Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission, with full citations and source links on every page.
No Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Must a judge recuse after inadvertently reading a party’s letter about a pending case or because the other party’s father serves on a legislative judiciary committee?
No on the stated facts. The judge promptly disclosed the letter, developed no personal bias from it, and the father’s legislative service did not reasonably call impartiality into question.
May a judge send a letter on official stationery encouraging local lawyers to join the State Bar’s Volunteer Lawyers Program?
Yes. The Commission concluded that the proposed letter as written was permitted because it sought professional service for a State Bar program and did not impair the appearance of impartiality.
Must a judge who established and presides over a drug court recuse from a case involving a major private donor to that program?
Yes on the stated facts. The Commission found the donor’s large contribution to a program the judge founded and managed would reasonably call the judge’s impartiality into question.
Is a circuit judge automatically disqualified when city police officers may testify and the judge’s spouse is the city’s mayor?
No. The relationship alone did not disqualify the judge in the described criminal matters, but direct involvement or an affected interest of the mayor could do so; the Commission said the judge…
Must a judge recuse after a party publishes a letter criticizing the local judicial system?
No on the stated facts, so long as the judge remains impartial and develops no personal bias from the letter. The Commission found the criticism indirect and no special circumstance calling…
May a judge accept an honorarium for conference participation when it equals the amount paid to nonjudge participants?
Yes on the submitted facts. The Commission found the activity and payment source permissible, the amount reasonable, and the payment no greater than what nonjudges received.
Must a judge recuse from an attorney’s cases when that attorney’s firm colleague represents an estate opposing the estate for which the judge is executor?
No on the stated facts. The Commission said the conflict tied to an attorney opposing the judge does not ordinarily extend to that attorney’s other firm members absent extraordinary circumstances.
Is a judge disqualified from a school board contract case because the judge’s daughter is a substitute teacher seeking permanent employment in the district?
No on the submitted facts. The Commission found no bias, affected interest, material-witness role, or other personal involvement of the daughter in the litigation.
How long must a judge recuse from cases involving an attorney representing the judge in separate litigation?
The disqualification continues throughout the representation, including inactive periods. It ordinarily ends when the matter or representation ends, subject to unusual circumstances that still…
May a judge chair a county children’s policy council when its executive director is married to a prosecutor appearing at the judge’s preliminary hearings?
Yes. The Commission found no conflict in continued council service, while saying the judge should avoid discussing with the director cases involving her prosecutor spouse.
Must a judge recuse from a case involving a party who opposed the judge in an election more than twelve years earlier?
No on the stated facts. The Commission distinguished a remote former opponent from a current election opponent and found no reasonable question about impartiality here.
May a judge chair a community corrections authority that operates a work release center used in sentencing?
Yes. The Commission found the judge’s interest in keeping the center available was shared with the public, and board service related to improving the administration of justice.
May a judge lead a fundraising charity and appear on its letterhead without a judicial title?
Yes on the stated arrangements. The Commission permitted service as president and name listing without judicial title, while restricting fundraising use of office prestige and investment advice.
Must a circuit judge recuse from a suit against a city after earlier substitute judging and unrelated civic work for that city?
No on the submitted facts. The Commission found neither possible earlier related judicial work nor the two unrelated civic assignments created a reasonable question about impartiality.
May a minister identify a judge’s office when introducing the judge’s report at a church service followed by an offering to the judge’s organization?
Yes in the described setting. The Commission found the report’s primary purpose was not fundraising and the minister’s identification was permissible, while cautioning against the judge personally…
Must a judge recuse because he represented a defendant’s former spouse in a divorce thirty years ago and imposed a maximum sentence in another case?
No on the submitted facts. The old divorce was unrelated to the current charges, and the earlier sentence alone did not create a reasonable question about impartiality.
Should a judge recuse from a case requiring assessment of the conduct and testimony of lawyers who regularly appear before him?
Yes on the stated facts. The Commission found the combined circumstances reasonably called impartiality into question, even if the judge felt he had no personal bias.
May a municipal judge serve on a family support center board when the court refers clients there?
Yes, under the stated facts: referrals did not affect center funding, and the judge would not supervise referred clients or staff. The judge could contribute money and suggest funding sources, but…
May a judge serve on a statutory Juvenile Justice Fund Committee?
Yes. The Commission permitted service because the facts did not suggest the judge had a connection with any entity that might receive money from the fund.
