North Carolina State Bar Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the North Carolina State Bar, with full citations and source links on every page.
No North Carolina State Bar opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a lawyer disburse settlement funds from the trust account against an insurance check before confirming it has been collected?
Only with reasonable due diligence and a backstop. The opinion concludes that a lawyer may disburse immediately against cash, wired funds, or instruments listed in the Good Funds Settlement Act, but f…
Can a lawyer provide services through a prepaid legal services plan, and what must the plan do to qualify?
Only if the plan satisfies Rule 7.3(d). The opinion concludes a lawyer may participate in a prepaid legal services plan only if the conditions of Rule 7.3(d)(2) are met, including that the plan is not…
When a lawyer is asked by one person to prepare a will, trust, or power of attorney for someone else, who is the client and what must the lawyer do?
The opinion concludes that 2003 FEO 7 applies to the preparation of any legal document that purports to speak solely for a principal, such as a will, advance directive, trust, or power of attorney, wh…
How must a lawyer safeguard the confidential health information of clients and opposing parties, given HIPAA?
The opinion concludes that health information a lawyer acquires during a representation is confidential under Rule 1.6, and that the standard of care is reasonable care under the circumstances rather …
Can a lawyer contact a county's officials or elected commissioners directly about a client's dispute when the county is represented by its attorney?
The opinion concludes that Rule 4.2(a)'s no-contact rule applies to communications with government employees when the communication concerns the negotiation or litigation of a specific claim, so a law…
Can a North Carolina lawyer print extra statements, like 'Accident Report Enclosed,' on the envelope of a targeted direct-mail solicitation letter?
Yes, but only if the statement does not mislead. The opinion concludes a lawyer may note that an accident report is enclosed only if the envelope makes clear the report is a copy of a public record an…
Can a county's tax attorney, acting as the appointed foreclosure commissioner, buy the property at the tax foreclosure sale she is conducting?
No. The opinion concludes that a county tax attorney appointed as commissioner to conduct a tax foreclosure sale may not bid on the property on her own account, because she has a duty to oversee the s…
Can a lawyer refer a client to a financing company that buys notes or settlements, and can the lawyer take a finder's fee for the referral?
The opinion concludes that a lawyer may refer a client to a financing company only if the lawyer is satisfied the company's arrangement is legal, the lawyer receives no consideration from the company …
If a parent consults a North Carolina lawyer about a matter for her minor child but no one is hired, can the lawyer use what the parent disclosed to help the child against the parent's interests?
No, not without consent. The opinion concludes that a parent who consults a lawyer in good faith about a minor's matter is a prospective client owed a duty of confidentiality under Rule 1.18, so the l…
Can a North Carolina lawyer for a publicly traded company disclose confidential information to the SEC under SEC Rule 205, even when the state confidentiality rule would not permit it?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a North Carolina lawyer who appears and practices before the SEC may 'report out' confidential information as permitted by SEC Rule 205 without violating the North Caro…
Can a North Carolina law firm use a website URL, like Asbestos-Mesothelioma.com, that does not identify the site as belonging to a law firm?
Yes, with a condition. The opinion concludes a firm may use a URL that does not include words identifying it as a law firm's website, so long as the URL is not otherwise false or misleading and the we…
When a North Carolina lawyer charges a 'minimum fee' billed against an hourly rate and then leaves the firm, must the firm refund the unearned portion to the clients?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a minimum fee billed against the lawyer's hourly rate is client money that belongs in the trust account until earned, not a true retainer or flat fee that may be deposi…
When a third party pays a North Carolina lawyer's fee for a client, who owns the unearned funds and what must the lawyer do if the payor demands them back?
It depends on the source and the fee type. The opinion concludes a lawyer generally follows the client's directive for funds belonging to the client and owes no duty to a stranger merely claiming an i…
Can a North Carolina real estate firm hold recording and courier costs in a separate non-trust account and keep the markup if actual costs come in lower?
Only with safeguards. The opinion concludes that funds collected at a closing to pay recording and courier costs remain client funds until disbursed, so a 'Recording Account' holding them must be a tr…
Can a North Carolina lawyer run an internet-only virtual law firm and offer clients unbundled, limited-scope legal services?
