Virginia State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Virginia, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Virginia rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Is a Virginia Indian tribe exempt from Virginia sales and use tax on purchases it makes off the reservation for use on the reservation?
No. The Virginia Department of Taxation ruled that a federally recognized Indian tribe has no exemption from the retail sales and use tax on purchases it makes off its reservation, even when the items…
Can a Virginia sales tax auditor keep an unusually large month in the audit sample if it skews the error rate applied to the whole audit period?
No -- not if that month isn't representative. Virginia auditors project a tax 'error factor' from a sample of months and extrapolate it across the entire audit period, so the sample must fairly repres…
Can an agricultural dealer get audit exceptions removed for exemption certificates verified after the audit, and must the second-audit compliance penalty stand?
Partly. An agricultural supply dealer was audited for sales lacking valid exemption certificates and for its own untaxed purchases. The Tax Commissioner allowed relief where it could be verified: for …
Can a cigarette retailer escape a resale-tax assessment by claiming the exempt purchases shown in a distributor's records were made without its knowledge?
No, on this record. Virginia's cigarette compliance program matched distributor records showing this retailer bought cigarettes tax-free for resale, then assessed sales tax because those cigarettes sh…
Does the occasional-sale exemption cover a tractor bought from a farmer, and is a trailer bought from a Virginia dealer but picked up out of state subject to Virginia tax?
Split result. A truck-driver training school was assessed use tax on fixed-asset purchases. On the **tractor** it bought from a livestock-and-hay farmer, the Tax Commissioner agreed the occasional-sal…
When an entertainment company bundles a taxable photo-booth rental with exempt disc-jockey services in one contract, is the photo-booth charge taxable?
Yes -- the photo-booth rental is taxable. A wedding and party entertainment company bundled disc-jockey services (exempt) with photo-booth rentals in a single contract and argued the whole package was…
Which items at a meat-processing plant qualify for Virginia's manufacturing exemption, and can the audit penalty be waived as a new area?
Mixed, with the penalty upheld. At a meat-processing plant, Virginia's manufacturing exemption covers property 'used directly' in an integral step of production, not ancillary maintenance (Va. Code Se…
Must a restaurant show free employee meals on payroll or W-2s to claim the wages exemption, or can policy and accounting records prove it?
Yes, exempt -- the restaurant won. The Department had assessed use tax on free meals a restaurant gives employees during shifts, because the value wasn't shown in the payroll account or on W-2 forms. …
How are a restaurant's fiscal-year reporting, free meals to employees' families, and complimentary meal cards treated in a sales tax audit?
Mixed. A five-restaurant operator's audit raised three issues. On its 52-53 week fiscal year, the Department found catch-up payments made its remitted sales tax consistent with its income return, so t…
Are separately stated programming charges and technician 'trip' charges tied to selling audiovisual equipment taxable?
Yes, both are taxable. An audiovisual integrator was assessed sales tax on separately stated 'programming' charges (customizing the AV equipment it sold) and 'trip' charges (sending a technician). It …
Can a restaurant on a 52-53 week fiscal year show that a monthly-based audit sample overstated its unremitted sales tax?
A chance to prove it. A fast food restaurant's audit found it underreported sales tax versus its daily sales reports, treated as tax collected but not remitted. The restaurant said the mismatch came f…
Is a general contractor liable for use tax on payments to subcontractors who furnish and install materials on a real property project?
Mostly for the contractor. A real property construction contractor was assessed consumer use tax on untaxed purchases. The Tax Commissioner removed several items: a computer bought in 2007 (before the…
Can a one-time end-of-lease equipment purchase be pulled out of an audit sample when the taxpayer can't prove the purchased item is the same equipment assessed?
No, on this record. A medical practice that never filed sales or use tax returns was audited using a sample factor extrapolated over the whole period. One sampled item was the exercise of an end-of-le…
Can a Virginia contractor that paid Virginia sales tax on materials used in a North Carolina project get a Virginia credit or refund through a reciprocity agreement?
No relief. A Virginia real property contractor paid Virginia sales tax on materials it used on a North Carolina construction project and asked whether a reciprocity agreement could give it a credit to…
When a cigarette retailer cannot document its resale purchases, can Virginia assess tax from distributor records, and is a new owner liable for the prior owner's cigarette sales tax?
Mostly upheld, with one credit. A cigarette retailer could not produce sales records, bank statements, or purchase invoices, so the Department used distributor records of the retailer's tax-free (for …
Does the ISP equipment exemption cover wholesale Internet access and 100%-exempt mixed-use claims, and can a refund be denied for unverified transactions?
