Virginia State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Virginia, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Virginia rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
When a Virginia dealer or marketplace facilitator sells to a government agency, what does it need to accept the ST-12 exemption certificate and not charge sales tax?
A Virginia dealer can sell tax-free to a federal, state, or local government buyer once it has EITHER a required official purchase order paid from public funds OR a properly completed, signed Form ST-…
My business was audited for sales and use tax and hit with an estimated assessment I think is arbitrary. Can Virginia estimate my tax if my records are incomplete, and are bank and credit-card statements enough proof?
The assessment was upheld -- Virginia can estimate your tax when your records are incomplete. This taxpayer was a Virginia "consuming contractor" audited for sales and use tax over March 2017 through …
Does the sales-and-use-tax research-and-development exemption cover a testing lab's purchases -- including common hardware -- or is its 'pass/fail' testing just non-exempt quality control?
The taxpayer won -- a Richmond Circuit Court held the testing lab's purchases were exempt research and development, and ordered the $75,041.41 assessment corrected with a refund plus interest. E-Labs,…
My corporation owes back sales tax, litter tax, and withholding tax from years after I sold my ownership stake and resigned — can the Department come after me personally for it?
No — because the Taxpayer had already sold 95% of the company and resigned as an officer, director, and employee well before the tax periods the corporation failed to pay, the Department found he wasn…
My company can't locate original invoices for some equipment purchases -- including purchases from our own parent company -- will Virginia accept purchase orders and a spreadsheet instead to prove a sales tax refund claim?
Not on their own -- Virginia requires documentation that ties each specific transaction to proof of payment, and a purchase order or spreadsheet summary isn't a substitute for an actual invoice. A Vir…
We buy medical devices and implants in bulk from manufacturers and use them per a doctor's prescription for surgery -- does that qualify for Virginia's durable medical equipment sales tax exemption without a signed consignment contract?
Not without documented proof -- generic vendor letters simply asserting a 'consignment' relationship aren't enough; Virginia requires actual contracts or agreements clearly showing no money changed ha…
I filed an amended Virginia sales tax return claiming a refund a little while after the original filing deadline -- can the Department still deny it purely for being late?
Yes -- Virginia's three-year deadline to claim a sales tax refund runs from the original return's due date, and it is enforced strictly with no grace period. A company that provides computer and data …
We rent out an event venue for one lump-sum price that includes tables and chairs -- can we get Virginia to reconsider a ruling that our whole rental fee is taxable, by arguing the space itself is a nontaxable service?
No -- a request for reconsideration only succeeds if it meets one of four specific, narrow grounds, and simply repeating an argument the Department already rejected isn't one of them. An event venue c…
The Department estimated my company's sales tax liability because we never filed returns, and the estimate doesn't match our point-of-sale records -- can we get it corrected without ever filing the actual returns?
No -- simply asserting that the Department's estimate doesn't match your own records isn't enough; you have to actually file the missing returns with supporting documentation to displace an estimated …
We use kiln decking to dry raw lumber before it's processed, and a computerized picture tally system to track lumber -- do either qualify for Virginia's manufacturing sales tax exemption?
No -- neither item qualified, because Virginia's manufacturing exemption only covers equipment that is an indispensable, immediate part of actual production, not equipment used before production start…
I bought sterling silver flatware from an online auction -- does it qualify for Virginia's sales tax exemption for silver bullion?
No -- Virginia's precious-metal bullion exemption requires the item's sales price to fluctuate based solely on the market price of the underlying metal, and an auction purchase of silver flatware does…
We sell and install security systems, cabling, and home audio-visual equipment for homebuilders -- do we owe sales tax on the equipment, or does it become part of the house and become the homebuilder's tax burden instead?
It depends on whether the equipment is physically annexed to the house, essential to its use, and intended to become a permanent part of it -- a three-part legal test that hardwired security systems c…
My dealership sells optional vehicle service contracts on behalf of another company that actually does the repairs, and an insurance company backs the contracts -- who's responsible for collecting Virginia sales tax, and does the insurance backing make it exempt?
The dealer that actually sells the contract to the customer -- not the company backing it or performing the repairs -- is the one responsible for collecting and remitting sales tax, on half the total …
I submitted an offer in compromise instead of a formal appeal after my sales tax audit assessment -- when the offer was rejected years later, can I still appeal the original assessment?
No -- submitting an offer in compromise instead of a formal administrative appeal doesn't stop or extend Virginia's 90-day deadline to appeal the underlying assessment, and the clock isn't restarted b…
I got a 'Detail Bill Information' notice a month after my original assessment -- does that give me a fresh 90 days to appeal?