Yes to both. The opinion concludes a lawyer may operate a virtual practice delivered entirely over the internet so long as the lawyer avoids unauthorized practice and out-of-state advertising violatio…
Does a North Carolina lawyer have to register a law firm website URL with the State Bar as a trade name if the URL is different from the firm's name?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a website URL is a trade name, because a trade name is any designation used to identify a lawyer, firm, or its services, and the comment to Rule 7.5(a) treats a distinc…
Can a North Carolina bankruptcy lawyer let clients complete the required credit-counseling course in the lawyer's office using a third-party provider, and collect the provider's fee?
Yes, with disclosure and no markup. The opinion concludes a bankruptcy lawyer may offer prospective clients the chance to complete the federally required pre-filing credit-counseling course in the off…
Can a North Carolina law firm base a nonlawyer employee's pay on the fees that employee earns representing Social Security disability claimants, and refer clients to her after she leaves?
Yes. Because federal law lets nonlawyers represent claimants before the Social Security Administration and earn fees for it, those fees are not 'legal fees' subject to Rule 5.4(a)'s ban on fee sharing…
Can a North Carolina lawyer, or the lawyer's firm, appear before a judge who is a close relative of one of the firm's lawyers?
The related lawyer may not personally appear before a closely related judge without the consent of all parties, but other members of her firm are not disqualified. The opinion concludes the firm must …
Can a North Carolina lawyer threaten to report an opposing party or witness to immigration authorities to gain leverage in settling a civil case?
No. The opinion concludes that a lawyer may not threaten to report an opposing party or witness's undocumented immigration status to immigration authorities in order to gain an advantage in civil sett…
When a North Carolina lawyer represents the buyer in a residential closing, can the lawyer prepare the deed for an unrepresented seller without becoming the seller's lawyer?
Yes, with disclosures. The opinion concludes a buyer's lawyer may prepare the deed as an accommodation to her client without representing the seller, provided she first tells the seller that she repre…
If a North Carolina law firm uses a nonlawyer to represent Social Security claimants, must it disclose that in its advertising and to the client, and is the nonlawyer bound by the ethics rules?
Yes on all counts. The opinion concludes that a firm advertising Social Security representation must disclose when a nonlawyer will provide it, because omitting that fact is materially misleading unde…
Which communications to prospective class members in a North Carolina class action must carry the 'This is an advertisement for legal services' disclaimer?
Only the ones that solicit employment. The opinion concludes that a court-issued class notice and informal litigation communications by counsel do not require the Rule 7.3(c) disclaimer, but a lawyer'…
Can two North Carolina lawyers each form a single-shareholder professional corporation and have the two corporations form a partnership to practice law?
Yes. The opinion concludes that two lawyers may each form their own professional corporation and have the corporations form a law partnership without violating Rule 5.4(b)'s ban on partnering with a n…
Is a North Carolina lawyer appointed only as a parent's guardian ad litem bound by the Rules of Professional Conduct, and what changes if the same lawyer is also the parent's counsel?
It depends on the role. The opinion concludes that a lawyer serving solely as a parent's guardian ad litem has no client-lawyer relationship and so is not governed by the Rules that impose client duti…
Can a North Carolina solo lawyer name or trade-name his firm 'North Star Law Office' when it leases space from and takes referrals from North Star Financial Group?
No to both. The opinion concludes the firm's official corporate name must contain a shareholder's surname under the State Bar's professional-entity regulations, so 'North Star Law Office' cannot be th…
Can a North Carolina lawyer advertise 'no fee unless you recover' in a contingent-fee case without mentioning that the client may still owe litigation costs?
It depends on the wording. The opinion concludes that 'no recovery, no fee' style statements are misleading under Rule 7.1 unless the lawyer always makes repayment of advanced court costs and litigati…
Can a prosecutor handle a habitual-felon case against a former client whose prior conviction the prosecutor once defended, or a defense lawyer handle a case built on a conviction he once prosecuted?
The opinion concludes a prosecutor may not try a habitual-felon case against a former client if effective cross-examination would require confidential information from the prior representation, and a …
Can an insurance defense lawyer who represents both the insured and the insurer give the insurer a full settlement-value evaluation, and recommend whether to settle?
The opinion concludes the lawyer may give both the insured and the insurer a full, candid evaluation of liability, verdict range, and likely settlement, but may not recommend that the insurer decline …
Can a North Carolina law firm advertise 'put our 30 years of experience to work for you' when that figure is the lawyers' combined experience and no single lawyer has practiced that long?
