New Mexico Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in New Mexico, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New Mexico opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Is New Mexico's outfitter set-aside for elk and bighorn sheep hunting licenses constitutional?
The AG concluded that the 10% outfitter set-aside, as enforceable after a federal injunction, violates New Mexico's anti-donation clause. Pooling bighorn sheep tags across hunt units would add a…
Can New Mexico police departments withhold an entire internal-affairs investigation as a personnel matter?
No, not under IPRA's matters-of-opinion exception. The AG concluded that a custodian must separate protected opinion material from factual or other nonopinion information and disclose the remainder,…
Can a New Mexico charter school's capital-outlay project include both its land lease-purchase cost and new school construction?
Yes. The AG concluded that a charter school's total project cost may include both the purchase option under an existing land-only lease-purchase agreement and the remaining cost to build the school…
Can New Mexico's State Auditor examine agency computer systems during a special audit, and can a rule broaden that power?
The State Auditor may examine an agency's information technology systems when the examination directly relates to its financial affairs or transactions and generally accepted auditing practices…
Can the New Mexico Commission for the Blind use Title VII Part B federal funds and Social Security reimbursements for independent living services, and do the Statewide Independent Living Council's proposed public-comment policies violate the First Amendment?
Yes, the Commission can use Part B funds for independent living services for people under 55. Receipt of Part B funds is not a prerequisite for using Social Security reimbursements for independent…
When New Mexico law enforcement uses a warrant to extract data from someone's phone or email and then is required by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act to seal portions unrelated to the investigation, can a third party still get those sealed portions through an Inspection of Public Records Act request?
No. The Electronic Communications Privacy Act's sealing provisions (§ 10-16F-3(D)(2), (G), (H), and (L)) qualify for IPRA's catchall exception under § 14-2-1(N), which exempts records 'otherwise…
Is New Mexico's refundable Film Production Tax Credit (which can pay film companies more than they owe in tax) constitutional under the state constitution's Anti-Donation Clause?
Yes. The Anti-Donation Clause prohibits gifts of public funds without consideration. The Film Production Tax Credit Act requires film companies to fulfill specific statutory obligations (employment…
When New Mexico's legislature changed watershed district director selection from elections to appointments in 2025 and dropped the residency requirement built into the old election framework, did the change make it unconstitutional to require directors to live in the district?
No, the amendment is not facially unconstitutional. The New Mexico Constitution (art. 5, § 13) independently requires that 'district officers' be residents of the political subdivision they…
Can New Mexico's legislature give the State Chief Information Security Officer authority to set cybersecurity standards across all branches of government, including for judicial branch IT systems, without violating the separation of powers?
It depends on the substance of the standards. The legislature can constitutionally delegate authority to the executive to set cybersecurity standards. It can also condition use of executive-owned…
Did New Mexico's 2023 Native American Voting Rights Act force counties to redraw precinct boundaries on tribal lands right away, or do counties wait until their next regular boundary update?
Counties wait. Section 1-21A-3 does not impose its own deadline. The tribal-consultation duty is triggered the next time a board of county commissioners adjusts precinct boundaries under existing…
Can a New Mexico public university just promote its interim president into the permanent role, or does state law force the board of regents to run a formal search?
A formal search is required. Section 21-1-16.1(B) makes the board consider at least five finalists, give 21 days' public notice of the finalists, and take the final hiring vote in an open public…
Can a New Mexico county or city use opioid settlement money to help build a general behavioral health facility that will treat some opioid patients along with patients who have other mental health conditions?
No. Under the State-Subdivision Agreement, opioid settlement funds can only pay for opioid-specific expenditures. Construction of a general behavioral health facility that treats a mix of patients…
Are DraftKings, FanDuel, and other Daily Fantasy Sports apps legal in New Mexico?
The AG could not reach a definitive conclusion about DFS contests without facts about particular games. No New Mexico law expressly authorizes DFS. Whether a contest is a regulated game depends on…
Can New Mexico let non-tribal racetracks offer Class II gaming (like bingo-style machines) without breaking the 2015 tribal-state gaming compact, and could the tribes stop their revenue sharing if it does?
