New Mexico Advisory Committee on the Code of Judicial Conduct Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the New Mexico Advisory Committee on the Code of Judicial Conduct, with full citations and source links on every page.
No New Mexico Advisory Committee on the Code of Judicial Conduct opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
May a judge's photo and biography appear on a charity board's website that also accepts donations?
The committee found that the judge's incidental photo and biography on this charity's website did not conflict with the Code, provided the page did not appear to make the judge a personal fundraiser.
May a part-time probate judge run for trustee of a member-owned electric cooperative?
The committee found no Code provision barring the part-time probate judge from seeking election to the cooperative's private trustee position. Because the trustee duties were unspecified, it left…
How long may a new judge retain a financial interest in a transferred law practice, and which related cases require recusal?
On the facts presented, the committee found a fourteen-year financial tie to the successor lawyer unreasonable and said the judge could and should end it within five years. It also required recusal…
How may a new district judge wind down a former solo law practice, handle pending fees, and notify former clients and courts?
The committee allowed administrative steps to collect earned fees and close matters, including trust-account processing, while rejecting continued legal practice and attorney-identifying stationery.…
May a judge help prosecutors or police run a mock trial that trains officers to testify in court?
The committee concluded the Code did not permit the proposed training. A judge's participation in prosecution-side witness training could reasonably appear biased and could cause disqualification if…
May a judge serve on the board of a local nonprofit mental health provider whose staff do not appear before the judge or receive court referrals?
The committee permitted board service on the stated facts, finding no conflict under Rules 21-307(A)(5) or 21-301. It said the judge would need to reassess if the provider or its staff later…
May a district judge publish an autobiographical book about work as a lawyer, midwife, and judge?
The committee did not give blanket approval without reviewing the manuscript. It directed the judge to examine whether the book could cause disqualification or undermine impartiality, while finding…
May a part-time probate judge work for New Mexico or volunteer with the county sheriff's reserve program?
The committee said a continuing part-time probate judge was exempt from Rule 21-304's government-position restriction and could generally do either, but Rule 21-301 still barred activities that…
May a judge join a limited liability company formed only to let members share a recreational hot-air balloon?
The committee treated the proposed cost-sharing balloon LLC as a recreational club rather than a business and permitted participation on the stated facts. It cautioned that Rule 21-311(C) would bar…
May a judicial campaign event suggest contribution amounts while making clear that attendance requires no contribution?
The committee permitted an invitation listing suggested contribution levels if it expressly said a contribution was not required to attend. It reasoned that the candidate could then attend with…
May a sitting judge host a home meet-and-greet to seek a party committee's nomination for another judicial seat?
Yes. The committee said the Code permits the candidate to hold the home event, while requiring impartial conduct and disqualification in cases involving attorney members of the central committee…
May a judge recommend a lawyer who appears before the judge for a public defender contract?
Yes. The committee found that the requested reference for a lawyer applying for a public defender contract would not abuse judicial prestige or impair the appearance of impartiality on the stated facts.
May a magistrate work as a paid sports referee when court is closed or while taking vacation during court hours?
The committee permitted evening or weekend refereeing and a small stipend if the Code's outside-activity limits were met and law-enforcement availability remained intact. It advised against…
May a municipal judge require a traffic offender to donate to Crime Stoppers as a deferred-sentence condition?
The committee said no unless the municipality had granted the court authority to require such a donation. It left undecided whether a broad ordinance authorizing probation conditions would suffice…
May a judicial candidate learn which attorneys endorsed the campaign committee?
The committee read Comment 17 to Rule 21-402 as calling for the campaign committee not to tell the candidate which attorneys it obtained endorsements from. It treated the comment as aspirational…
May a judge perform or serve as a talent judge at a State Bar Foundation fundraiser for legal services?
Yes, under the 2012 Code and subject to its limits on direct solicitation and outside activity. The committee said its contrary 2008 advice in AO 08-04 should be disregarded in favor of this opinion.
May a judge speak at a bail bondsmen's conference and accept travel reimbursement from its association or a local bondsman?
The committee found the proposed talk permissible. It called expense reimbursement from either the national trade association or the local bail bondsman who invited the judge highly inadvisable…
May a magistrate judicial campaign accept offered endorsements from a county bar association and a police union?
The committee said the campaign committee could receive the offered organizational endorsements under the Code then in force and the revised Code scheduled for January 2012. The opinion addressed…
May a judge and spouse buy foreclosed property at a judicial sale arising from a case handled by the judge's court?
The committee permitted the proposed purchase on the stated facts: the judge had no role in the case, obtained information through public channels, would not bid personally, and did not know the…
Must a judge recuse from State Police cases after the judge's spouse becomes a major overseeing the zone that includes the judge's court?
