Virginia State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Virginia, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Virginia rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Were free meals for convenience-store employees exempt when the stores also operated fast-food restaurants?
Virginia removed the tax from the 2003-2006 audit because the company reasonably relied on guidance from earlier audits. Going forward, however, all free employee meals were taxable because employees …
Were natural-gas compressor agreements taxable leases, and were compressor transfers in a business reorganization exempt?
The agreement was a taxable equipment lease because furnishing the compressor was its true object; start-up, transport, installation, and maintenance supported that lease. The compressor transfers to …
Could Virginia consolidate an intangible holding company with its affiliated group when royalty and loan arrangements improperly reduced Virginia income?
Yes. Virginia found that the intangible holding company had not shown sufficient economic substance and that royalties, loans, uncompensated services, and trademark-value contributions were not handle…
Could a nonprofit continuing care community exempt purchases for unlicensed independent-living cottages under Virginia's new nonprofit rules?
Yes. After the old licensed-nursing-home exemption expired, the community could exempt tangible personal property used throughout the nonprofit—including food and supplies for unlicensed cottages—if i…
Did clarified facts overturn Virginia's treatment of a male S-corporation shareholder's lump-sum payment after he moved out of state?
No. Virginia corrected factual statements from the earlier determination but found that the clarifications did not change the tax result. The Department concluded that the December lump sum was not su…
Did clarified facts overturn Virginia's treatment of an S-corporation lump-sum payment received after the shareholder moved out of Virginia?
No. Virginia corrected factual statements from the earlier determination but found that the clarifications did not change the tax result. The Department concluded that the December lump sum was not su…
Did a taxpayer abandon Virginia domicile by taking long-term foreign jobs even though his wife, driver's license, vehicle, and voting ties remained in Virginia?
Yes. Long-term or indefinite foreign employment, established homes abroad, foreign licenses, a vehicle, and a citizenship application showed abandonment of Virginia domicile beginning in 2002. The exp…
Which packaging, engineering, vendor-support, and refurbishment costs of a food manufacturer were subject to Virginia local machinery-and-tools tax?
Virginia treated cartoning equipment, engineering-related assets, and most vendor installation support as taxable machinery and tools used in manufacturing. Case-packing equipment used only to prepare…
Could a multistate salon operator remove disputed purchases and a 20% amnesty penalty from a Virginia sales-and-use-tax audit?
Only with supporting records, and the amnesty penalty remained valid. Virginia allowed 60 days to produce invoices, contracts, delivery evidence, allocation records, and proof of electronic software d…
Which cardiology and radiology products qualified for Virginia's medical-equipment sales-tax exemptions?
Virginia exempted the listed catheters and specifically related supplies, plus compression stockings that met all four durable-medical-equipment criteria. Two syringes were exempt only when dispensed …
What had Northern Virginia repair providers and customers do after the regional motor-vehicle repair tax was invalidated in 2008?
Providers had to stop collecting the repair tax as of February 29, 2008, remit all amounts collected through February and any mistakenly collected in March, and file the February return by May 6, 2008…
Were bags, pallets, and containers used by a Virginia export-packaging service exempt under the foreign-commerce exemption?
No. The foreign-commerce exemption applied to qualifying sales of tangible personal property, but the taxpayer provided packaging services rather than selling the bags, pallets, and container material…
Did a timely notice of intent preserve a Virginia corporate-income-tax appeal when the complete appeal arrived after 90 days?
No. The taxpayer filed a notice of intent before the January 14, 2008 deadline, but that notice did not fully state the grounds needed for an informed determination. The complete appeal arrived Februa…
Did the Hampton Roads repair and motor-vehicle fuel taxes scheduled for May 1, 2008 ever take effect?
No. After the Supreme Court of Virginia held the House Bill 3202 regional-tax provisions unconstitutional, the Hampton Roads repair and motor-vehicle fuel taxes scheduled for May 1, 2008 did not take …
What Virginia tax underpayment and refund interest rates applied during the second quarter of 2008?
