Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission, with full citations and source links on every page.
No Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Did a judge's serious accusations against opposing attorneys require recusal from their firms' cases?
Yes on these unusual facts. The Commission required recusal from pending cases involving either firm and from new cases where a firm member was initial counsel while related disciplinary proceedings…
Did a judge have to recuse from an insurer's cases because the judge's spouse sued the same insurer elsewhere?
Not merely because the cases shared an insurer and general subject. The Commission identified recusal grounds if the spouse worked on the same matter during their joint practice, had an affected…
Was a judge disqualified from city or county cases solely because the judge's son or his firm served as counsel for the city or county party but did not handle that case?
No, if the son did not participate in the particular case. The Commission listed additional grounds involving bias, affected interests, material-witness status, or case-related advice that could…
Did a $2,000 campaign contribution automatically require recusal, and did the JIC decide the statute's enforceability?
The Commission did not decide whether Ala. Code § 12-24-2 was enforceable or required reporting. Apart from any applicable statute, it found no automatic recusal from a contribution alone, while…
Could a district judge hear cases filed by the local Department of Human Resources when the judge's spouse directed that office?
No. Canon 3C(1)(d)(i) disqualified the judge because the spouse directed a party office. The opinion allowed remittal of that ground under Canon 3D, absent additional nonremittable impartiality grounds.
Could a circuit judge serve on a local bank board that approved substantial loans and paid directors?
Yes on the stated facts, subject to limits on prestige, finances, fiduciary service, and compensation. The Commission said bank-party cases require disqualification, subject to Canon 3D remittal,…
When should a judge recuse after lunch with a party during a pending case?
The Commission said a judge should recuse if the lunch was private, close to case proceedings, and another party or counsel expressed reasonable concern. The Commission distinguished private party…
Did a spouse's job as a public-school teacher itself bar a judge from hearing a case against school board members?
No. The Commission said ordinary employment alone did not require recusal, but bias, disputed-fact knowledge, an affected salary or job interest, material-witness status, or other direct involvement could.
Did an unsolicited ex parte allegation by a party's relative require the judge to recuse?
No on the stated facts. The judge had disclosed the incident, felt no bias, and saw no evidence that the party arranged it; the Commission said no further remedial action was required unless the…
Was a judge automatically disqualified when a lawyer appearing in court subleased space in the judge's building?
No on the stated sublease facts. The Commission required recusal if the judge knew a financial interest could be substantially affected by the case or other facts reasonably called impartiality into…
Could a sitting district judge use the title 'Judge' while campaigning for a circuit judgeship?
Yes, if the materials did not mislead voters into believing the candidate already held the office sought. The Commission approved an informative flyer but rejected a bumper sticker that could imply…
Did a district attorney's television endorsement disqualify the elected judge from local criminal cases?
No on the facts presented. The Commission said the endorsement alone did not require recusal, though additional circumstances could reasonably call the judge's impartiality into question.
Did opposing campaign activity and a defeated election opponent's appearance as counsel require recusal?
No on these facts. The Commission said support or opposition by parties and lawyers alone did not disqualify the judge after the election, absent personal bias or prejudice toward a party.
Could a part-time municipal judge serve on the municipality's employee grievance committee?
Yes on the stated facts. The Commission said the unpaid, nonlegal role would not interfere with court duties or impartiality, and the part-time judge was exempt from Canon 5G.
Could a judge resume a case after the party whose lawyer also represented the judge left the lawsuit?
Yes if the case was properly reassigned and no unusual circumstance continued to call impartiality into question. The Commission said the original ground for recusal ended when that party left the case.
Did an alleged acquaintance with a custody litigant's family disqualify the judge?
No on the facts provided. The judge knew only a casual acquaintance who might be related to the plaintiff and had once been listed as a witness; the Commission found no close relationship reasonably…
Could a judge join a host committee for benefit banquets supporting three ministry organizations?
No for the described committee. The Commission considered the duties together and identified concerns about impartiality, possible legal advice, and using judicial prestige to solicit funds or other…
Did paying respects at a murder victim's funeral disqualify the judge from the capital trial?
No on these facts. The judge had not known the officer, only briefly offered condolences, and had formed no view on guilt; the Commission nevertheless said the judge should disclose the attendance…
Did a litigant's separate lawsuit against the judge disqualify the judge from the litigant's pending cases?