The committee said yes for cases involving State Police officers within the spouse's zone, despite finding no actual conflict on the described duties. It found a reasonable appearance of bias and…
May a retired magistrate serving part time as a pro tempore judge also serve as an alternate municipal judge?
The committee read Rule 21-500 to allow both part-time judicial roles, provided the alternate municipal judgeship did not conflict with the hours or duties of the pro tempore magistrate service.
May a New Mexico judge use judicial letterhead, postage, position, or title to invite people to a Red Mass?
The committee prohibited using judicial position or title to solicit attendance or promote a religious event, and it rejected using court stationery or postage for invitations. It distinguished a…
May a full-time municipal judge continue paid drug, alcohol, and truancy classes for local students?
The committee allowed the teaching subject to limits: class work could not occur during judicial business hours, student appearances before the judge had to remain rare, and the stipend had to…
Must a judge recuse from sheriff's department cases when the judge's son-in-law is a sergeant supervising four deputies?
The committee required recusal when the son-in-law or any deputy under his supervision participated in a case. It did not require recusal from all other sheriff's department cases, though a…
May a New Mexico county pay a district judge pro tempore appointed to hear probation-violation cases?
The committee found no Code of Judicial Conduct bar to county payment, directly or through the Administrative Office of the Courts, for a judge appointed by the Chief Justice. It did not decide…
May a court lease its managed retail space to a coffee-shop company partly owned by an attorney who regularly appears there?
The committee said the court could not lease the space to the attorney's company because the continuing financial relationship would create an appearance of impropriety and suggest special standing…
May a New Mexico judge serve as an officer of a nonprofit drug court professionals association?
The committee allowed service in principle but conditioned officer service on impartiality and on the organization and its members not regularly appearing before the judge. It recommended against…
Must a New Mexico retention-election judge form a campaign committee when planning no spending, fundraising, or endorsements?
The committee said no campaign committee was required for the described retention election: the judge planned no spending, fundraising, or endorsements and might only speak to voters when invited.…
Must self-funded New Mexico judicial candidates form a campaign committee and identify it on campaign literature?
The committee said the candidates still had to form campaign committees and identify the committee as responsible for paying for literature, even if they used only their own funds. It said the…
May a full-time New Mexico probate judge accept appointment to the U.S.–Mexico Border Health Commission?
The committee said the probate judge could accept the commission appointment because the Code excepted probate judges from the rule that otherwise barred judges from serving on governmental…
Must a New Mexico judge recuse from State Police cases when the judge's spouse commands the district, and can parties waive it?
The committee required recusal from cases involving officers under the spouse's district command. Given the docket's unrepresented defendants and the spouse's supervisory and liaison roles, it…
May a New Mexico judge publish and promote a poetry book while mentioning judicial office in a biography?
The committee permitted publication of the nonlegal poetry book subject to the Code's content and work-hour limits. A factual, incidental mention of judicial office in a biography was acceptable,…
May a New Mexico municipal judge and court staff use conviction-funded judicial education money for out-of-state courses?
The committee permitted the judge and staff to use the judicial education fund for courses, including out-of-state programs. It relied on the mandatory fee, independent fund administration, the…
May an incumbent New Mexico judge serve as an elected delegate to a county political convention?
The committee said no. It treated a convention delegate as an office in a political organization barred by Rule 21-700(A)(3)(a), and said the role would compromise public confidence in judicial…
May a New Mexico judge publish a magazine essay about her same-sex relationship and public policy?
The committee said the Constitution and then-current Code protected publication of the essay, but a case directly raising its subject might require recusal. It suggested a personal-views disclaimer…
May a judge speak about matters arising in the judge's courtroom at a seminar limited to criminal defense lawyers?
The committee recommended declining the seminar invitation. Because prosecutors could not attend, the presentation could create a reasonable public perception that exposure only to the defense side…
May a judge hire a law clerk who also serves without pay on the county planning commission?
The committee found no Code bar to the hiring on the stated facts. The clerk must be insulated from county-party cases, and the judge must recuse from county-party cases involving matters on which…
May a judge donate identifiable race-car lessons or band performances for a charity auction where the judge meets the winning bidder?
The committee found the proposed services donation problematic under the fundraising and judicial-prestige rules because bidders could identify the judge and the judge would interact with the…
Must a judge recuse when a litigant adds the judge as a defendant in an apparent sham claim about a case-management order?
The committee said the amendment did not automatically disqualify the judge on the described facts and allowed a hearing to assess it. If the claim was not sham or frivolous, or if the judge had…
Must judges recuse from an attorney's other cases after one judge charged the attorney with contempt and another handled that proceeding?
