State Tax Rulings
Free state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions with plain-English summaries, full citations, and the original source on every page.
No rulings match these filters
Try fewer or different words, check the spelling, or clear the filters to browse everything.
When did separately billed hospital central-supply items remain hospital-consumed property rather than retail sales to patients?
Treatment depended on actual use and transfer. Staff-used items could be self-consumed, while personal items or property given to patients were retail sales.
Did a riding mower qualify for Texas' agricultural sales-tax exemption when it was used in pastures and in a garden?
No on the facts described. Mowing pasture weeds for production could qualify, but aesthetic mowing and mowing nonproduction areas did not. Garden use qualified only if the food was sold in the…
How did revised Florida TAA 92C2-004R determine the exempt share of a business trust and the relevant portfolio valuation date?
The trust first excluded the net-asset portion attributable to direct U.S. and specified territorial obligations. The remaining portfolio portion was exempt only if every remaining asset was exempt…
Would part of a trade association's membership dues become taxable if it separately stated a bulletin subscription price to obtain second-class mailing privileges?
Yes. The bulletin had been nontaxable when every member received it for undivided dues with no stated publication amount. Separately identifying a subscription price created an understanding that a…
Were accommodation charges at a nonprofit hospital's family-support and discharge-training facility subject to Florida sales or local option taxes?
No. Based on the stated patient program, the Department treated the facility as designed and operated primarily for people dependent on special care or attention. Its accommodation charges were…
How did California tax public educational seminars that included lunch and course materials, and optional training on separately sold software?
Significant classroom instruction was nontaxable except for lunch, but a short mandatory lunch speech was fully taxable; optional software training was nontaxable.
Was an HMO brochure inviting prospective members to enroll, explaining benefits, and listing participating physicians a printed sales message?
Yes, when published and distributed to prospective members to explain enrollment benefits and promote the HMO's services; qualifying delivery could support an exemption certificate.
How much of a Massachusetts business trust's net asset value was exempt from Florida intangible tax when it held federal and Florida tax-exempt securities?
The net asset value attributable to direct U.S. obligations was exempt. The remaining value was also exempt only if every remaining portfolio asset was Florida-exempt; if any remaining asset was…
How did California apply sales and use tax to reupholstery, carpeting, linoleum, area rugs, delivery, and other interior-decorating charges?
The opinion separated taxable materials and fabrication from nontaxable installation and delivery, with lump-sum contractor rules depending on who consumed the materials.
Were labor charges for cleaning up a crude-oil spill taxable when the spill might be an industrial discharge regulated by the Texas Water Commission?
Potentially no, but only conditionally. If the Texas Water Commission confirmed the crude spill was a regulated industrial discharge, the provider could accept an exemption certificate for…
Were shares of a Massachusetts business trust exempt from Florida intangible tax when its portfolio held only GNMA-guaranteed mortgage participation certificates?
Yes. The certificates represented proportional ownership in a mortgage pool, and the trust shares represented beneficial ownership of that exempt portfolio. Because the trust invested solely in…
Would annual payments from an out-of-state lottery become subject to Florida intangible personal property tax after the winner became a Florida resident?
No. The Department treated the annual lottery payments as an annuity, which the cited statute classified as money. Money was exempt from Florida's annual intangible personal property tax under the…
How did this now-obsolete 1992 ruling tax financial-information network services, communication access, installation, and provider equipment?
Historically, it treated equipment-use charges, telephone-network access, installation, software access, direct-feed modem use, optional information services, and per-workstation viewing charges as…
Did an advertising agreement become a nontaxable service when an addendum denied the advertiser access to the signs and required the center to make all changes?
Yes, prospectively. The addendum converted the arrangement from a taxable license to use real property into a nontaxable advertising service because the center alone placed, changed, and accessed…
Were a corporation's lease payments to a commonly owned partnership nontaxable debt payments because the corporation was liable on mortgages secured by the leased plant?
No. The corporation and partnership were related because the same four people owned them in the same proportions, but the corporation was not equally liable with the partnership on all debt secured…
Did the described postoperative silicone drains and reservoir qualify for California's surgical-opening supply exemption?
