Legal Ethics Opinions
Free state and local bar legal ethics opinions with plain-English summaries, full citations, and source links on every page.
No opinions match these filters
Try fewer or different words, check the spelling, or clear the filters to browse everything.
May a lawyer send selected items of stored client property to another person at the client's request?
The committee found no rule prohibiting the lawyer from locating and forwarding specified items of stored client property to a person the client authorized.
Did the committee consider ordinary unencrypted email for routine client matters a Rule 1.6 violation?
The committee said routine unencrypted email with clients or jointly representing lawyers did not violate Rule 1.6 as analyzed in 1997, unless unusual circumstances required stronger security.
May estate counsel represent an attorney whose malpractice defense could reduce recovery on an estate bond?
The committee said Rule 1.7(a) barred the proposed representation because the estate could benefit from the malpractice recovery, creating adverse responsibilities. Consent from both clients did not…
Can a lawyer publicly take a personal position, such as in bar association or legislative activity, that is contrary to a client's interests?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concluded a lawyer may espouse a personal viewpoint adverse to a former or present client's interest, without client consent, as long as the lawyer does not reveal…
In Kentucky, does complying with the workers' compensation law's attorney-fee limits and fee-approval disclosures violate the ethics rules, and do the ex parte rules apply before the Department of Workers' Claims?
The opinion concluded that complying with the statutory fee limits does not by itself violate the rules (qualified no) and that a fee-approval affidavit can be supplied without disclosing privileged…
In Kentucky, when a lawyer represents the fiduciary of a decedent's estate or trust, does the lawyer also represent or owe special duties to the beneficiaries, and may the lawyer represent both?
The opinion concluded a lawyer for a fiduciary represents the fiduciary, not the estate, trust, or beneficiaries, and owes beneficiaries no duties beyond those owed to other third parties;…
Must a criminal defense lawyer warn a client about the risks of cooperating with law enforcement, including the lack of witness protection?
Yes. The opinion concluded that when a cooperation agreement may create a risk of harm to the client or the client's family, the lawyer must inform himself of the relevant facts, including whether…
May a judge continue serving on a private family foundation board that makes charitable grants?
The Committee found the board service permissible on the stated facts, provided the foundation was not likely to be engaged frequently in adversary proceedings in the judge’s court and the judge did…
Could a chief judge hire another circuit judge’s granddaughter as probation officer?
West Virginia JIC Opinion 1997-21 found no nepotism in the described merit-based hiring process where the related judge did not participate and the appointee would not work on that judge’s cases.
Could a circuit judge attend a local Crimestoppers law enforcement appreciation banquet?
A majority in West Virginia JIC Opinion 1997-20 advised that attendance at the described Crimestoppers banquet would be improper.
May judges write an explanatory article for a trade magazine and appear with its president on the cover?
Yes, if the article informs readers about the legal process and the cover appearance does not promote one side of an issue or cast doubt on impartiality.
Can a lawyer who investigates public corruption for a municipal department of investigation take part in partisan political activity?
The opinion concluded no: a municipal examining attorney with subpoena power who investigates public corruption and refers matters for prosecution is subject to the same bar on partisan political…
Can a lawyer list a paralegal as a 'Certified Legal Assistant' on letterhead when a private association issued the certification?
The opinion concluded yes, provided the materials disclose that the National Association of Legal Assistants issued the certification and the lawyer has confirmed NALA certifies everyone who meets…
Can a lawyer join a real estate broker's program that selects the lawyer to represent both the home buyer and the lender at a reduced flat fee?
The opinion concluded no: the lawyer's dependence on the broker's continued approval created a personal-interest conflict that could not be cured by consent, and the broker's promotion of the…
Can a lawyer let a paralegal use the lawyer's signature stamp to sign checks drawn on the client escrow account?
The opinion concluded yes, with conditions: a nonlawyer may not be a signatory on the special account, but a lawyer may authorize a paralegal to apply the lawyer's signature stamp to escrow checks…
Could a magistrate serve on the governor-appointed State Fire Commission?