Is a mayor-appointed municipal judge disqualified from hearing an assault charge against a city employee?
No, on the stated facts, so long as the judge feels able to act impartially. The Commission found no reasonable question about impartiality merely from the appointment and the defendant’s city employment.
May a part-time municipal judge donate legal services to a charity?
Yes. The Commission held that the Canons did not prohibit a part-time municipal judge from donating legal services to a charitable organization.
Must a judge recuse because the defendant once worked with the judge’s brother?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found that the past acquaintance and occasional later contact did not reasonably call the judge’s impartiality into question.
May a bar foundation fund court staff salaries through reimbursement to the courts?
Yes, on the stated facts. The Commission permitted the proposal because the funds came from a charitable foundation with varied donors, and judges and judicial employees would not know whether any…
Does county funding of court staff disqualify judges from cases that could cost the county money?
No, absent actual bias or prejudice. The Commission held that county funding of salaries for court employees did not by itself disqualify judges from cases that could impose serious financial loss…
May a local bar association pay a judge's research assistant after a budget cut?
No. The Commission concluded that local bar payment of the assistant's salary, directly or through the Administrative Office of Courts, would raise reasonable questions about impartiality in cases…
Can a judge hear a class action after the judge's estate and relatives are excluded from the class?
Only if neither the estate nor the judge's cousins retain an interest that may be substantially affected by the case. The Commission held that exclusion from the class alone does not remove…
May a district judge ask the county commission to create a merit position for a sheriff's chaplain?
No. The Commission held that the judge could neither sign nor present the proposed request to the county commission.
Would a district attorney-funded courthouse employee disqualify judges from prosecution cases?
Yes, if the district attorney's office pays part of the shared employee's salary. The Commission found that a joint employee would create a reasonable question about judicial impartiality in…
May an Alabama judge perform legal duties as a military judge advocate while on active duty?
Yes. The Commission held that active-duty service as a judge advocate general in the United States military did not violate Alabama Canon 5F.
May a family court judge join a committee supporting a tax-related constitutional amendment?
Yes, if the judge's participation remains consistent with Canons 4, 5B and 7A(1). The Commission made its approval conditional on the scope and manner of participation.
Must a judge recuse when a former law clerk joins a lawyer's firm in a related case?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found no reasonable basis to question the judge's impartiality, but said it would be appropriate to bring Rule 1.12 to the attorneys' attention.
May a Court of the Judiciary judge serve on bank and university boards?
Yes, on the stated facts. The Commission permitted the bank board service subject to Canons 2C and 5C, and the university board service subject to Canon 5B.
Must a retired judge recuse when a lawyer's firm also appears in an unrelated mediation he handles?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found no reasonable basis to question impartiality, but recommended disclosure to the parties if the judge accepted the case assignment.
Can parties waive recusal when their lawyer regularly acts as the judge's appointed referee?
No. The Commission held the judge disqualified because the lawyer regularly assisted him as an appointed child-support referee; the resulting Canon 3C(1) disqualification could not be remitted under…
Must a judge recuse from a civil case against a prosecutor who handles most of the judge's criminal docket?
Yes, on these facts. The Commission found that the prosecutor's handling of about 85% of the judge's criminal docket, together with her bringing the civil case to his attention, reasonably called…
Does a former partner's consultation with a party disqualify the judge from that party's case?
It depends on whether the consultation established an attorney-client relationship. Without one, the judge was not disqualified; if one arose and privilege attached, the Commission held that recusal…
May a judge hear an inmate's post-trial request after the judge's nephew represented the inmate at trial?
Yes, if the nephew's representation has ended and no special circumstance continues to question impartiality. An issue the nephew litigated or a question about his representation would require recusal.
Must a judge recuse when a lawyer from the judge's brother's firm appears?
Not merely because the lawyers share a firm. The judge is disqualified if he knows the brother has an interest that could be substantially affected by the case or other facts reasonably question…
May a circuit judge retain an official court reporter after marrying her?
No, where Alabama Code § 12-17-270 applies. The Commission found that the statute barred the spouse's continued service as the judge's court reporter despite her appointment before the marriage.
Must a judge recuse when a lawyer appearing in court subleases space in the judge's building?
Not on the stated sublease alone. The Commission required recusal if the judge knew his financial interests could be substantially affected by the case or other circumstances reasonably questioned…
May a judge chair an American Heart Association fund-raising campaign?