No on the stated facts, during or after the collateral suit. The Commission required recusal only if the suit caused the judge to develop actual personal bias or prejudice toward the litigant.
Did judges' active opposition to a salary class action require recusal from unrelated cases involving the plaintiffs' lawyer?
Yes. The Commission treated the judges' filed opposition, affidavit, and strategy communications as personal involvement that reasonably questioned impartiality in unrelated matters involving…
Could a judge join the board of an environmental charity involved in recurring permit litigation?
No for this organization. The Commission found it would regularly engage in adversary court proceedings and was concerned that the judge's public board role could lend judicial prestige to its activities.
Could a judge hire a prominent local lawyer's mother-in-law as bailiff?
No where the hire would cause more than occasional recusal and moving the bailiff to another judge was impractical. The Commission tied the prohibition to recurring appearances by the lawyer's firm.
Could a part-time municipal judge defend a city police lieutenant in a federal civil-rights case?
No. The Commission said representing a city police supervisor would adversely reflect on the municipal judge's impartiality even though that officer and subordinates rarely appeared in the judge's court.
Could a retiring judge give a factual affidavit or interview about an unrecorded chambers conference in a former case?
Yes. The Commission found no Canon bar to a requested factual account or counsel interview before subpoenaed testimony, while distinguishing character testimony and noting that an inactive retired…
Must a judge recuse when counsel in another case represents the judge or an opposing party in a quo warranto action?
Yes. The Commission held that the judge’s personal role as relator required recusal from cases involving counsel for either side of that action, despite its public character.
Do a litigant’s reported threats against a judge require recusal in that litigant’s later case?
No, unless the reported threats actually caused the judge to develop personal bias or prejudice against the litigant.
Must a judge recuse from harassment charges against a police officer after deciding related resisting-arrest cases?
No, unless the judge formed personal bias or prejudice concerning a party. The Commission declined to decide who should appoint a special prosecutor.
Must a judge recuse because local lawyers, court staff, law enforcement personnel, or another judge are parties?
No, those roles alone did not disqualify the judge in this case. The Commission found no special relationship or other circumstance requiring recusal.
Do past employment by parties and earlier campaign contributions require a judge to recuse?
No on the facts presented. The Commission identified narrower exceptions for legal-adviser work on the dispute or a spouse’s participation in it, neither of which was stated.
May a judge accept a fee for legal work performed before taking office when payment becomes available nine years later?
Yes, where a fee agreement predated the judgeship. The Commission said its earlier opinions controlled even though payment arrived years after taking office.
May a judicial candidate retain a contribution from a later litigant or accept one from a current party?
Yes, under the described facts. The Commission required the cited statutory campaign filings but no additional disclosure of these contributions.
Must a judge who owns property recuse from a county storm-water fee challenge that could affect the judge’s assessments?
No on the stated facts. The Commission found no disqualifying financial interest and concluded the judge’s other interest could not be substantially affected.
May a judge seeking reelection describe types of cases a challenger has never handled?
Yes, if the statements are true, not misleading to a reasonable person, and preserve the dignity of judicial office.
Must a trial judge recuse from a postconviction petition after witnessing an incident and testifying about it in related civil litigation?
Not automatically. The Commission required recusal if the judge developed personal bias or was, or was likely to be, a material witness under its two-part test.
When must a judge recuse if an announced election opponent is a lawyer or party in the case?
The judge must recuse from cases filed after the opponent became counsel following the candidacy announcement and from any case with that opponent as a party; earlier pending cases require…
May a judge set a status call after informally hearing of a possible conflict in a case?
Yes. The Commission permitted a status call to determine whether the reported conflict actually existed.
Does a judge remain disqualified after the party whose lawyer created the conflict is dismissed from the case?
Usually no under these facts. The Commission allowed the judge to hear the case after dismissal unless unusual additional circumstances left a continuing impartiality concern.
May a judge serve on a committee recommending changes to Alabama domestic-violence law?
Yes. The Commission permitted service under Canon 4 if it did not interfere with judicial duties or cast doubt on impartiality.
Must a judge recuse from an insurance-policy case because the judge has a similar lawsuit against a different insurer?
No on the stated facts. Similar subject matter alone did not create a reasonable impartiality question, though personal bias or a substantially affected interest would require recusal.