West Virginia JIC Opinion 1997-19 concluded that a magistrate could not accept the State Fire Commission appointment under article VIII, section 7.
Could a magistrate judge sell land to a contractor bidding to build a new courthouse?
The committee found no Code violation where the judge had no role in choosing the courthouse site or bid and would not use judicial office to influence the sale or bidding.
Can a Michigan judge attend a political party's testimonial dinner honoring judges where tickets are priced above the dinner's cost?
No. A judge may not attend a testimonial dinner where the admission price exceeds the reasonable cost, and may not let the prestige of judicial office be used to raise money for a political party.
Did the judge have to recuse because the defendant’s aunt married the judge’s spouse’s first cousin?
Opinion 97-666 originally said yes, but the Commission expressly superseded it with 97-677, which held that this relationship did not require recusal.
Must a judge recuse when a party’s law firm employs the judge’s daughter or son-in-law but that relative does no work on the case?
No on the facts stated. The Commission found no required recusal where the relatives were nonparticipating associates whose pay was not expected to be directly affected.
Must a judge recuse from a criminal case prosecuted by the judge’s nephew?
Yes. The Commission required recusal for a lawyer-relative within the fourth degree, while allowing possible remittal through Canon 3D’s procedure.
May a judge serve on the board of a public authority financing an amusement and public park project?
No. The Commission treated the public authority board as a Canon 5G position outside the law and justice purposes permitted for judicial service.
Does an adversary's threat to call the opposing lawyer as a trial witness, about a conversation the lawyer is sure never happened, force that lawyer to withdraw as trial counsel?
No; under MRPC 3.7 the lawyer must judge whether the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness, and an adversary's threat does not by itself make the lawyer's testimony necessary or require withdrawal.
Can a firm continue representing a trustee after earlier family representation and an attempted mediation?
The committee could not resolve the factual conflicts. It said related former-client work could disqualify the firm, and an intermediation under Rule 2.2 would require withdrawal if a client requested it.
After a lawyer leaves a government agency, which matters is she barred from handling for private clients, and can her new firm screen her so the rest of the firm can take the work?
The opinion concluded that Rule 1.11, not Rule 1.9(a) and (b), governs a former government lawyer's conflicts: she is disqualified only from particular matters in which she participated personally…
When a private party is in a dispute with a government agency that has its own counsel, may the party's lawyer talk directly to government officials, or must she always go through the agency's lawyer?
The opinion concluded that Rule 4.2 generally protects a represented government entity from unconsented contacts the same way it protects a private organization, but the constitutional right to…
May an Alabama judge receive an earned contingent fee from a former law firm after taking the bench?
Opinion 97-659 permits payment after the judge takes the bench if the basis for calculating the judge's share was established beforehand. An established but unpaid share does not, for that reason…
What must a North Carolina lawyer do after receiving an opposing party's privileged or confidential materials sent by mistake?
The opinion concluded a lawyer who receives materials obviously sent by mistake must stop reading once he realizes they may be privileged or confidential and not meant for him, notify opposing…
Can a North Carolina lawyer represent several accident victims with claims against the same limited insurance fund?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may represent multiple claimants in a common accident, even when limited insurance funds put them in competition, if there are no crossclaims among them and each gives…
When a North Carolina law firm closes a real estate file, what must it give the former client, and are the lawyer's title notes part of it?
A former client gets originals or copies of the documents generated solely for the client's closing, but not the lawyer's title notes or abstracts. If the lawyer who made the notes leaves the firm…
Can a North Carolina real estate lawyer hire an independent (non-employee) paralegal to perform title searches, and what supervision does that require?
Yes, a lawyer may use an independent-contractor nonlawyer to search titles, but the lawyer must supervise the work and stay competent in the area. A lawyer who is not competent in real property law…
When the lawyer who handled a firm's contingent case leaves, what are the firm's duties to the client, and can the firm withdraw after the appeal?
