Virginia State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Virginia, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Virginia rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Did a notice of intent preserve a Virginia tax appeal when the complete application was not filed within 90 days?
No. The assessments were issued April 30, 2009, making July 29 the deadline for a complete application stating all grounds and relevant facts. The taxpayer filed a notice of intent on May 28 but never…
Could a bakery and restaurant overturn estimated sales, purchase, and asset tax when its records and exemption certificates were incomplete?
Not on the existing record. Virginia upheld estimates where the bakery and restaurant lacked detailed sales and purchase support, rejected incomplete or questionable exemption certificates, and found …
Could a truss seller remove delivery and design charges from its Virginia audit and receive credit for tax paid to vendors?
Only in part. The seller received 45 days to prove a reasonable delivery amount for this audit, but future exempt delivery charges had to be separately stated. Truss design services remained taxable e…
Was a 1997 Virginia amended return timely for a credit after another state finally taxed part of a retirement lump sum?
Yes. Virginia followed the IRS closing agreement treating the 1997 lump sum as capital gain, a category eligible for the other-state tax credit. The other state's audit became final on October 25, 200…
Could a late 2003 Virginia overpayment claim offset a 2004 assessment after an IRS correction moved retirement income between years?
No. The federal correction became final on October 20, 2006, and Virginia said the amended 2003 return had to be filed by October 22, 2007. The couple waited until April 2008. Even though the same ret…
Could a 2003 overpayment reported on an August 2007 original return be credited against a 2004 Virginia assessment?
No. The three-year period for the 2003 overpayment expired May 1, 2007, and the taxpayer filed the original return on August 29, 2007. Calling the request a credit or carryforward rather than a refund…
Could a taxpayer challenge old Virginia assessments in 2008 when the latest assessment had been issued in May 2001?
No. For these pre-August 15, 2003 assessments, Virginia's then-existing policy accepted an administrative appeal within the three-year period for a judicial remedy. The latest assessment was dated May…
Could Virginia refund a 2003 overpayment when the original return was filed in April 2008 after the refund deadline?
No. Virginia's refund statute required the return or written claim within three years of the timely filing deadline. The April 2008 original return came after the applicable period, even considering t…
Could a taxpayer recover a 2001 Virginia overpayment, or use it against a 2003 balance, after filing the return in January 2008?
No. Even with a valid filing extension, the deadline for a 2001 refund claim expired November 1, 2005. The January 2008 return was too late under Va. Code § 58.1-499(D), so Virginia denied both a refu…
Was a sign fabricator a retailer or real property contractor during 2003-2004, and was its full audit timely?
For this 2003-2004 audit, Virginia treated attached signs as real property and the fabricator-installer as the consuming contractor, so resale and manufacturing exemptions did not apply. The September…
Was a Virginia use-tax appeal timely when the assessment was dated July 8, 2008 and the appeal was mailed in February 2009?
No. Under the 90-day deadline cited in the ruling, the July 8, 2008 assessment had to be appealed by October 6, 2008. The Department's records showed no appeal correspondence until a February 2009 let…
Did a notice of intent preserve a Virginia tax appeal when no complete appeal was filed within the cited 90-day period?
No. The November 3, 2008 assessment required a complete appeal by February 2, 2009 under the 90-day rule quoted in the ruling. A notice of intent did not supply the required grounds and relevant facts…
How much refund could a taxpayer receive after filing a part-year return beyond the normal three-year deadline?
Only one payment qualified. The late part-year return was outside the normal three-year refund period, and no IRS change supported the separate 60-day federal-adjustment rule. Virginia could refund as…
Was a Virginia consumer use-tax appeal timely when the letter was dated one day after the 90-day deadline?
No. The June 18, 2008 assessment had to be appealed by September 16 under the 90-day period quoted in the ruling, but the appeal letter was dated September 17. Virginia treated the protest as time-bar…
Did owning a Virginia home through a qualified personal residence trust and holding Virginia licenses make a long-term foreign couple Virginia domiciliaries?
No. A Virginia QPRT residence and Virginia driver's licenses indicated possible Virginia domicile, but the couple's continuous foreign residence, voting, permanent-residency status, home, and license …
Did a timely notice of intent preserve a Virginia sales-tax appeal when the taxpayer did not submit the grounds for relief within 90 days?
No. A notice saying the taxpayer disagreed and was gathering data was not a complete administrative appeal. Because the taxpayer did not fully state its grounds within 90 days of assessment, the right…
Could financial hardship allow a Virginia income-tax refund when the original returns were filed after the three-year refund deadline?
No. Although tax had been overwithheld, Virginia could not issue refunds for 2000-2003 because the original returns were filed after the three-year limitation period. Financial hardship did not change…
Did a Virginia city's former E-911 tax apply to hundreds of internal phone lines that could not access the local exchange or emergency center?
No. The former E-911 tax applied only to lines accessing the local exchange system and public safety answering point, not private internal communications lines. The city's October 2003-December 2005 a…
Could an insurer claim old use-tax overpayments as return credits and exempt agent-incentive brochures and annual reports?
Only with proper proof and reporting. The insurer had to document overpayments, claim them on the correct return line within three years, and support printed-material exemptions. Internal agent brochu…
Did a notice of intent preserve a Virginia tax appeal when the taxpayer did not file a complete appeal within 90 days?