No -- only the Department's official "Notice of Assessment" starts the 90-day appeal clock; a later document like a "Detail Bill Information" notice, which just restates a balance already due, does no…
My auditor estimated my sales tax assessment because I couldn't provide records during the pandemic -- can I still submit the documentation now to get the assessment corrected?
Yes, generally -- if you failed to provide requested records during a sales tax audit (here, because of pandemic-related disruptions) and the Department estimated your assessment using the best inform…
I print and mail direct-mail advertising to people in Virginia from out of state -- do I have to charge Virginia sales tax on that?
It depends on who your customer actually is. Virginia exempts "advertising" -- including direct mail -- from retail sales and use tax, and treats an advertising business as the user/consumer (not rese…
My auto repair shops bill customers a lump sum for parts and labor, and I also thought accepting a government ID or license plate proved a sale to a government customer was tax-exempt -- why did my audit assessment include both?
Two different results for two different issues. A multi-state vehicle repair shop was audited and assessed sales tax on lump-sum-billed invoices (where parts and labor charges weren't separately state…
My company got assessed sales tax because we couldn't produce a valid exemption certificate at the time of an audit -- can we still fix it with certificates or invoices we gather afterward?
Partially -- a certificate gathered after the sale can still work if the Department can independently verify the customer was actually entitled to the exemption, but it only covers invoices dated on o…
I was only a minority shareholder when my corporation fell behind on its taxes, then later became the sole owner -- can Virginia hold me personally liable for taxes from before I owned the whole company?
It depends on when you actually became a 'responsible officer' under Virginia's four-part legal test -- and the answer can split by time period for the same person. A Virginia corporation was assessed…
My cold storage business freezes and chills customers' food products before shipping them out -- does my refrigeration equipment qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing and processing sales tax exemption?
No -- a business whose predominant activity is refrigerated storage, not manufacturing, doesn't qualify, even if it also does some freezing. A Virginia cold storage company asked whether an industrial…
My cold storage business freezes and chills customers' food products before shipping them out -- does my refrigeration equipment qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing and processing sales tax exemption?
No -- a business whose predominant activity is refrigerated storage, not manufacturing, doesn't qualify, even if it also does some freezing. This ruling is Virginia's word-for-word duplicate publicati…
My use tax compliance ratio came out to 0% on a second sales tax audit because of heavy employee turnover during the audit period -- does that turnover excuse the penalty?
No -- employee turnover doesn't excuse a mandatory compliance penalty, though the underlying tax bill itself could still be reduced with the right paperwork. A utility inspection services company was …
My conference center's all-inclusive room-and-meal package got hit with use tax on food purchases and employee meals, my vendor's custom-table charge got taxed a second time, and the Department extended my audit period past three years -- which of these can I actually fight?
Mixed result across several issues -- the center lost on the substance of most items but won a real procedural fight over how far back (and forward) the audit could reach. A Virginia conference center…
My company sells a bundled smart-home system -- remote video, door locks, lights, controlled through our app and network -- along with our basic monitored alarm service. Is the whole bundled charge taxable as equipment, or exempt as a service?
A nontaxable service -- because customers were really paying for ongoing remote control and monitoring capability, not just to own the hardware. A security company's optional smart-home-style add-on s…
My company took title to equipment outside Virginia through an affiliate transfer, and calls it a corporate reorganization or a gift -- can Virginia still assess use tax once the equipment gets used here?
Yes. A marine cargo terminal operator owed Virginia use tax on ship-to-shore cranes because it took actual possession and began using them at the Virginia port once the cranes were erected, tested, an…
My company repairs and replaces command/communications/surveillance systems on Navy ships, including cabling and racks -- does that make me a retailer who can buy the parts tax-exempt for resale, or a consuming contractor who owes tax on them?
A retailer, not a consuming contractor -- meaning the contractor can buy the equipment and materials tax-exempt for resale to the government. A company contracts with the U.S. Navy to repair and repla…
The Department's auditor removed offsetting credit memos from my sales tax audit sample without a signed sampling agreement -- does that make the sample inflated and invalid?
No -- removing the offsetting invoice/credit-memo pairs and leaving the remaining unmatched credits out of the sample followed the Department's established, previously-published sampling policy, and t…
A vendor charged us sales tax on data center backup batteries because they were first delivered to a storage facility instead of straight to our data center -- does that disqualify the batteries from Virginia's data center exemption?