The firm must stand in the departed lawyer's place and may withdraw only under Rule 1.16. The opinion concluded the firm may move to withdraw if it can do so without material adverse effect, giving…
When an hourly-fee client discharges a lawyer, can the lawyer bill for time spent moving to withdraw, for briefing successor counsel, and for responding to a grievance the client files?
The lawyer may bill for withdrawal time when the client requested the withdrawal, need not brief successor counsel for free absent agreement, and may not charge for responding to a client's…
Could a firm continue a wrongful-death suit against its current corporate client after limiting recovery to insurance?
The committee found a Rule 1.7(c) conflict despite consent, because the corporation’s condition that recovery stay within insurance limits restricted the parents’ options and adversely affected the…
A former client is being investigated for forging my signature on a letter on my letterhead. Investigators want a statement and my testimony that I didn't write or sign it. Does Rule 1.6 stop me?
The panel concluded that Rule 1.6 does not prohibit the lawyer from stating or testifying that the lawyer neither wrote nor signed the letter, because that fact is not information relating to the…
A human-rights agency directs me to send my client's position paper to the represented complainant. May I also copy the complainant on my adversarial cover letter to the agency, or does Rule 4.2 forbid it?
The panel concluded that the agency directive might fall within Rule 4.2's exception for communications authorized by law as to the required position paper, but that sending the represented…
My spouse is an associate at a big firm but doesn't work on family-court cases. Do I and my firm need client consent to handle a family-court matter where a different lawyer at my spouse's firm is opposing counsel?
The panel concluded that disclosure and consent are not required unless an actual conflict exists or is reasonably foreseeable; because the spouses are not opposing each other, Rule 1.8(i) does not…
I took over a case from a lawyer who has since become a judge, and I'll receive one combined check for all attorneys' fees. Can I pay the judge for the legal work done before going on the bench?
The panel concluded that it is not a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct for a successor attorney to pay a judge for legal services performed on the case before the judge's appointment,…
Could an Illinois judge preside over a cancer charity and speak at its fundraiser?
The Committee allowed the presidency and name on nonfundraising stationery, but barred solicitation and the proposed financial report followed by a donation appeal at a fundraising event.
Could an Illinois judge hear cases handled by assistant city prosecutors when the city prosecutor owed the judge money?
Yes, on the bare facts, where the assistants had no private-practice tie to the prosecutor. Circumstances suggesting the judge favored them to protect repayment could require recusal.
Could an Illinois judge hear cases involving a hospital subsidiary of the spouse’s employer?
Likely yes on the bare facts if the spouse’s interest was de minimis. The Committee made the assessment fact-dependent and discussed remittal if impartiality was reasonably questioned.
Could a defense fund pay an Illinois judge’s attorney fees after criminal charges?
The Committee permitted a defense fund, subject to former Rule 65C(4)(c) limits on donors and the other safeguards in the opinion. The judge’s name could promote a dinner benefiting only that judge.
Could an Illinois judge serve on the board or committee of a nonprofit economic development corporation?
The Committee allowed board, secretary, and information-committee service subject to the judge’s assessment of the former Code’s litigation, fundraising, impartiality, and financial-contact limits.
Could an Illinois judge play violin with an orchestra or at weddings and accept an honorarium?
The Committee permitted the performances and an honorarium within the former six-month $5,000 limit, provided the musical work did not interfere with judicial duties. It cautioned against performing…
May a judge serve on a university chancellor’s governmental advisory committee?
The Committee concluded that service on the University of Nebraska committee was incompatible with former Canons 4C(2) and 2A because the committee advised a state institution on policy outside the…
How must a newly appointed judge wind up a law corporation with ongoing cases and attorney employment agreements?
The Committee required the new judge to end all involvement in the corporation’s affairs and pending cases upon taking office; only passive receipt of fees for legal work already performed could continue.
Must a judge recuse when lawyers appearing before the judge rent offices from the judge’s spouse?
The majority in West Virginia JIC Opinion 1997-18 required recusal from cases involving the spouse’s two lawyer tenants; a stated minority favored disclosure and party choice.