Virginia's April 1-June 30, 2008 rate was 8% for tax underpayments and 8% for overpayments. The federal rates were 6%, and Va. Code § 58.1-15 added two percentage points. The 8% underpayment rate also…
Was a Virginia sales-tax appeal timely when the letter was dated on the deadline but the fax arrived one week later?
No. Holiday rules moved the deadline to January 2, 2008, but a faxed appeal had to be received by that date. The Department received it January 9, so the appeal was barred. Virginia did not reach the …
How did Virginia classify a wireless LLC for BPOL tax when an FCC-licensed affiliate supplied the licenses needed to operate?
Virginia treated the wireless LLC as a telephone company because its management agreement with an FCC-licensed sister affiliate effectively supplied the licenses needed to operate. Retail-store receip…
What did Northern Virginia repair providers have to do immediately after the regional repair tax was invalidated?
They had to stop collecting the Northern Virginia motor-vehicle repair labor and services tax immediately on February 29, 2008. The ruling did not affect the separate motor-vehicle fuel sales tax in t…
Did filing Virginia's Administrative Appeal Form preserve an appeal when the taxpayer never supplied complete grounds and authority?
No. The filed form did not fully identify the alleged errors, relevant facts, remedy, and legal authority required for a complete administrative appeal. Virginia contacted the representative and allow…
Would Virginia accept a retailer's electronic multipurpose exemption certificate and electronic customer signature?
Not as presented. Virginia was willing to accept an electronic resale certificate with an electronic signature if it captured all information and statements required by Form ST-10. The retailer's gene…
Were software license fees exempt when the vendor remotely installed every application and upgrade and emailed the documentation?
Yes. Although the agreement did not require a delivery method, emails showed that the vendor logged directly into the taxpayer's server to install every application and upgrade and sent the documentat…
Could a retail chain remove a large untaxed sale from Virginia's audit sample when it lacked a valid exemption certificate?
No. The retailer lacked a valid exemption certificate or other support for the untaxed sale, and the transaction appeared consistent with its normal business. A large dollar amount or large effect on …
Did a $40 federal digital-to-analog converter-box coupon reduce the box's taxable sales price in Virginia?
No. Because the federal government reimbursed the retailer for the $40 coupon, the retailer still received the full price. Virginia treated the coupon like a manufacturer coupon and taxed the cash plu…
What happened to the Hampton Roads repair and fuel taxes after their start date was postponed from April to May 2008?
The bulletin originally moved the taxes' start from April 1 to May 1, 2008 to satisfy a 60-day notice period, with first returns due June 20. But the official source later added that the Supreme Court…
How did Virginia's move to December 31, 2007 federal conformity affect 2007 income-tax returns?
Virginia conformed to federal tax law as of December 31, 2007 for tax years beginning in 2007, except it still disallowed specified bonus depreciation and five-year carrybacks of 2001 or 2002 net oper…
What did Virginia's January 2008 Motor Vehicle Fuel Sales Tax guidelines require, and which part was later invalidated?
These historical guidelines explained a 2% retail fuel sales tax, including tax base, exemptions, refunds, registration, monthly returns, collection, dealer discounts, penalties, records, and appeals.…
Did incomplete, outdated, or product-mismatched exemption certificates protect a Virginia hardware retailer from sales tax?
No. Virginia found that the retailer failed to exercise reasonable care because certificates were incomplete or outdated and often did not cover the products sold. Manufacturing certificates used for …
Did moving out of Virginia before an S corporation sold its assets keep the entire capital gain outside Virginia tax?
No. The couple moved in April 2004 and the S corporation sold its assets in September, but the corporation remained in operation for the entire year. Virginia required the pass-through capital gain to…
Which out-of-state subsidiaries belonged in a Virginia consolidated return, and could the group use alternative apportionment?
Virginia removed Corporations A and C because the evidence showed no positive Virginia apportionment factor or taxable Virginia activity. Corporation B had a Virginia office, significant property and …
When could church-operated day-care centers qualify for Virginia's charitable nonprofit BPOL exemption?