No -- delivering batteries to a storage facility first, rather than straight to the data center, doesn't disqualify them from Virginia's data center sales and use tax exemption. A battery manufacturer…
My business claims its supply purchases were tax-exempt for resale and its vendor invoices were labor-only -- but I don't have great paperwork proving it. Does the assessment still get upheld?
Yes, the assessment was upheld -- without adequate records, a business can't prove its purchases actually qualified for the resale exemption or the labor-only services exemption. A seasonal frozen yog…
My vendors told me by letter and email that our software was delivered electronically, not on a disc -- is that enough to get it exempted from a Virginia use tax audit assessment?
No -- a vendor's letter or email saying software was delivered electronically, by itself, isn't enough proof to win the exemption; you need contemporaneous sales documentation that expressly certifies…
My business claims its supply purchases were tax-exempt for resale and its vendor invoices were labor-only -- but I don't have great paperwork proving it. Does the assessment still get upheld?
Yes, the assessment was upheld -- without adequate records, a business can't prove its purchases actually qualified for the resale exemption or the labor-only services exemption. A seasonal frozen yog…
The Tobacco Unit rejected updated exemption certificates I submitted with my appeal, and I never got to discuss the audit findings directly with the auditor -- what happens now?
The case wasn't resolved on the merits yet -- it was sent back to the Tobacco Unit audit staff to actually review the new documentation using the Department's standard verification procedure, and then…
My business has to make Virginia's 'accelerated sales tax payment' in June -- how is it calculated, when is it due, and can I get a waiver?
Virginia requires dealers whose taxable sales and/or purchases met a set threshold in the prior fiscal year ($10.0 million for the payment due in June 2021 onward, confirmed by the 2021 Appropriation …
What does Virginia Ruling of the Tax Commissioner P.D. 20-185 conclude about Exemption: Occasional Sale - Sale or Exchange of Substantially All Assets of a Division of a Business (Criteria), Medical Practice?
No exemption: the Tax Commissioner upheld the use tax assessment because the Taxpayer failed to show the purchased oral surgery practice was a separate and distinct division of the Seller's larger hea…
What does Virginia Ruling of the Tax Commissioner P.D. 20-174 conclude about Dealer: Vehicle Repair Administration: Refund - Taxes Paid On Inventory, Statute of Limitations?
Partial win: the Tax Commissioner agreed to credit the taxpayer for sales tax it had erroneously paid to vendors on items later assessed as retail sales, but only for amounts the taxpayer documents it…
State Tax Ruling
No. The Virginia Tax Commissioner ruled that an Indian Tribe is not exempt from Virginia retail sales and use tax on purchases occurring off its reservation, even when the items are for the Tribe's ow…
What does Virginia Ruling of the Tax Commissioner P.D. 20-169 conclude about Sales Price: True Object, Exemptions - Manufactured Signs, Permit Fees, Permit Procurement Fees, Installation?
Manufactured signs are taxable tangible personal property, so permit fees and permit procurement fees billed with a sign purchase are part of the taxable sales price, but the taxpayer's separately sta…
State Tax Ruling
Mixed outcome: the sign sold to a church stayed taxable because the church never gave the Taxpayer an exemption certificate, but the billboard/advertising charges were removed from the audit because t…
If a business didn't have invoices ready during a Virginia sales and use tax audit, can it still fix the assessment by submitting invoices later during the appeal?
Yes, but only for the specific line items where the taxpayer actually produced the missing invoices. Virginia's Tax Commissioner removed audit line items from a dermatology practice's use tax assessme…
If Virginia returns my sales tax refund request because it was submitted on a CD, does the three-year filing deadline still count against me?
Granted in part: the Tax Commissioner found the Taxpayer's refund requests were timely filed in December 2015, even though the Department had returned them because they were submitted on a CD, and gav…
Can a taxpayer still appeal a converted sales and use tax assessment after the 90-day appeal deadline has passed, and what options remain if they cannot afford to pay it?
No. Virginia Code § 58.1-1821 gives a taxpayer only 90 days from the date of an assessment to apply for relief, and an appeal filed years after that deadline is barred regardless of its merits. A taxp…
Is a retailer that sells and installs custom closets selling taxable tangible personal property or performing exempt real-property construction, and does sales tax apply to its installation and delivery charges?
The custom closets remain tangible personal property even after installation, so the retailer must charge and collect Virginia sales tax on the sale of the materials. However, separately stated instal…
Does an airline catering company qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing sales-tax exemption, and how are the other contested items in its audit resolved?