The Attorney General declined to give a categorical answer. The questions turn on whether the term Gaming Machine in the 2015 Compact reaches Class II machines or only Class III, and that requires…
Can a new political party in New Mexico collect its qualification-petition signatures electronically (DocuSign, online portals, tablets), or do they have to be on paper in pen?
On paper in pen. Section 1-7-2(A) requires the petition information, including signatures, to be hand-printed. The AG concluded the more specific Election Code requirement controls over the general…
Can a New Mexico hospital that financed its building through the Hospital Equipment Loan Council claim a property tax exemption on the land and the building, or only on the equipment?
Not based on Council ownership. The Hospital Equipment Loan Act tries to designate the Council as 'the state' just for purposes of the constitutional property-tax exemption, but the same statute…
Are the meetings of the New Mexico Activities Association (the body that runs middle and high school sports and activities) covered by the state's Open Meetings Act?
Yes. NMAA and its committees and subcommittees, including the Hardship Review Committee and the Appeals Review Committee, must follow the Open Meetings Act. Section 22-2-2(L) directs the Public…
When can a New Mexico racetrack casino legally have its gaming machines on, and does it have to set aside money for racing purses?
A racetrack casino can run gaming machines only on days the racetrack is conducting live or simulcast horse races, up to 18 hours per day and 112 hours per week (with the week resetting Tuesday 8:00…
Can two proposed New Mexico hydrogen projects that produce hydrogen from natural gas qualify for grants from the state Energy Transition Economic Development Assistance Fund, which the statute reserves for projects 'unrelated to fossil fuel development or use'?
No. Both projects propose to use steam-methane reforming with natural gas as the feedstock. Natural gas is a fossil fuel under any ordinary definition, and the Fund's enabling statute, Section…
Does New Mexico's law requiring disclaimers on AI-generated political ads (HB 182) violate the First Amendment?
Mostly no, but partly yes. The disclaimer requirement and the consent exception are constitutional, but the AG concluded the requirement that satire and parody also carry the disclaimer is likely…
Can New Mexico require county jails to provide medication-assisted treatment for opioid addiction without paying for it?
No. The Attorney General concluded that the rule (8.325.12 NMAC) requiring all correctional facilities to run medication-assisted treatment programs is an unconstitutional unfunded mandate against…
Is the Jackpocket lottery app legal in New Mexico, or does it violate state lottery and gambling laws and trigger renegotiation of the Indian Gaming Compact?
It is likely illegal. The AG concluded the Jackpocket app constitutes 'internet gaming,' which triggers the Tribal-State Class III Gaming Compact's renegotiation clause. The app also likely violates…
Do tribal libraries and nonprofit libraries in New Mexico have to hold open meetings under the Open Meetings Act?
No, generally not. Tribal libraries are part of sovereign tribal governments and not state agencies. Nonprofit libraries are private charities, not public bodies. Either could become subject to the…
Does the New Mexico Military Institute get a share of the extra 1.25% annual distribution from the state's land grant permanent funds that voters approved in 2022, including the 60% piece earmarked for early childhood education?
No, on either question. The 2022 amendment's extra 1.25% distribution comes only from the permanent school fund, which the federal Enabling Act limits to support of public (common) schools. NMMI is…
Can a New Mexico state agency sign the standard US Forest Service indemnity language for a special-use permit that lets it put a cell tower or other equipment on federal land?
Partly. The State can agree to indemnify the United States up to the Tort Claims Act's liability limits and can name the USDA as an additional insured on a commercial general liability policy…
Can the Mesalands Community College Board of Trustees demand money from the Mesalands Community College Foundation when the College needs cash?
No. The College Board can request funds, but the Foundation is not legally required to comply with any specific request. The Foundation's directors owe fiduciary duties (good faith, care, loyalty)…
If a New Mexico statute says members of the State Music Commission cannot receive 'compensation, perquisite or allowance,' can they still be reimbursed for the gas and per diem they spend traveling to a Commission meeting?
Yes. The Per Diem and Mileage Act applies to members of the Commission as nonsalaried public officers and authorizes mileage reimbursement at the IRS standard rate plus per diem within statutory…
When the New Mexico State Ethics Commission votes in closed session on whether to file a civil enforcement action, does the Open Meetings Act force it to put the target's name on the public agenda?