A church day-care center could qualify if it met the federal § 501(c)(3) standards and furthered the church's exempt purpose, with BPOL still possible on unrelated business income. Church A had strong…
Did two-year convertible notes or the stock received on conversion qualify for Virginia's equity and subordinated-debt investment credit?
No. The notes had to convert or be redeemed within two years, so they could not satisfy the credit's three-year holding requirement for convertible subordinated debt. The common stock received on conv…
Could a Virginia resident remove IRS-reported trucking income by stating that another person owned the business?
No. The taxpayer said her involvement with the other person's trucking business ended in 2001, but she did not prove that the 2003 IRS information or Virginia assessment was wrong. Because Virginia be…
Did Virginia properly assess additional tax when taxpayers failed to report final IRS changes to their federal income?
Yes. Virginia law required the taxpayers to report final IRS changes within one year. When they did not file amended Virginia returns or otherwise report the changes, the Department could assess from …
Were amusement tickets bundled with hotel reservations and sod installed by an out-of-state contractor taxable to the Virginia taxpayer?
No on both audited items. The amusement-ticket and hotel prices were set independently, so the tickets were not an integral lodging charge even though sold in one package; Virginia recommended separat…
Could a Virginia resident avoid filing by claiming the Department unlawfully received insufficient IRS income information?
No. The Tax Commissioner-signed IRS exchange agreement satisfied the federal written-request requirement, and IRS data showing federal adjusted gross income supplied a factual basis for the assessment…
Did a telecommunications reseller with no Virginia presence owe Virginia income, retail sales, or communications tax on calls routed through a supplier?
No corporate-income or retail-sales-tax nexus arose because the reseller had no Virginia property, payroll, sales, physical presence, customers, or dealer activity. The supplier-to-reseller communicat…
When did Virginia's 2008 guidelines classify machinery and tools as idle and exempt from local machinery-and-tools tax?
Machinery and tools were classified as exempt intangible property when they had been continuously unused for at least one year before tax day, were unused on tax day, and had no reasonable prospect of…
Did all related-party royalties escape Virginia's add-back merely because affiliates reported the gross royalties in other states?
No. The exception covered only the portion of royalty payments corresponding to the affiliate income actually apportioned and subjected to net-income or capital tax in another state. Reporting the gro…
Was a former officer personally liable for a corporation's January-June 2005 delinquent Virginia withholding taxes?
No. The former officer documented that the president, not he, controlled payment of corporate taxes, and the first-quarter payroll did not list him as an officer or employee. Because the evidence show…
Did a nonresident owe Virginia tax on dividends and bond interest reported to a Virginia mailing address?
No. The taxpayer lived in another state, and her stock dividends and bond interest were not from intangibles used in a Virginia business. Her rental property was outside Virginia, and Social Security …
Was a nonresident decedent's LLC membership taxable by Virginia merely because the LLC owned Virginia real estate?
No. Virginia law treated the decedent's LLC membership as personal, intangible property located in her state of residence. The estate owned the LLC interest, not the Virginia real estate held by the L…
Were per-foot patent and trademark royalties taxable when tied to a contractor's purchases and use of gutter coil?
Yes. The distributor agreement tied the licenses, required material purchases, royalty discount, and weekly royalty invoices directly to the coil and accessories used or sold. The royalty was an incre…
What Virginia tax underpayment and refund interest rates applied during the first quarter of 2008?
Virginia's January 1-March 31, 2008 rate was 9% for tax underpayments and 9% for overpayments. The federal rates were 7%, and Virginia added two percentage points. For calendar-year 2007 estimated-tax…
How did Virginia coordinate its long-term care insurance credit and deduction with the federal medical-expense deduction under 2006 law?
Virginia allowed taxpayers to allocate premium dollars among the federal deduction, Virginia credit, and Virginia deduction, but not to use the same dollars twice. Only premiums actually absorbed by t…
Could a city require a second BPOL license when a growing service business moved employees to a second city location?
Yes. The second office conducted regular, continuous, nonancillary service activity for more than 30 days, making it a separate definite place of business. The city could require a second license and …
Was electronic catalog data conversion manufacturing for BPOL tax, and could a county default to payroll to situs receipts?