The big exemption was denied. An airline catering company argued its kitchens turn raw food into finished in-flight meals and should qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing exemption (Va. Code…
Will Virginia remove a communications sales and use tax assessment on Universal Service Fund and PUC fee charges if the taxpayer proves a one-month system error caused the tax to be under-collected?
The Tax Commissioner did not decide the merits; instead the Department sent the case back to the auditor to review the taxpayer's documentation of a claimed one-month system abnormality and make any a…
Is a resale exemption certificate valid when it names a related but different entity than the actual buyer, and can I raise a new audit-sample challenge on reconsideration?
The Department said no. On reconsideration of P.D. 19-85, the Commissioner again rejected the dealer's resale exemption certificate because it named a different, related entity (Company A trading as C…
When can a Virginia dealer avoid sales tax on sales it treated as exempt, and how are exemption certificates for meals sold to nonprofits, churches, and governments handled?
It depends on your documentation. A Virginia dealer is liable for sales tax on any sale it treats as exempt unless it took a valid exemption certificate from the buyer in good faith, using reasonable …
Why did Virginia uphold sales tax on a caterer's meals sold to a federal agency and a nonprofit even though each customer claimed exemption?
The federal banquet lacked the required purchase order and proof of direct federal payment. The nonprofit's certificate had expired and the caterer produced neither an updated certificate nor the Depa…
After Virginia let governments and nonprofits buy meals exempt in 2016, what documentation does a caterer still need to treat those sales as tax-exempt?
The taxpayer lost on all three sales. This caterer treated meal sales to a federal (DOD) employee and two nonprofits as exempt, but the exemption certificates were invalid or incomplete, so the tax wa…
Can I re-appeal a Virginia sales tax audit if I already had a chance to submit documentation and missed the deadline?
No. This wedding-photography business had appealed the same audit back in 2016, and a 2017 Department letter gave it 30 days to submit documentation supporting its claim that gross sales were overstat…
When a third-party financer buys property from a dealer and leases it to the dealer's customer, who owes Virginia sales tax -- and does the dealer's tax on the purchase satisfy it?
The financer must collect the tax on the lease. Because the lease-to-own contract is a conditional lease under which the financer takes ownership of the property, the financer is the lessor and must c…
What happens if a Virginia sales tax audit is closed before the taxpayer has a chance to review the findings and provide documentation?
The taxpayer gets a second chance. Because the audits closed before the taxpayer could review the findings with the audit staff, the Commissioner directed the auditor to schedule a review meeting and …
Did Virginia decide whether an event venue's space rentals were taxable when the operator refused to provide rental records during audit?
No. Without the records, the Department could not evaluate the venue's claim that it rented only space and provided no transient lodging. The estimated six-year assessments were upheld, but the operat…
Could a Virginia convenience store overturn an assessment for sales tax collected but not remitted when earlier records were destroyed and no proof of overpayment was supplied?
No. Available 2018 z-tapes and tax records showed that the store collected tax at correct rates but underreported sales and tax. The assessment was presumed correct, and the owner supplied no evidence…
Were structural 'blue boxes' permanently attached to a building to support a manufactured sign treated as real property or taxable tangible personal property in Virginia?
They were taxable tangible personal property. Virginia's manufactured-sign rule covered the sign and structural additions built to support it, even when permanently attached to the building. The Commi…
Could a Virginia home-staging company keep design services nontaxable by separately stating them from taxable furniture rentals on the same invoice?
Yes. 'Billed separately' required separate line-item charges, not separate invoices. Because the staging company separately stated design services and furniture rentals and collected tax on the rental…
Were points used only to activate games and rides taxable when sold with food in an entertainment center's value-deal and birthday-party packages?
No. The points were neither admission charges nor taxable meal-related charges, gave no entitlement to food, and activated only games and rides. Including them in a package with food did not make them…
What proof did Virginia require before refunding use tax paid on software claimed to have been delivered electronically?
An invoice, contract, sales agreement, or comparable evidence had to expressly confirm electronic delivery and that no tangible software medium was or would be supplied. The taxpayer failed to provide…
Could a Virginia business remove sales-tax audit items through an appeal without providing invoices, exemption certificates, or other supporting records?
Not on the existing record. Virginia required suitable transaction records and a complete appeal supported by essential documentation. The taxpayer had supplied none, so it received one final 30-day p…
Were separately stated fees to pick up, remove, and recycle an old mattress taxable when offered only with the sale and delivery of a new mattress?
Yes. The services were offered only in connection with new-mattress sales, making the pickup, removal, and recycling fees part of the taxable sales price. Separately stating the charges did not change…
Browse Virginia rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Virginia's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.