Not as worded. The opinion concludes that advertising '30 years of experience' is misleading under Rule 7.1 when it is the lawyers' combined experience and no single lawyer has practiced more than ten…
Can a North Carolina lawyer reveal a client's confidential information in a suit to collect an unpaid fee, including to support a claim to pierce the corporate veil?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes that Rule 1.6(b)(6)'s self-defense exception lets the lawyer disclose confidential information learned in the representation to establish a corporate-veil-pie…
Can a lawyer feed deposition questions to another lawyer to ask a represented opposing party who is testifying as an expert in an unrelated case?
It depends on the questions. The opinion concludes that submitting general questions about the medical procedure does not violate Rule 4.2, but if the questions probe the facts at issue in the lawyer'…
When an appointed client disappears, can the lawyer advocate for the outcome the facts seem to support, or must the lawyer move to withdraw?
No, the lawyer may not substitute his own objectives. The opinion concludes that when an appointed client has disappeared and her objectives are unknown, the lawyer must use reasonable diligence to lo…
Can one North Carolina lawyer represent both a lender and the trustee on a deed of trust when a borrower sues to enjoin the foreclosure?
Yes, if impartiality can be maintained. The opinion concludes that a lawyer may jointly represent a lender and the deed-of-trust trustee in litigation over a foreclosure, provided the lawyer can prese…
Can a lawyer offer free promotional merchandise to accident victims who call in response to a targeted direct mail letter?
The opinion concludes no. Promising promotional merchandise as an inducement to call is an improper solicitation, because a recipient may call only for the item and the lawyer could then solicit them …
Can a North Carolina lawyer join a commercial online service that matches prospective clients with lawyers and lets lawyers send offer messages?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may participate, even though the for-profit service does not meet every condition for a lawyer referral service, because the client chooses the lawyer rather than receiv…
When a lawyer takes a client to a new firm and a fee is later awarded, what does the lawyer owe the former firm, and how must the disputed fee be handled?
The opinion concludes the departed lawyer must honestly notify the former firm of the awarded fee, deposit the mixed fee check intact in trust, may pay herself any undisputed share while keeping the d…
In a North Carolina settlement, can a lawyer agree not to represent other employees with similar claims, and can the lawyer later take those claims after a confidential settlement?
The opinion concludes that Rule 5.6(b) bars a lawyer from agreeing to a settlement term that restricts representing other claimants, but a confidentiality-only term is permitted. The lawyer may later …
When an adult child asks a lawyer to draft a power of attorney for an elderly parent, who is the lawyer's client and what must the lawyer do?
The opinion concludes the parent (the principal) is the client because the engagement is for the parent's benefit, not the child requesting and paying for the work. The lawyer must consult the parent …
Can a personal injury lawyer give medical lienholders an accounting of how settlement proceeds were disbursed?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a lawyer does not violate the confidentiality rule by providing medical lienholders the accounting that N.C.G.S. 44-50.1 requires, because Rule 1.6(b)(1) permits disclo…
Can a lawyer file a lawsuit for a client when the statute of limitations on the claim has already run?
Yes. The opinion concludes that filing a time-barred claim is not frivolous under Rule 3.1, because the statute of limitations is a waivable affirmative defense that does not strip the court of jurisd…
Can a lawyer who takes over a Social Security claim from a nonlawyer representative pay that nonlawyer a share of the fee for prior work?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a lawyer who takes over a Social Security claimant's case from a nonlawyer representative may compensate the nonlawyer for work actually performed, even out of the lega…
Under North Carolina Rule 1.18, do duties to a prospective client attach to an initial consultation, and how does a firm screen a lawyer to avoid disqualification?
The opinion concludes that 'representation' under Rule 1.18(d) includes an initial consultation, so duties to a prospective client attach even when no attorney-client relationship forms. A firm can av…
Can a lawyer advertise membership in a group like the Million Dollar Advocates Forum that is named for a verdict threshold?
Yes, if it is not misleading under Rule 7.1. The opinion concludes a lawyer may advertise membership in an organization with a self-laudatory name only when the group has strict, verifiable admission …
What can a lawyer do when opposing counsel appears to have a mental health or substance problem affecting the case, and when must it be reported?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may not contact the represented opposing party about it, need not press every advantage, may report observations to the Lawyer Assistance Program, and must report to the…
Can a North Carolina law firm outsource the employment of its lawyers and staff to a professional employer organization (PEO) for payroll and benefits?
