherapy', 'physical therapist', or letters like PT, RPT, MPT, …
After the Reed v. Town of Gilbert ruling on content-based sign regulations, does Arizona need to amend its political sign statute (A.R.S. § 16-1019)?
No. The Supreme Court's Reed v. Town of Gilbert decision applies strict scrutiny to content-based speech restrictions. A.R.S. § 16-1019 doesn't restrict speech; it limits what local governments can do…
Which Arizona local government records belong to the State Library, and which Arizona special districts and unincorporated communities have to comply with the State Library's records retention rules?
When 'agencies' appears unmodified in the State Library Statute, surrounding language usually clarifies whether it covers state, local, or both. Records of unincorporated communities aren't State prop…
Can Pima County conduct a hand count audit of a county bond election, a Tucson city election, and an Oro Valley recall election without running afoul of A.R.S. § 16-602(B)(2)(f)?
No conflict. A.R.S. § 16-602's mandatory hand count audit applies only to countywide primary, special, general, and presidential preference elections that include statewide ballot measures, statewide …
Can a parent in Arizona pull their child out of the AzMERIT or other state-mandated standardized tests, the way they can opt out of certain learning materials?
No. A statewide assessment such as AzMERIT is not a 'learning material' or 'learning activity' under A.R.S. § 15-102, so the opt-out provisions don't apply. The Parents' Bill of Rights at A.R.S. §§ 1-…
When an Arizona school district calculates how much bond debt it can take on, does it use the full cash value of taxable property in the district or the lower limited property value?
Full cash value. School district bond indebtedness limits under Article 9, §§ 8 and 8.1 of the Arizona Constitution have always been calculated on full cash value. Proposition 117's introduction of li…
When does the ban on counties using public resources to support or oppose a ballot measure kick in, and what kinds of communications cross the line?
The prohibition on counties using public resources to influence a ballot measure under A.R.S. § 11-410 begins when the Secretary of State issues a serial number to the petition. Whether particular con…
Can two or more Arizona nonprofits team up to run a single raffle without violating gambling laws, or does each raffle need a single sponsoring nonprofit?
Yes. More than one Arizona nonprofit may serve as the 'sponsoring organization' for a single raffle under A.R.S. § 13-3302(B), as long as each nonprofit independently qualifies for the gambling exempt…
If pilots land aircraft for recreational fly-ins on Arizona state trust land, can the State be sued for injuries, or does the recreational-use immunity statute shield it?
The recreational use statute can immunize the State Land Department, but only if access is granted without an admission fee or other consideration. Standard Department leases and special use permits c…
After SB 1476's changes, which Arizona charter schools still get the Small School Weight bump in their state funding, and how does it apply to schools serving K-12?
A charter holder qualifies for the Small School Weight only if its aggregate average daily membership across all its schools is under 600. The number of separate charters held no longer matters. The c…
Is the Rio Nuevo Multipurpose Facilities District in Tucson subject to Arizona's Gift Clause when it spends money to attract private development?
No. The Rio Nuevo Multipurpose Facilities District is a tax-levying public improvement district under A.R.S. § 48-4202, and Arizona's Exemption Clause (Art. 13, § 7) exempts such districts from the Gi…
Can a city or county refuse to apply Arizona's charter-school zoning protections to a charter school that leases its building instead of owning it?
No. Under A.R.S. § 15-189.01, charter schools must be treated like district schools for zoning, regardless of whether they own or lease their facilities. A municipality cannot impose any zoning restri…
If I fire an antique black-powder pistol or muzzleloader in Arizona, am I treated the same as if I fired a modern firearm under criminal law?
Yes. Arizona's criminal code defines 'firearm' to include any operable firearm without distinguishing antique from modern. The federal antique-firearm exception in 18 U.S.C. § 921(a)(16) (covering pre…
Can Arizona racetracks offer 'Instant Racing' slot-machine-style betting on historical horse races, or does that count as illegal gambling?
No. The Arizona Racing Commission and Department of Racing cannot authorize Instant Racing by rule. Pari-mutuel wagering on horseraces is permitted under A.R.S. § 5-112(A) only at live races at a meet…
If an Arizona inmate eligible for parole refuses to attend their parole hearing, does the Board still have to hold the hearing and make a decision?
Yes on all three. When an Arizona inmate is certified as parole-eligible, the Board of Executive Clemency must conduct a parole hearing and decide whether to grant or deny parole, even if the inmate w…
Can an Arizona municipality limit the right to petition for or vote on disincorporation to property taxpayers, and require six months' residency before voting?
No. The provisions in A.R.S. §§ 9-212 and 9-215 limiting disincorporation petition signers and voters to property taxpayers, and the 6-month residency requirement to vote on disincorporation, violate …
If a retired Arizona police officer goes back to work in another public job, does receiving their PSPRS pension count as 'participating' in PSPRS, exempting them from joining ASRS?
No. A retired PSPRS member (Public Safety Personnel Retirement System) who returns to work for an employer participating in ASRS (Arizona State Retirement System) must join ASRS if they meet ASRS memb…
Are electronic cigarettes (vape pens) taxed as tobacco products in Arizona, and can they be used in places where smoking is banned?