Yes, on the stated assumption that bodily fluids drained into the reservoir. California treated the items as qualifying appliances and related supplies.
Were Meadox cardiovascular knits, felts, meshes, pledgets, and fabrics exempt prosthetic devices in California?
Yes, when in fact permanently implanted to repair, reinforce, or assist the heart or blood vessels and sold or furnished under the required conditions.
Could an Oklahoma corporation buy motorcycles for resale, customize them in California and export them to foreign buyers before functional use?
Yes. Customization was not taxable use before resale, but a dealer could reject a resale certificate and collect sales-tax reimbursement.
When did a plant-turnaround charge remain nontaxable real-property maintenance despite including some taxable repairs?
Scheduled periodic work on operating improvements was maintenance. If repairs and other taxable services were 5% or less of an individual lump-sum charge, that charge remained nontaxable.…
Did a fertilizer manufacturer's converted spreader truck qualify for Texas's farm-machine vehicle tax exemption despite highway travel?
Yes. The vehicle would be converted into a spreader truck, loaded with fertilizer, driven to farms or ranches, and used off-road to spread fertilizer over the land. It met the farm-machine…
Were a long-term vehicle lessor's master lease and later vehicle-order forms subject to Florida documentary stamp tax as written obligations to pay money?
No. The submitted forms did not state a fixed debt or direct promise to pay a determinable amount when signed. The vehicle and rental amount depended on later selection and calculations, so the…
Were separately stated oil-and-gas well gauging and pumping-service charges taxable under Texas Letter Ruling 9204L1166D11?
Gauging was not taxable when it consisted of reading well-production information and reporting the results. Pumping services were taxable because adjusting well instruments that affected production…
How were shares of a Massachusetts business trust valued for Florida intangible tax when its portfolio held Florida tax-exempt and possibly taxable securities?
Shares were fully exempt when the portfolio consisted solely of exempt Florida obligations. If the year-end portfolio also contained taxable securities, only the portion attributable to taxable…
Did a subcontract clause vesting title in the government and/or buyer clearly pass overhead materials to the United States before the seller used them?
No. Its mixed government, buyer, and seller references were ambiguous and did not show the clear pre-use federal title intent found in FAR 52.232-16(d).
Were a pressure washer and air compressor exempt farm-maintenance equipment when they were also used on highway vehicles and well casing?
No. Maintenance equipment qualified only if used exclusively on exempt farm equipment. Using the washer on highway vehicles and the compressor on well casing, an improvement to realty, meant both…
The Niagara Falls Bridge Commission plans to issue bonds to finance improvements to and maintenance of the highway bridges it operates across the Niagara River. Will interest paid to individual bondholders be subject to New York State and New York City personal income tax?
No. The interest is exempt from both New York State and New York City personal income tax, because the Commission is neither another state's political subdivision nor a federal instrumentality -…
Which of 20 medical products were exempt or taxable when sold by a Florida medical-supply distributor?
The ruling exempted disposable needles, sutures, splints and supports, casting materials, airway and tracheal tubes, colostomy supplies, dressings, medicated dressings, skin staples, and dressing…
How were state sales tax and county tourist tax divided between the residence and RV-storage phases of a 12-month campground lease?
The six-month-and-one-day residence phase was exempt from the 6% state tax and 2% county tourist tax because the written lease exceeded six months of continuous residence. The remaining on-site…
Which parts of a gas pipeline are tax-exempt 'materials used directly in the furnishing of gas,' and is building the pipeline a taxable service?
Partly exempt. An interstate gas-pipeline company bought the components of a new Connecticut pipeline. DRS split them: the PIPE and the VALVE ASSEMBLIES and CONNECTORS are 'materials used directly…
Is managing the redevelopment of a vacant office complex into a leased multi-tenant property a taxable service in Connecticut?
Yes, taxable. A property-management company was hired to oversee turning a vacant office complex into a fully occupied, multi-tenant property -- developing a master plan, hiring the architect and…
Are an investment advisory firm's consulting fees subject to Connecticut sales tax, and does it matter whose investments the advice concerns?