The opinion concludes the arrangement does not violate Rule 5.4 as long as the PEO does not control or interfere with the lawyers' professional judgment, the PEO is paid a percentage of payroll costs …
Can a criminal defense lawyer stay silent about, or stipulate to, a sentencing worksheet that understates a defendant's prior record level?
The opinion concludes a defense lawyer may decline to stipulate and remain silent when the prosecutor presents an inaccurate prior-record worksheet, but may not stipulate to or otherwise help present …
Can a lawyer use an investigator's pretextual conversation with a represented opposing party as evidence, and can purely visual surveillance be used?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may not proffer evidence of an investigator's pretextual conversation with a represented person, because Rule 4.2 bars through an agent what the lawyer cannot do directl…
Can one lawyer represent both a general contractor and its surety in defending a payment bond claim, and when must the lawyer withdraw?
The opinion concludes one lawyer may jointly represent a general contractor and its surety because their interests are ordinarily aligned, but the lawyer must assert only valid defenses and avoid unne…
Can a North Carolina lawyer collect both a contingent fee and a separate court-awarded attorney fee from the same personal injury case?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may collect both the contingent fee and a court-awarded fee, or some portion, so long as the total is consistent with the fee agreement and not clearly excessive under R…
Can a nonlawyer handle a residential real estate closing in North Carolina, and what closing tasks may a nonlawyer perform?
No. The opinion concluded a nonlawyer may not handle a residential real estate closing because most closing functions are the practice of law, though a nonlawyer may perform purely ministerial tasks l…
Can a North Carolina lawyer have a supervised nonlawyer oversee the signing of documents and disbursement of proceeds at a residential real estate closing without the lawyer present?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may delegate overseeing document execution and disbursement of closing proceeds to a supervised nonlawyer, who must not give legal advice, and the lawyer need not be phy…
When a court-appointed guardian ad litem is also a lawyer and is represented by trial counsel, can opposing counsel contact the GAL directly under Rule 4.2?
The opinion concludes that a guardian ad litem who happens to be a lawyer is still a represented party for Rule 4.2 purposes, not co-counsel. Opposing counsel must comply with Rule 4.2 and respect the…
Can the lawyer for a deceased client testify about the client's confidences in a will contest or other litigation over the estate?
The opinion concludes the lawyer may testify. If the personal representative calls the lawyer, that consent allows the disclosure; the lawyer may also testify when required by law or court order. If s…
Can a lawyer for one divorcing spouse prepare an answer or waiver for the unrepresented spouse, or represent both spouses in the divorce suit as an intermediary?
The opinion concludes no. One lawyer may not appear in court for opposing parties no matter how amicable the divorce, and a lawyer may not prepare a pleading or waiver admitting the complaint for the …
Must a North Carolina lawyer keep client emails in the file, and on termination can the lawyer return them electronically instead of as paper copies?
The opinion concludes whether to retain an email is a competence judgment under Rule 1.1, and the lawyer may store retained emails electronically or on paper. On termination the lawyer must give the c…
When a lawyer represents an estate and the administratrix has a personal interest that conflicts with the estate, must the lawyer withdraw?
The opinion concludes the lawyer represents the estate and the personal representative in her official capacity, not individually. If estate assets are enough to pay creditors, the lawyer need not wit…
Can a lawyer's firm sue or take matters adverse to a public body or nonprofit board when one of the firm's lawyers serves on that board?
The opinion concludes the firm may proceed if the board-member lawyer is screened in the firm and makes full disclosure to the board, refraining from any consideration, discussion, or vote on the matt…
Can a North Carolina lawyer take part in collaborative family law and agree in advance to withdraw before any court proceeding?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may represent a spouse in a collaborative family law process, even when the other spouse is represented by a member of the same collaborative organization, if both lawye…
Does a bank-supplied CD-ROM of digital check images satisfy a North Carolina lawyer's trust-account record-keeping requirement?
The opinion concludes that a CD-ROM containing digital images of the fronts and backs of canceled checks satisfies Rule 1.15-3(a)(2), because the images can be retrieved and printed when needed; it al…
Browse North Carolina State Bar opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the North Carolina State Bar interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.