No, not necessarily. The Open Meetings Act requires 'reasonable specificity' on agendas, but reasonableness is fact-specific. Because the State Ethics Commission Act keeps complaint and…
When does the New Mexico Public Education Department have to submit its annual special-appropriations budget request to the Legislative Finance Committee and the Department of Finance and Administration?
September 1. Section 6-3A-7(B) sets the September 1 deadline for performance-based program budget requests, and PED's special 'below the line' appropriations (teacher development, AP test waivers,…
Can New Mexico's Public Education Department give money from the state Indian Education Fund directly to tribal schools and Bureau of Indian Education schools, or must the funds go only to public schools the state controls?
Yes, PED can fund tribal and BIE schools from the Indian Education Fund. Distributions support the Indian Education Act's purposes and do not run afoul of the Anti-Donation Clause, the prohibition…
When does a developer have to give up control of a master-planned community's homeowners association board and let homeowners elect their own representatives?
Under New Mexico's Homeowners Association Act, the developer can run the board alone only until 25% of lots are sold to non-developer owners. After that, owners must elect at least 25% of the board,…
Can a New Mexico school board member vote against a check the superintendent has already paid?
An individual school board member has no unilateral authority over expenditures, but the board as a body does. The board may question, discuss, and vote on any check, including ones the…
Can a New Mexico town annex part of a designated 'traditional historic community' if a single landowner asks, or does the state require the wider community to vote?
The wider community has to vote. Under NMSA § 3-7-1.1, a municipality cannot annex any land within a traditional historic community (THC) unless a majority of the qualified electors of the THC…
Can the rules or bylaws of a state political party (Democratic, Republican, or other) override New Mexico state law or federal law?
No. Party bylaws and rules in New Mexico are subject to the laws that govern them: the Nonprofit Corporation Act, the Election Code, and the Campaign Reporting Act. Bylaws inconsistent with…
In New Mexico, can a county manager or county commission overrule the elected county treasurer on hiring a deputy or investing county money?
No on both counts. The treasurer (and other elected county officers) has exclusive statutory authority to hire and supervise their own deputies and staff. For investments, the treasurer makes the…
Can the New Mexico judiciary set its own paid-time-off rules that pay out unused leave more generously than the limits the Legislature set for state employees?
No. The judiciary's PTO rules, which let judicial employees cash out far more unused leave than statute allows for other state employees, conflict with the Legislature's payout caps in NMSA §§…
Are mutual domestic water consumers associations (MDWCAs) in New Mexico exempt from paying property taxes on the land and infrastructure they own?
Yes. The AG concluded that MDWCAs are 'municipal corporations' under Article VIII, Section 3 of the New Mexico Constitution and are therefore exempt from property tax. This reverses a 1968 AG…
If someone trespasses on my property or creates a nuisance, can I sue for the annoyance and inconvenience, or only for the dollar damage to the property?
In a private nuisance or trespass case in New Mexico, you can recover damages for annoyance, discomfort, and inconvenience even without proving the property lost market value. Pure emotional…
Can a New Mexico legislator who practices law serve as a special prosecutor in one criminal case?
Yes. The AG concluded that a private attorney serving in the Legislature may take an isolated, case-specific appointment as a special assistant district attorney without violating Article III,…
Does giving craft distillers a lower New Mexico liquor excise tax violate the dormant Commerce Clause?
No. New Mexico's lower excise tax for spirits made by craft distillers does not violate the dormant Commerce Clause because the craft-distiller license is open to both in-state and out-of-state…
Who owns the Santa Fe Plaza Obelisk, and where did it go after its removal?
The AG did not decide who owns the Obelisk. Ownership may lie with the City of Santa Fe under a 1901 federal land patent, but the AG said a court must resolve that factual question. The City…
Can a New Mexico educational-services cooperative use its joint-powers procurement agreement to fund a student scholarship program?
Based on the proposal described, the AG's office could not conclude that CES had authority to run the scholarship program. It said the proposed disbursement of funds was outside the cooperative…
Are New Mexico Livestock Board inspectors required to wear body cameras under state law?
No. New Mexico's body-worn camera mandate applies only to municipal police, county sheriffs, the State Police, and the Department of Public Safety. The Livestock Board is not on that list, so its…
Browse New Mexico opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in New Mexico are written by the New Mexico Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.