It depends on whose investments the advice is really about. An investment advisory company asked whether its investment-consulting fees are subject to Connecticut sales and use tax. DRS held: (a)…
Is a qualified REIT subsidiary a separate corporation for Connecticut corporation business tax, or is it merged into the REIT?
Both, in a sense. A qualified REIT subsidiary -- a wholly-owned subsidiary of a real estate investment trust that federal law disregards as a separate corporation under 26 U.S.C. § 856(i) -- is…
Could an electric cooperative formed under Article 1528(b) buy taxable items for its own use without paying Texas sales or use tax?
Yes, if it was formed under the Electric Cooperative Corporation Act, Article 1528(b). Such a cooperative was exempt on taxable items bought for its own use and could give vendors properly completed…
Could a commercial-property tenant obtain a sales-tax refund for natural gas bought by its landlord and passed through at cost?
No for the period at issue. The property owner was the gas purchaser and used it in connection with commercially leasing the property. The tenant's manufacturing activity and reimbursement of the…
Is installing a synthetic-turf putting green on real property a nontaxable capital improvement, or a taxable installation service?
It's a nontaxable capital improvement — with a catch. Installing a permanent synthetic-turf putting green on real property qualifies as a capital improvement under Tax Law §§ 1105(c)(3) and…
Were television research reports nontaxable compilation services or taxable information products when delivered on tangible media in California?
Custom compilation could be a nontaxable service, but standardized specialty products, industry data, programs, and printed local surveys were taxable tangible property.
When were television research reports nontaxable compiling services rather than taxable information products delivered on tangible media?
Custom compilation could be a service if the contract price covered that work; standard reports, software, and post-repeal printed local surveys were taxable.
Does the reduced residential sales-tax rate on energy apply to a homeowners association's energy used to maintain development common areas?
No. The reduced residential sales-tax rate on energy sources and services under Tax Law § 1105-A does not apply to a homeowners association's charges for energy used to maintain the development's…
Did adding one general-interest article to each issue prove that a specialized publication qualified for Florida's former newspaper exemption?
No. The Department refused to revise TAA 92A-017 because a token general-interest article did not show routine reports and matters appealing to a broad public, and satisfying technical rule language…
Is number 2 heating oil used only for heating a taxable 'petroleum product' under Connecticut's petroleum products gross earnings tax?
Not taxable as a petroleum product. A petroleum refiner/distributor sold NUMBER 2 HEATING OIL (ASTM Specification D396-69) to a customer that used it only to HEAT things -- the interior of its…
Was a customized, computer-generated diet plan taxable when an independent dealer collected the questionnaire and fee and the diet company sent materials to the client?
Yes. The Comptroller said the custom diet was taxable to the clients. The independent dealer had to collect the tax and report and remit it on quarterly returns.
How did Texas tax soil decontamination, disposal, hauling, and backfill sales by a facility treating petroleum-contaminated soil?
Decontaminating the soil was nontaxable regardless of reimbursement. Disposing of soil after treatment was taxable waste removal; hauling untreated soil could be nontaxable if it was a regulated…
Was electricity for condominium common areas exempt as residential use when about 30 of 114 units were rented to the public, usually for fewer than 30 days?
No. Short-term rentals made the common areas serve both residential and commercial use, so the electricity was taxable and the refund was denied. An exemption could apply to separately metered…
Did the individual's documents establish Florida domicile and require Florida intangible-tax filings for 1987, 1988, and 1989?
Yes. The Department treated the individual as a Florida resident for those years based on the submitted domicile and homestead evidence, so paying Florida intangible tax was correct. Florida's…
Could a corporate tenant make most related-party rent nontaxable by later guaranteeing the partnership landlord's existing mortgage note?
No. Although the related-entity debt-payment rule could extend to a partnership landlord and an absolute payment guarantee could create equal liability, the proposed guaranty came after the 1989…
Were fees for remote database access, customer-site computer terminals, and telephone auto-parts information subject to Rhode Island sales tax?