Refund denied. This is one of three materially identical companion determinations the Department issued the same day (May 12, 2020) to related Internet service providers -- see P.D. 20-80 (the fuller …
Does the ISP equipment exemption cover wholesale Internet sales and 100%-exempt mixed-use claims, and can a refund be denied for unverified transactions?
Refund denied. This is one of three materially identical companion determinations the Department issued the same day (May 12, 2020) to related Internet service providers -- see P.D. 20-80 (the fuller …
Does the Internet service provider (ISP) equipment exemption cover wholesale Internet sales and mixed-use equipment, and can a refund be denied for unverified transactions?
Refund denied. The Internet service provider (ISP) equipment exemption (Va. Code Sec. 58.1-609.6 2) reaches only equipment used to provide Internet access to end-user subscribers -- retail ISPs -- not…
Can Virginia estimate a use tax assessment from a contractor's income tax returns, and use a six-year period, when the contractor did not provide records or file sales tax returns?
Upheld, with one more chance. A real property contractor with a Virginia location never filed Virginia sales and use tax returns and did not respond to the auditor's repeated requests for records or t…
In a fuel dealer's audit, which sales qualified as exempt home heating fuel, and when do manufacturing or government exemptions and out-of-state certificates fail?
Partly won. This fuel dealer's audit was adjusted but mostly upheld. Home heating oil, gas, coal, or firewood sold to an individual for non-business use is exempt for domestic consumption (Va. Code Se…
Does the ISP equipment exemption cover wholesale Internet access and 100%-exempt mixed-use claims, and can a refund be denied for unverified transactions?
Refund denied. This May 5, 2020 determination is part of the same materially identical series of Internet service provider refund rulings as P.D. 20-80 (the fuller companion) and P.D. 20-81 and 20-82 …
Does a building-supply retailer's lumber mill shop qualify for the industrial manufacturing exemption when milling is only 12-15% of the business?
No exemption. A business that sells building materials at retail and also runs a lumber mill shop making custom millwork asked whether its mill equipment qualifies for the industrial manufacturing exe…
What happens when a taxpayer supplies, on appeal, the audit documentation it could not produce during the audit itself?
Closed and referred back. The taxpayer's whole appeal turned on documentation it could not provide during the audit. Because it supplied that documentation on appeal, the Department referred it to the…
Is cloud-delivered software exempt from Virginia use tax, are out-of-state-shipped purchases exempt, and can a third-generation audit's compliance and amnesty penalties be waived?
Mixed, with relief. This government contractor's use tax audit was adjusted on several fronts. Software from two vendors was cloud-based software-as-a-service, so it was electronically delivered and e…
Are monthly charges for contractor-owned standby generators at Virginia grocery stores taxable equipment leases or exempt power services?
They were exempt service charges. The contractor owned, installed, monitored, maintained, fueled, and ultimately removed the generation systems; the grocery operator never possessed or could buy them …
Can a Virginia cigarette wholesaler defeat a sales-tax assessment with resale certificates and invoices obtained only after the audit began?
No. The wholesaler obtained two resale certificates only after the audit started, so they were not treated as accepted in good faith and required independent validation. Both customers' registrations …
Could two restaurants overturn estimated Virginia sales-tax assessments based on income returns and comparable businesses when they lacked verifiable sales records, and did first-audit penalties apply?
The estimated tax stood, but the compliance penalty was waived. Because the restaurants lacked adequate records and their reported figures were inconsistent or unverifiable, the auditor reasonably use…
When may a Virginia equipment distributor rely on cable-television and resale exemption certificates, and which purchases remain taxable?
Mixed. The distributor properly accepted a cable customer's Form ST-20 in good faith for equipment used to broadcast, amplify, transmit, or distribute cable signals, and properly accepted a facially v…
What happens when a Virginia taxpayer first supplies documents supporting a sales-tax refund claim during the administrative appeal?
The Department closed the appeal and referred the new documents to field audit staff to review the refund claim and revise it as appropriate. If issues remained after the refund audit revision, the ta…
How long does a Virginia taxpayer have to request reconsideration of a final Tax Commissioner determination?
Forty-five days under 23 VAC 10-20-165 F. The taxpayer asked on September 18, 2019 to reconsider P.D. 19-49, issued May 8, 2019, well after the deadline. Further review was barred, P.D. 19-49 remained…
What happens when a Virginia sales-tax taxpayer first provides supporting audit documentation during its administrative appeal?
The Department closed the appeal and sent the newly supplied documentation to field audit staff for review and any appropriate audit adjustments. If issues remained after the auditor revised the audit…
Was a Virginia cable, internet, and telephone provider entitled to a sales-and-use-tax refund for thousands of equipment purchases without item-specific proof of exempt use?