Must a judge recuse when the judge’s brother-in-law is in-house counsel for a corporate party’s parent company?
Yes on the facts stated. The Commission found the attorney-client relationship and corporate connection created a reasonable impartiality question.
May a judge appoint a relative within the fourth degree as guardian ad litem after a minor nominates that lawyer?
No. The Commission barred the appointment and said the disqualification could not be remitted in this proceeding because the attorney-relative stood in for the minor.
Must a judge recuse when a party is represented by a lawyer who rents office space from the judge?
Yes. The Commission held that rent paid by the lawyer to the judge created a financial relationship requiring recusal from that lawyer’s cases.
How did Alabama JIC Opinion 97-658 address a judge's former clients in unrelated cases?
Opinion 97-658 disqualified the judge from one case involving a former long-term client and left another fact dependent. The JIC marked it modified by Opinion 99-740, which adopted a two-year…
May an Alabama judge socialize with a lawyer-friend convicted of a federal crime?
Opinion 97-657 says private and public interactions are not categorically barred, but they can create an appearance of impropriety under Canons 1 and 2. Mere attendance at the same church is not…
Does a judge’s Bar complaint against an attorney-litigant automatically disqualify the judge?
Opinion 97-656 says the judge’s ethical complaint against an attorney-litigant does not itself require disqualification. Recusal is required if the judge becomes personally biased or prejudiced…
Does a litigant’s complaint to the Alabama JIC require the judge to recuse?
Opinion 97-655 says a litigant’s complaint against the judge, including its allegations, does not by itself require disqualification. The judge must step aside if the complaint produces personal…
Must an Alabama judge remain recused after a first cousin withdraws as counsel?
Opinion 97-654 says recusal was required while the first cousin appeared as counsel but ceased to be required after withdrawal, absent extraordinary circumstances raising a reasonable question about…
Is an Alabama judge disqualified when counsel works at the judge’s sister-in-law’s firm?
Opinion 97-653 says another lawyer’s membership in the sister-in-law’s firm does not itself disqualify the judge. Disqualification can arise from personal bias, a substantially affected interest, or…
Is an Alabama judge disqualified when a party’s lawyer works with the judge’s cousin’s husband?
Opinion 97-652 says a law firm connection to the judge’s cousin’s husband does not alone require disqualification. The judge must disclose the relationship and assess bias, an affected financial…
May an Alabama judge reject reassigned cases because of a heavy regular workload?
Opinion 97-651 says a judge may not peremptorily reject cases properly assigned by the presiding judge. Heavy workload may mitigate a prompt-disposition charge but does not completely excuse delay.
Could a Maine judge accept a $5,000 college award recognizing work as a lawyer and judge?
The committee unanimously allowed the award under the public-testimonial gift rule, but a majority found accepting the $5,000 prize would violate Canon 2A; donating it afterward did not change that result.
Can a lawyer who served on a county planning commission and as campaign treasurer for a supervisor represent clients in zoning cases before those bodies?
Generally yes, with limits. The opinion concluded the lawyer's former service on the planning commission does not bar representing clients before it or the board of supervisors in matters where he…
How these opinions are useful
- Understand the rules: Ethics opinions interpret how the rules of professional conduct apply to real fact patterns.
- Weight varies by state: Most bar opinions are advisory, not binding like court discipline decisions, though formal opinions carry substantial weight. Some states go further: Georgia and Virginia opinions approved by the state supreme court bind lawyers there, New Jersey's bind the ethics committees that decide grievances, Rhode Island and Alabama protect the lawyer who asked for an opinion and followed it, and Utah and North Dakota protect lawyers who rely on one. Each opinion page says how much weight its opinion carries.
- Working guidance: The committee shows lawyers what the rule actually requires day to day (conflicts checks, fee letters, intake screens, withdrawal mechanics).
- Practice research: Cite ethics opinions in fee agreements, engagement letters, conflict waivers, and disqualification motions.