The committee said neither judge had to recuse from the attorney's other cases merely because of the contempt proceeding. Its conclusion depended on the absence of personal bias or extrajudicial…
May a New Mexico municipal judge publicly oppose a ballot amendment requiring municipal judges to be lawyers?
The committee permitted the judge's proposed public opposition to Amendment 7 and activity in a non-attorney judges' association, subject to the Code's integrity, impartiality, work-time, and…
May a judge host an unpaid bilingual music and culture radio program?
The committee permitted the unpaid Saturday program on the described facts, provided it did not interfere with judicial duties, compromise impartiality or the office, or use judicial status to…
May a judge represent the judge's court as a party in mediation over a technology contract?
The committee said the judge could participate as the court's knowledgeable party representative, provided the judge did not perform a lawyer's functions. The court's general counsel would act as…
May a judge remain president or a board member of a nonprofit that operates a county hospital appearing regularly in the judge's court?
The committee concluded that the judge could not remain president or a board member while serving as a judge. Hospital related garnishment proceedings regularly reached the judge's court, and the…
What should a family court judge do when a nonprofit uses the judge's name on fundraising letterhead without approval?
The committee advised the judge to request removal of the name from future letterhead. It did not advise a correction letter for solicitations already sent, because that could draw more attention to…
Must judges recuse when a former judge from their court appears as a lawyer?
The committee found no automatic disqualification for a judge who formerly served alongside the lawyer as an elected judge, nor for a newer colleague who had not served with that lawyer. It left…
May a hearing officer sell a home outright to an attorney who regularly appears before the officer?
The committee found the proposed single sale permissible if it was at arm's length, at market price, and without favorable special terms. It agreed the attorney should stay out of the officer's…
Must a judge automatically recuse when a former law partner requests recusal less than five years after the judge left the firm?
The committee rejected automatic recusal based on the former partner's letter. It said the five-year interval suggested in an earlier opinion was not an absolute rule, and the judge could invite a…
May a judge hear criminal cases prosecuted by an office where the judge's spouse is chief deputy district attorney?
The committee said the spouse's chief deputy role required the judge's recusal from all cases involving that district attorney's office, even without the spouse's personal work on a case. It found…
May a newly elected probate judge continue serving in an elected seat on a community college board?
The committee said the probate judge could not hold both elected offices and must resign the college board seat. The order in which the judge won the elections did not change its conclusion.
May a part-time probate judge also serve as a city's chief of police?
The committee found the dual service permissible on the stated facts if judicial and police work remain separate in time and particular conflicts are addressed. Material city claims against estates…
May a new judge sell the telephone number of the judge's former law practice to another attorney?
The committee permitted the sale on the stated facts and described contract disclosures to avoid an apparent continuing relationship or benefit from judicial office. The attorney who bought the…
May a hearing officer owner-finance a home sale to an attorney who regularly appears before the officer if escrow handles payments?
The committee concluded that title and escrow intermediaries would not remove the continuing business relationship created by the owner-financed sale. The ongoing contract with an appearing attorney…
May an unopposed judicial candidate use campaign funds to repay a personal campaign loan and raise more to retire the debt?
The committee treated the candidate's personal loan as a campaign expense payable before unused funds had to be returned or donated. It also permitted further fundraising to retire the remaining…
May a part-time judge direct a nonprofit and attend a one-sided DWI defense seminar taught by an attorney appearing in the judge's court?
The committee allowed nonprofit executive-director work only if it did not conflict with judicial duties and complied with limits on fundraising and use of office. It concluded that the judge could…
Must a municipal judge recuse from every city case after suing the city and naming its attorney in an official capacity?
The committee concluded that the described lawsuit did not require recusal from every case filed by the city attorney's office. It relied on the absence of personal bias, the city attorney's lack of…
May a judge serve on a multidisciplinary team reviewing deaths from intimate partner violence?
The committee concluded that the described team membership was allowed because its law-related work and neutral, broad membership did not appear to impair impartiality. It said the judge would have…
May a university public-law institute director also serve as a municipal judge pro tem when court fees support the institute?
The committee found no conflict on the facts presented, including the director's arrangement that no judicial education fees fund personal salary or benefits. It required the judge to take leave…
May a judge teach a paid evening evidence course outside court hours?
The committee permitted the described teaching if it did not use court time or resources or impair judicial duties. It said compensation must be reasonable, comparable to a nonjudge's pay for the…
May a municipal judge lease a personally owned warehouse to a drug task force whose officers appear in the judge's court?
The committee concluded that the judge should not lease the warehouse to the task force. The lease would create an apparent continuing business relationship with police officers whose department…
Browse New Mexico Advisory Committee on the Code of Judicial Conduct opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the New Mexico Advisory Committee on the Code of Judicial Conduct interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are advisory, not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.