No on both. Electronic cigarettes (vapor products) do not contain rolls or pieces of tobacco, so they fall outside the categories of taxable tobacco products in A.R.S. title 42, chapter 3. They also a…
If my spouse works for the Arizona fire district where I serve on the board, does one of us have to resign? What about non-spouse relatives, and what training do board members need?
If a fire district board member is married to an employee of that fire district, one of them must immediately resign because the spouse-employee combination is a class 2 misdemeanor for the board memb…
If I own my real estate through one LLC and manage it through a separate LLC I also own, do I need a real estate broker's license for the management LLC?
Yes. Under A.R.S. § 32-2101(48), an entity that manages property for another and for compensation must have an Arizona real estate broker's license. The owner-managed exemption in A.R.S. § 32-2121(A)(…
If I had a misdemeanor conviction for theft 25 years ago and have had my civil rights restored, can I be denied an Arizona alarm-industry license today?
Yes on all three. A.R.S. § 32-122.07(A) requires the AZ Board of Technical Registration to deny alarm certifications to anyone who has ever been convicted of any of the 13 listed crimes, regardless of…
If I just want to look at Arizona public records or photograph them with my phone, can the agency still charge me a copying fee?
No on both counts. Under A.R.S. § 39-121, a public body cannot charge a copying fee when a requesting party only wants to inspect records (even if the agency has to print or redact internally to enabl…
If someone registers to vote in Arizona using only the federal form and doesn't show proof of citizenship, can they vote in state and local races, get a ballot at all, or sign petitions?
Voters who register using only the federal form without providing evidence of citizenship are eligible to vote only in federal races, not in state or local elections, and cannot sign state or local ca…
Can the city of Tucson require gun owners to report lost or stolen firearms within 48 hours, or require alcohol tests of people who negligently discharge firearms, when state law preempts city firearm ordinances?
Yes, A.R.S. § 13-3108 preempts both Tucson ordinances. Ordinance 11080 (alcohol-test request after negligent firearm discharge) directly conflicts with § 13-3108(A) because it relates to firearm disch…
If a lobbyist anonymously contributes to a legal defense fund for an Arizona legislator, does that count as a 'gift' under the lobbyist gift restrictions, and is it reportable?
A lobbyist's anonymous contribution to a legal defense fund for an Arizona legislator falls within the broad definition of 'gift' under A.R.S. § 41-1231(9). However, under the rule of lenity (because …
After the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the Voting Rights Act preclearance coverage formula in Shelby County, are Arizona statutes that were enacted but never precleared now valid and enforceable?
Yes. The U.S. Supreme Court's June 25, 2013 decision in Shelby County, Alabama v. Holder struck down the Voting Rights Act coverage formula in Section 4(b), removing Arizona's Section 5 preclearance o…
After Arizona's 2013 HB 2593 raised contribution limits and split them across primary and general elections, when can a candidate accept those amounts and how should the committee account for them?
Yes to most of the eleven questions. After HB 2593 (effective Sept. 13, 2013), an Arizona candidate committee may accept up to the maximum contribution for both the primary and the general election, e…
Can a sitting Arizona legislator be on the board of a super PAC or 501(c)(4) that supports other candidates, without violating Arizona campaign-finance law?
Yes, with limits. An incumbent Arizona legislator may associate with a state political committee or super PAC that supports or opposes other candidates, provided (a) the committee is not the candidate…
Can a JROTC instructor or guidance counselor at an Arizona public school be paid from the Classroom Site Fund's performance-pay set-aside?
Possessing a teaching certificate is necessary but not sufficient for Classroom Site Fund performance pay under A.R.S. § 15-977. Per Reeves v. Barlow, a school employee must hold a Board of Education …
Was Arizona's House Bill 2178 (forgiving property taxes for landowners along the Colorado River) constitutional, or did it improperly favor a small group of property owners?
H.B. 2178 is an unconstitutional special law. Forgiving 1987-2009 property taxes only for Mohave County landowners in the Disputed Triangle (sued by the federal government for the Fort Mojave Tribe) b…
When an Arizona legislative seat opens up in a district that crosses county lines, do the three nominees to fill the seat all have to live in the same county as the legislator who left?
Yes. Under A.R.S. § 41-1202(A), nominees to fill an Arizona legislative vacancy in a multi-county district must reside in the same county as the vacating legislator. The 1999, 2002, and 2012 amendment…
If an Arizona school district opens a new district-sponsored charter school, can it still claim Rapid Growth funding for students who shifted from the district's traditional schools to its charter schools?
When an Arizona school district opts to fund a district-sponsored charter school under A.R.S. § 15-185(A)(3), all charter school pupils must be excluded from the district's Rapid Growth calculation un…
Does an Arizona alarm-installation business already licensed by the Registrar of Contractors also need to register with the Board of Technical Registration, and what convictions disqualify alarm operators?
An Arizona alarm business may be licensed either by the Registrar of Contractors or by the Board of Technical Registration; it does not need both. Only BTR-certified businesses must comply with the fu…
Browse Arizona opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in Arizona are written by the Arizona Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.