Remote database access and telephone information fees were nontaxable services. Customer-site computer terminal fees were rentals, but no tax was due on the rental charges because Company elected…
Were automobile-insurance quote reports taxable when each report depended on a customer's drivers, vehicles, records, uses, and desired coverage?
The first truly custom report was a nontaxable service; separately charged extra copies were taxable unless the contract required mailing them out of state.
Did printed-message exemption apply when the seller delivered publications to the purchaser's parking lot for same-day pickup by distributors?
No. Delivery to the purchaser defeated the exemption regardless of same-day redistribution; the seller needed to deliver to the distributor with common-carrier involvement.
Was a political-campaign consultant merely its client's purchasing agent, and were campaign brochures exempt printed sales messages?
No. Markups and nonseparate billing defeated agent treatment, campaign literature was excluded from printed-message exemption, and brochures and artwork were taxable retail sales.
Was a 60-month equipment contract a sale from the start when the customer could return the property after month 54?
No. It was lease through month 54; continuing or missing return notice triggered title and sale treatment for six remaining payments.
How did California tax data entry delivered on magnetic media, by modem, or as an address list?
Media delivery was taxable, including related programming; modem-only delivery was not. One original address list was excluded, but multiple copies or added media were taxable.
Did a political-campaign consultant buy brochures as its candidate's agent, and were campaign brochures exempt printed sales messages?
No. Markups and failure to separately invoice supplier reimbursement defeated agent treatment, making the consultant a taxable retailer of brochures and artwork; campaign literature was also…
Did an FDIC or RTC property manager inherit the federal entity's Texas sales-tax exemption, and did a financial institution's tax debt disappear after takeover?
No on both points. A private manager did not become tax-exempt merely by working for FDIC or RTC, though a written purchasing-agency arrangement could change the purchase result. A financial…
How far back could a manufacturer seek a Texas utility-tax exemption refund under the 1991 Rule 3.295 amendments?
Up to four years from the request date. The amendments restored exemptions for manufacturing-area lighting, heating, and cooling retroactive to August 3, 1987, but the four-year limitations period…
Was a professionally performed fireworks display a taxable sale of fireworks, and could the provider buy the fireworks tax-free for resale?
No. The display was a nontaxable service because the customer received neither title nor possession of the fireworks. The provider consumed the fireworks and supplies and owed tax when buying them.…
Was a corporation's transfer of equipment to a new limited partnership for a 99% interest exempt as a joint-ownership transfer?
Only if the corporation retained a joint or undivided interest in the equipment after transfer and had paid tax when it acquired the property. If limited-partnership law prevented that ownership,…
Was a third party's electronic transmission of audio or audiovisual commercials to broadcasting stations subject to Texas sales tax?
It depended on where the transmission originated. The Comptroller classified the transmission as a telecommunications service: a Texas-origin transmission was taxable, while one originating outside…
How did Rhode Island treat a federally chartered bank's acquisition of failed credit-union assets, related DEPCO assistance, bank taxes, bulk-sale property, and parent nexus?
The ruling treated timely DEPCO aid as received by the credit unions before the asset sale, used purchase cost for asset basis, followed federal treatment for several income and debt items, imposed…
Were database input and listing-insertion fees taxable when an outside vendor also printed and sold multiple-listing-service books?
Optional database input services were nontaxable if not required with the books, but any credit against the book price tied to buying the service joined taxable book receipts.
Were database input and insertion fees taxable when a vendor also printed multiple listing service books?
Not if the database service was entirely optional and not required with the books. A credit against book price for buying the service remained taxable book receipts.
How these rulings are useful
- See how the rule applies: A letter ruling shows how a state revenue department actually applied the tax law to a specific business and set of facts.
- Plan with confidence: Find a ruling with facts close to yours before you charge, remit, or claim an exemption.
- Binding only on the requester: A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who asked. It is persuasive, not a substitute for your own ruling or professional advice.
- Research across states: Compare how different states treat the same issue, from SaaS and food exemptions to nexus and contractor purchases.