Virginia classified the county operation as a business service, not manufacturing, because it reformatted and indexed data without substantially changing its character and did not sell goods at wholes…
Could a Virginia partner claim resident credits for Arizona and California tax paid through unified nonresident partnership returns?
Yes. Arizona and California generally offered reciprocal individual credits, but their unified nonresident returns did not give the partnership or partners a credit for tax paid elsewhere. The Virgini…
Could a partnership compute a Virginia combined nonresident return separately for each partner instead of on aggregated income?
No. Filing a combined nonresident return was an elective administrative privilege subject to the Tax Commissioner's terms. Those terms required applying Virginia's graduated individual rates to the pa…
Did checks paid to another state's revenue department prove that a taxpayer was not a Virginia resident?
No. Checks sent to another state's revenue department could reflect nonresident tax and did not establish domicile. Virginia asked for evidence bearing on residence, employment, spouse, property, vehi…
Did merchant-seaman protections exempt a nonresident NOAA survey technician from Virginia tax on ship-related work?
No. Virginia found that a scientific survey technician on an oceanographic research vessel was not a seaman covered by 46 U.S.C. § 11108. Because she planned surveys, maintained and calibrated equipme…
Did lumber-mill catwalks, supports, measuring computers, cleanup equipment, ATVs, and tractors qualify for Virginia production exemptions?
No. Virginia held that catwalk material and structural supports were facilitative rather than direct production items; the field computer and log rulers served payment, inventory, and recordkeeping; t…
Which software sales qualified as custom programs or direct manufacturing equipment in Virginia?
Virginia removed Customer One's programs because extensive customer-specific programming made them custom software despite initial hopes for broader sales. Customer Two's software remained taxable bec…
Could a Virginia land-preservation tax credit be transferred before the Department issued it, contingent on later approval?
No. Under the 2006 statutory changes analyzed in the ruling, the donor did not possess a land-preservation credit until the Department issued it. A transfer could occur only after issuance, and the tr…
Could a revocable trust claim Virginia's Riparian Forest Buffer Protection for Waterways Credit under the law analyzed in P.D. 07-200?
No. Under the Virginia statutes analyzed in 2007, a trust was not an eligible corporation, individual, partnership, or S corporation and therefore could not claim the Riparian Forest Buffer Protection…
Did a merchant mariner who separated from his spouse and established ties to a U.S. territory remain a Virginia domiciliary resident?
No. Considering all the circumstances, Virginia found that the merchant mariner abandoned his Virginia domicile and established a domicile outside Virginia. His assessments for 2003 and 2004 were abat…
Could a Virginia nonprofit high-school orchestra buy and resell kitchen products tax-free for a school fundraiser?
Yes. Because the nonprofit school orchestra had obtained a Virginia sales-and-use-tax exemption certificate, it could buy and resell the company's products without paying or collecting tax, provided t…
Could a Virginia corporate group allocate passive partnership investment income and exclude construction-service sales from Virginia's sales-factor numerator?
Yes, in part. Virginia allowed the non-Virginia group members to allocate the partnership's passive interest and capital-gain income to their commercial domicile, while the Virginia-domiciled member's…
Did the Richmond Circuit Court uphold Virginia sales-tax successor liability against GFT, Inc. in P.D. 07-210?
Yes. The Richmond Circuit Court found GFT, Inc. was the successor to Tavern at Great Falls, LLC under Va. Code § 58.1-629, held that the Department's assessment procedures were not arbitrary and capri…
Did a petroleum marketer have a definite place of business, and therefore BPOL liability, at a third party's city terminal?
No. Virginia found that the petroleum marketer neither leased terminal facilities nor maintained a definite place of business in the city. Its throughput agreement bought temporary commingled storage …
Could a corporation retroactively use a 2002 overpayment credited to 2003 estimated tax to avoid interest on a later 2002 deficiency?
No. Once the corporation directed its 2002 overpayment to 2003 estimated tax, it became a 2003 payment and could not retroactively satisfy a later 2002 deficiency. Interest ran until a 2003 return ove…
Browse Virginia rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Virginia's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.