Administrative Hearing Brief - Professional Licensing

ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING BRIEF

Professional Licensing Proceeding

PART I: CAPTION AND FILING

BEFORE THE [OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS / STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL]

IN THE MATTER OF THE ACCUSATION AGAINST:

_________________________________
Respondent.

OAH Case Number: _________________________________

Agency Case Number: _________________________________

License Number: _________________________________

[RESPONDENT'S / COMPLAINANT'S] [PRE-HEARING / POST-HEARING] BRIEF

PART II: DOCUMENT IDENTIFICATION

2.1 Brief Type

☐ Pre-Hearing Brief
☐ Opening Brief
☐ Response/Opposition Brief
☐ Post-Hearing Brief
☐ Reply Brief
☐ Supplemental Brief
☐ Other: _________________________________

2.2 Party Information

Respondent:

Respondent's Counsel:

Complainant:

PART III: TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT.............................Page ____

II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE.......................................................Page ____

III. STATEMENT OF FACTS............................................................Page ____

IV. ISSUES TO BE DECIDED..........................................................Page ____

V. LEGAL STANDARD..................................................................Page ____

VI. ARGUMENT...........................................................................Page ____

VII. CONCLUSION........................................................................Page ____

PART IV: TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Statutes

Regulations

Cases

Secondary Sources

PART V: INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

5.1 Introduction

This brief is submitted on behalf of Respondent, _________________________________, a licensed [profession] in the State of _________________, in connection with the administrative hearing scheduled for _________________ before Administrative Law Judge _________________________________.

5.2 Summary of Argument

[Provide concise 1-2 paragraph summary of your key arguments]

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

PART VI: STATEMENT OF THE CASE

6.1 Nature of the Proceeding

This is an administrative proceeding brought by [Complainant Agency] against Respondent pursuant to [statutory citation], alleging violations of [specific code sections].

6.2 Procedural History

6.3 Relief Sought by Complainant

Complainant seeks the following relief:

☐ Revocation of Respondent's license
☐ Suspension of Respondent's license
☐ Probation with conditions
☐ Public reprimand
☐ Administrative fine
☐ Cost recovery
☐ Other: _________________________________

6.4 Respondent's Position

Respondent contends:

☐ The charges should be dismissed in their entirety
☐ The charges are not supported by the evidence
☐ If violations occurred, lesser discipline is appropriate
☐ Other: _________________________________

PART VII: STATEMENT OF FACTS

7.1 Background Facts

[Provide chronological narrative of relevant facts]

A. Respondent's Professional Background

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

B. Events Leading to This Proceeding

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

C. The Investigation

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

7.2 Disputed Facts

7.3 Undisputed Facts

The parties stipulate to the following facts:

1. ___________________________________________________________________________
2. ___________________________________________________________________________
3. ___________________________________________________________________________

PART VIII: ISSUES TO BE DECIDED

8.1 Factual Issues

1. Whether Respondent engaged in the conduct alleged in Cause [#]?

2. Whether Respondent's conduct constitutes a violation of [code section]?

3. [Additional factual issues]

8.2 Legal Issues

1. Whether [specific legal question]?

2. Whether [specific legal question]?

3. [Additional legal issues]

8.3 Penalty Issues (If Liability Established)

1. Whether [proposed sanction] is appropriate given the circumstances?

2. What weight should be given to mitigating factors?

PART IX: LEGAL STANDARD

9.1 Burden of Proof

The burden of proof is on Complainant to prove the charges by [clear and convincing evidence / preponderance of the evidence] pursuant to [citation].

9.2 Elements of Alleged Violations

Cause 1 - [Code Section]

To establish a violation of [code section], Complainant must prove:

1. ___________________________________________________________________________
2. ___________________________________________________________________________
3. ___________________________________________________________________________

Cause 2 - [Code Section]

To establish a violation of [code section], Complainant must prove:

1. ___________________________________________________________________________
2. ___________________________________________________________________________
3. ___________________________________________________________________________

9.3 Applicable Regulations and Standards

The following regulations and standards are applicable to this proceeding:

☐ [Citation and description]
☐ [Citation and description]
☐ [Citation and description]

PART X: ARGUMENT

10.1 Argument Regarding Cause 1 - [Title]

A. Statement of Issue

_________________________________

B. Applicable Law

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

C. Analysis of Evidence

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

D. Application of Law to Facts

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

E. Conclusion on Cause 1

For the foregoing reasons, Cause 1 should be [dismissed / sustained with modification].