May a judge write a requested letter to a judicial panel recommending an attorney for a circuit judgeship?
Yes. The Commission found a requested recommendation consistent with Canons 2C and 4 because a judge can contribute insight to judicial selection.
Did the alleged relationship between the judge and people associated with a party require recusal?
No on the facts supplied. The judge denied the claimed closeness and conduct, and the Commission found no relationship creating reasonable doubt about impartiality.
Is a party’s perception that a judge favors the opposing side enough to require recusal?
No. The shared opinion applies Canon 3C’s objective reasonable-person standard to the facts; a litigant’s perception alone was insufficient.
Does a litigant’s complaint to the Judicial Inquiry Commission by itself require the judge to recuse?
No. The shared opinion says a complaint alone does not disqualify the judge, though actual influence or special circumstances creating a reasonable impartiality concern could.
Did a prior related case, a complaint against the judge, perceived bias, and alleged social ties require recusal?
No on the facts provided. The Commission found no actual bias, special circumstances, or objectively reasonable impartiality concern from those allegations.
Must a judge recuse from a false-arrest suit because a defendant is a magistrate employed by the circuit clerk?
No, staff status alone was insufficient. The opinion required recusal for additional circumstances such as the judge’s appointment role, personal bias, or knowledge of disputed facts.
Must a judge return used computer equipment received lawfully from another state agency through the surplus-property program?
No. The Commission distinguished unsolicited state surplus property from the private-sector donations addressed in Opinion 97-682.
May a judge test new courtroom technology on an AOC committee funded by donated equipment?
Yes to committee service and testing. The Commission said the judge should not personally solicit or procure donated hardware, software, or training.
May circuit and district judges serve on a county work release board when the statute makes their positions ex officio?
Yes. The Commission permitted the statutory board roles, while saying the judges should keep individual participant supervision separate from judging.
May a recused Supreme Court justice vote to appoint a special justice in the same case?
Yes. The Commission characterized the appointment vote as a purely ministerial act and found no Canon bar despite the justice’s recusal from the merits.
When is a justice disqualified from deciding Commission membership while a complaint against that justice is pending?
The opinion permitted justices to decide the Court’s appointment authority generally, but required recusal after confirmed Commission notice of a pending complaint or a prior stated view on the merits.
May a judge sit on a nonprofit youth facility board while referring juveniles to that facility?
Yes on the additional facts described. The Commission permitted unpaid board service where the facility supplied needed rehabilitation and was not funded per referral; it overruled three earlier…
Must a judge recuse from a criminal case because the defendant’s aunt married the judge’s spouse’s first cousin?
No. The Commission found the defendant outside the fourth degree of relationship to the judge or spouse; this opinion superseded 97-666.
Do the judicial Canons cover part-time Court of the Judiciary members, and may they contribute to or solicit for other candidates?
Yes, Canon 7 covers those part-time judges. The Commission said it discouraged but did not prohibit contributions or solicitation for others, while barring personal solicitation for their own…
May a judge canvass church members for pledges in a stewardship campaign featuring the judge’s photograph and statement?
The Commission said Canon 5B discouraged judicial participation in charitable or religious fundraising, including the described canvassing role.
Must a judge recuse because an attorney in the case says they intend to run against the judge in the next election?
No. A stated intention to run did not alone create a reasonable impartiality question, though later facts or actual bias could require recusal.
May a judge serve as a bank director and receive normal board compensation?
Yes for an advisory role without day-to-day operations, with ordinary compensation. The opinion also addressed recusal in bank cases and the Canon 3D remittal procedure.
May a judge recommend lawyers for contract indigent-defense appointments before the judge’s court?
Yes. The Commission treated the recommendation as part of securing quality representation, subject to Canon 3B(4)’s merit, nepotism, and favoritism limits.
May an active retired judge serving part time consult for the county on jail programs?
Yes. The Commission permitted paid county consulting but said the judge must avoid assigned cases involving personal or ex parte knowledge gained in that role.
May a university name a chair for a living judge, and may the judge raise funds for it?
The chair could bear the judge’s name, but the Commission prohibited the judge from fundraising to endow it under the stated facts.
Must local judges recuse from a divorce case because one party is the circuit clerk’s child?
No. The family tie did not require disqualification, though the Commission said voluntary recusal would not violate the judges’ duty to sit.
Browse Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are advisory, not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.