The Canons discouraged but did not prohibit the proposed chairmanship. The Commission conditioned participation on compliance with Canons 1, 2 and 5, including limits on using judicial prestige to…
May a bank-director judge hear unrelated cases involving a lawyer suing the bank?
It depends on the circumstances when the judge is not a defendant: the Commission called for disclosure and a facts-based recusal decision if requested. If the judge is named a defendant in the bank…
May a judge hear a case handled by another lawyer in the appointed referee's firm?
Yes, if the referee has not acted as a lawyer in that case. The Commission said firm membership alone did not create the close-trust concern, but the referee's legal work on the case would require recusal.
Must a judge recuse from a murder case after representing the victim's mother in a related custody case?
Yes. The Commission held that the custody action and murder prosecution involved the same matter in controversy under Canon 3C(1)(b), given their common facts about the victim's death.
May a juvenile judge serve on a foster and adoptive parents association board?
Yes, if the service complies with Canon 5B. The Commission said the judge must account for activities that might suggest a predisposition in cases before him or interfere with judicial duties.
May a judge accept lawyers' event tickets and hear a case involving his financial advisor?
A ticket from a lawyer with a case pending before the judge was impermissible; without a pending case, the circumstances controlled. The judge was disqualified from the case involving his principal…
May judges select a court-ordered parenting provider who also testifies in criminal cases?
Yes, if an objective reason supports sole selection over any competing provider. The Commission also held that the provider's appearances as a prosecuting witness did not by themselves disqualify…
Can a judge hear a royalty class action when he administers an estate and trust with interests in it?
The judge was disqualified, even if he resigned as executor and trustee, because his cousins' affected interests remained. Canon 3D allowed remittal only through written agreements; after class…
May a judge buy property involved in a case he decided several years earlier?
Yes, on the stated facts. The Commission found no adverse appearance, exploitation of office, or use of information acquired judicially, subject to Canons 5C(1) and 5C(6).
May a judge acting as a volunteer state militia judge advocate give legal advice to another member?
No. The Commission held that Alabama Canon 5F prohibited the judge from giving a legal opinion about State Defense Force business to another member.
May a judge serving on a bank board solicit customers for the bank?
No. The Commission held that business calls to recruit or retain bank customers would use judicial prestige to advance the bank and exploit the judicial position.
Must a judge recuse from a negligence case against the YMCA branch his family uses?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found that ordinary YMCA membership did not reasonably question impartiality, but said the judge should disclose the memberships to the parties.
Must a judge recuse when a lawyer representing his uncle's estate appears in an unrelated case?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found no disqualification where the estate lawyer neither represented the judge nor opposed him in a contested estate matter.
Must a judge recuse from cases involving lawyers or a store connected to his adult child's suits?
No, on the stated facts. The Commission found no reasonable question about impartiality from the child's lawyer's spouse or associates appearing, or from unrelated cases involving the store that…
May a judge hear malpractice cases against a spouse's or child's current doctor?
No, in the ongoing doctor-patient relationships presented. The Commission held both judges disqualified, said the general Canon 3C(1) ground could not be remitted, and said disqualified judges could…
May a former DHR attorney serving as judge hear later cases involving the same children or families?
The judge may hear unrelated DHR matters absent bias or disputed-fact knowledge. If he previously filed a DHR petition for the child or family, the Commission required recusal unless the new case…
May a judge hear a criminal case prosecuted by the judge's judicial assistant's spouse?
No. The Commission found the judge disqualified from cases prosecuted by that spouse, but said the disqualification did not extend to cases prosecuted by other members of the district attorney's office.
Must a judge recuse when a party is represented by the judge's brother-in-law?
Yes, unless the disqualification is remitted under Canon 3D. After the judge discloses the relationship on the record, every party and lawyer must independently agree in writing that it is…
May a part-time municipal judge hear a case defended by a lawyer in another judge's law firm?
No. The Commission held that a part-time municipal judge was disqualified when defense counsel practiced in the firm of another part-time judge on the same court, and that the disqualification could…
May an appellate judge serve on a committee planning a domestic violence fatality review team?
Yes, subject to Canon 5B's limits. The Commission permitted service on the temporary, nongovernmental steering committee described, but said the judge would have to resign if its activities made it…
Browse Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are advisory, not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.