10.2 Argument Regarding Cause 2 - [Title]

A. Statement of Issue

_________________________________

B. Applicable Law

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

C. Analysis of Evidence

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

D. Application of Law to Facts

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

E. Conclusion on Cause 2

For the foregoing reasons, Cause 2 should be [dismissed / sustained with modification].

10.3 Affirmative Defenses

☐ Statute of Limitations
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Lack of Jurisdiction
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Procedural Defects
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Good Faith Defense
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Other Affirmative Defenses
_______________________________________________________________________________

10.4 Evidentiary Arguments

A. Evidence That Should Be Excluded

B. Evidence That Should Be Admitted

C. Credibility Arguments

_______________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________________________

10.5 Argument Regarding Appropriate Discipline (If Applicable)

A. Purposes of Professional Discipline

The purpose of professional discipline is to protect the public, not to punish the licensee. [Citation]

B. Aggravating Factors

C. Mitigating Factors

D. Comparable Cases

E. Appropriate Sanction

Based on the foregoing, the appropriate sanction is:

☐ Dismissal
☐ Public reprimand
☐ Probation for _____ years with conditions
☐ Suspension for _____ [days/months/years]
☐ Other: _________________________________

PART XI: PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT (Post-Hearing)

11.1 Proposed Findings

[For post-hearing briefs, include proposed findings of fact]

Finding 1:
_______________________________________________________________________________

Finding 2:
_______________________________________________________________________________

Finding 3:
_______________________________________________________________________________

PART XII: PROPOSED CONCLUSIONS OF LAW (Post-Hearing)

12.1 Proposed Conclusions

Conclusion 1:
_______________________________________________________________________________

Conclusion 2:
_______________________________________________________________________________

Conclusion 3:
_______________________________________________________________________________

PART XIII: CONCLUSION

For all of the foregoing reasons, Respondent respectfully requests that the Administrative Law Judge:

1. ☐ Dismiss the Accusation in its entirety;

2. ☐ In the alternative, find that Complainant has failed to prove [specific causes];

3. ☐ In the alternative, recommend [lesser sanction] rather than [proposed sanction];

4. ☐ Issue a Proposed Decision in accordance with Respondent's Proposed Findings and Conclusions;

5. ☐ Grant such other relief as is just and proper.

STATE-SPECIFIC NOTES

CALIFORNIA

• Government Code Section 11500 et seq. governs
• Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) conducts hearings
• ALJ issues Proposed Decision; agency may adopt, reject, or modify
• Clear and convincing evidence standard for most license cases
• Post-hearing briefs typically due 15-30 days after hearing

TEXAS

• Texas Government Code Chapter 2001 (APA) governs
• State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) conducts hearings
• ALJ issues Proposal for Decision
• Agency makes final decision
• Preponderance of evidence standard unless otherwise specified

FLORIDA

• Chapter 120, Florida Statutes governs
• Division of Administrative Hearings (DOAH) conducts hearings
• ALJ issues Recommended Order
• Agency enters Final Order
• Clear and convincing evidence for license discipline

NEW YORK

• State Administrative Procedure Act governs
• Hearing officers may be agency employees or independent
• Varies by licensing agency
• Substantial evidence standard
• Agency has final decision authority

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on _________________ [date], a true and correct copy of the foregoing brief was served upon:

☐ Administrative Law Judge at:
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Complainant/Agency Counsel at:
_______________________________________________________________________________

☐ Other parties at:
_______________________________________________________________________________

Method of Service:
☐ Personal Service
☐ Certified Mail
☐ Electronic Service
☐ Other: _________________________________

Respectfully submitted,

_________________________________
Attorney for Respondent

Dated: _________________________________

FORMATTING GUIDELINES

General Requirements

Page Limits (Check Local Rules)

EXHIBIT LIST

Template Version 1.0 - Professional Licensing Defense Series