No. A notice of intent was not a complete appeal. Because the taxpayer did not file the required grounds and relevant facts within 90 days of assessment, the appeal was time-barred and collection resu…
Could an individual appeal a Virginia converted assessment more than a year after the 90-day deadline because he learned of the tax lien later?
No. The individual had 90 days from the April 6, 2006 assessment date, making July 5, 2006 the deadline. His June 29, 2007 appeal was untimely, and neither the statute nor the appeal guidelines create…
Were Virginia income-tax assessments barred when the taxpayer appealed 1997-1999 late and had never filed a 2000 return?
No. The 1997-1999 appeal missed the former three-year administrative window. The 2000 appeal was timely, but because no 2000 return was filed Virginia could assess at any time, and the taxpayer suppli…
Could a sole proprietor challenge 1990-1995 converted tax assessments through an administrative appeal filed in 2007?
No. The latest assessment was issued March 9, 1995, and under Virginia's policy then in effect the administrative appeal was due by March 9, 1998. The 2007 filing was untimely, so Virginia denied abat…
Did a timely notice of intent preserve a Virginia corporate-income-tax appeal when the complete appeal arrived after 90 days?
No. The taxpayer filed a notice of intent before the January 14, 2008 deadline, but that notice did not fully state the grounds needed for an informed determination. The complete appeal arrived Februa…
Was a Virginia sales-tax appeal timely when the letter was dated on the deadline but the fax arrived one week later?
No. Holiday rules moved the deadline to January 2, 2008, but a faxed appeal had to be received by that date. The Department received it January 9, so the appeal was barred. Virginia did not reach the …
Did filing Virginia's Administrative Appeal Form preserve an appeal when the taxpayer never supplied complete grounds and authority?
No. The filed form did not fully identify the alleged errors, relevant facts, remedy, and legal authority required for a complete administrative appeal. Virginia contacted the representative and allow…
Could Virginia consider a retailer's exemption certificates when its administrative appeal was filed after the 90-day deadline?
No. The retailer filed its appeal after the 90-day statutory deadline, so the Tax Commissioner could not consider whether the customer exemption certificates supported the sales. The assessments were …
Was an administrative appeal timely when its letter was dated before the 90-day deadline but the delivery service received it afterward?
No. The delivery service's receipt date controlled the filing date. Although the appeal letter was dated January 10, 2007, the carrier date was February 7, after the January 16 deadline. Virginia ther…
Could a taxpayer challenge 2001 and 2002 Virginia residency assessments by filing an administrative appeal in April 2006?
No. Va. Code § 58.1-1821 required an appeal within 90 days of each assessment. The April 2006 filing came after the April 2004 and April 2005 deadlines, so the Tax Commissioner dismissed it as time-ba…
Could a taxpayer reopen two sales-tax audits to submit records its former bookkeeper had not provided?
Only the timely audit. The appeal from the December 24, 2003 assessment was filed years after Virginia's 90-day deadline, so that audit could not be reopened or supplemented. The appeal for the Septem…
Was Virginia's 2006 assessment recovering an incorrect 2003 out-of-state tax credit issued too late?
No. The refund date was when Virginia applied the amount to the taxpayer's 2004 estimated payments, not when he signed the 2003 return. The incorrect California credit came from information listed by …
Could Virginia consider a corporate tax appeal filed one day after the 90-day deadline?
No. The assessments were dated October 19, 2006, and Virginia counted 90 consecutive calendar days beginning the next day, including weekends and holidays. The deadline was January 17, 2007. Because t…
Could Virginia consider an individual's challenge to corporate-officer assessments filed more than two years after the latest assessment?
No. Virginia did not decide whether the individual was a corporate officer. The latest converted assessment was dated September 17, 2004, making December 16, 2004 the latest 90-day appeal deadline. Hi…
Could Virginia refund an overpayment claimed on a 2002 individual income tax return filed after the three-year refund deadline?
No. The 2002 return was due May 1, 2003, so the refund claim had to reach the Department by May 1, 2006. Because the couple filed in June 2006, Va. Code § 58.1-499 D barred the refund, and the Tax Com…
Did a commercial printer owe Virginia litter tax when it printed envelopes, stationery, brochures, letterhead, and business cards but not newspapers or magazines?
No. Merely printing images on paper did not make the company a manufacturer or seller of covered paper products, and it did not print newspapers or magazines. Virginia ended its litter-tax filing obli…
Could a Maryland commuter recover Virginia tax withheld in error for 1997 through 2000 when the refund claims were not filed until April 2006?
No. Maryland reciprocity meant the commuter's wages were not subject to Virginia withholding, but he had not given his employer the required exemption certificate. More importantly, his April 2006 ref…
Did a notice of intent preserve a Virginia tax appeal when the complete administrative appeal was not filed within 90 days of assessment?
No. The assessment was dated December 22, 2006, making March 22, 2007 the deadline. A March 21 notice stating that a complete appeal would follow did not satisfy or extend the 90-day period, so the ap…
Could Virginia refund 2000 and 2001 tax paid in error after the statutory refund deadline expired?
No. Even though the Maryland resident's wages were described as exempt from Virginia tax and her preparer had filed incorrectly, the 2000 and 2001 refund claims were outside Va. Code § 58.1-1823. The …
Browse Virginia rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Virginia's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.