No. Cable-television and internet amplification, transmission, and distribution equipment could qualify for Virginia's exemption, but telephone-service equipment did not qualify after the public-servi…
Are easy-return-label fees, logo setup and embroidery, combined shipping-and-handling charges, and a resale sale taxable in Virginia?
Mostly yes. Easy-return-label fees were taxable because they paid for purchaser-to-seller return delivery, not exempt seller-to-purchaser transportation, and remained tied to the original merchandise …
Can a cigarette wholesaler avoid use tax on resale purchases when its exemption certificates are incomplete or belong to another supplier?
Partly. A cigarette wholesaler assessed use tax on exempt resale purchases wins relief only for sales it can properly document. The Department accepted the wholesaler's sales invoices (rejecting the a…
Are nonmonitored fire alarm systems taxable, and can a taxpayer pull a vendor's untaxed purchases out of an audit sample by calling them a one-time glitch?
Nonmonitored fire and alarm systems are taxable sales of tangible personal property (only separately stated installation is exempt), so the contractor's purchases of subcontracted fire safety systems …
When will Virginia accept resale documentation for exempt sales, and when can it uphold an estimated sales-tax assessment because a dealer's records cannot be reconciled?
Virginia gave the seller narrow relief for Customer A because a prior Department determination had accepted an undated resale letter without clearly limiting that acceptance to the earlier audit; thos…
Are purchases and leases of computer equipment between affiliated Virginia companies exempt as internal transfers when the entities charge each other?
No. Virginia treated the automotive dealership and its affiliate as separate entities, not two locations of one company. Department records showed the dealership had reported under its own FEIN since …
Can a Virginia heavy-construction contractor avoid use tax by saying its purchases served exempt mining or gas work, belonged to end users, or predated an ownership change?
Not without transaction-specific proof. The contractor supplied no evidence that contested assets were used directly and predominantly in qualifying mining, natural-gas, oil, or legally required recla…
Does a Virginia resort owe sales tax when guests redeem donated gift certificates for lodging and when venue customers pay a garbage-disposal fee?
Yes. Donating gift certificates to nonprofits and receiving no cash when guests redeemed them did not make the lodging free or exempt. The certificate's original sale was not taxable, but redemption p…
When did Virginia's 2019 economic-nexus law require remote sellers and marketplace facilitators to register, collect tax, source sales, and track direct versus facilitated transactions?
Beginning July 1, 2019, a remote seller or marketplace facilitator with more than $100,000 of annual Virginia retail-sales revenue or at least 200 Virginia transactions in the current or prior calenda…
Can a Virginia UPS-system seller obtain a refund for a data-center sale when the contractor supplied a valid Department exemption letter only after the transaction?
Possibly, but only after transaction-specific verification. At the time of sale, the seller correctly collected tax because it had no valid Department-issued data-center exemption certificate. The con…
Did telecommunications equipment and software sales qualify for Virginia's retail ISP or electronic-delivery exemptions, and when was dealer refund interest payable?
The additional tax refunds were denied, but refund interest was allowed on amounts already approved. Wireless providers can qualify for Virginia's ISP equipment exemption, yet the seller did not prove…
How did Virginia's June 2019 accelerated sales-tax payment work, including the $4 million threshold, 90% calculation, reconciliation, penalties, and hardship waivers?
For June 2019, a dealer with at least $4 million of taxable sales and/or purchases during July 1, 2017 through June 30, 2018 had to prepay 90% of its June 2018 retail sales and use tax liability. All …
Could a restaurant member remove converted sales-tax assessments by saying her late husband alone managed finances when Department records listed her as a member?
Not on the unsupported statement alone. Individual liability under Va. Code § 58.1-1813 requires willfulness, a covered officer/member/employee role with a duty concerning the tax, knowledge of the fa…
Could a Virginia horse-boarding stable buy feed and supplies under the agricultural exemption, and could Virginia extend its use-tax audit from three to six years?
No exemption applied. Virginia requires production of an agricultural product for market, while stable operators must pay tax on operating property and feed for riding or pleasure horses is expressly …
Can a Virginia seller claim good-faith reliance on resale certificates that lack a date, valid registration number, or the specific exemption?
No. Virginia presumes sales taxable unless the dealer accepts a valid exemption certificate in good faith. A certificate incomplete, invalid, infirm, or inconsistent on its face is never acceptable wi…
Could a Virginia retailer invalidate a two-month purchase sample projected over a 36-month audit when it agreed the months were representative but lacked invoices?
No. At the audit's start, the specialty retailer confirmed that the two chosen months represented the full January 2015-December 2017 period. When it could not produce all requested invoices, the audi…
Could a convenience store disprove Virginia's cigarette-sales reconstruction using purchase records from one distributor location when the distributor report covered the full membership account?
No. The distributor's data identified all tax-free cigarette purchases under the convenience store's membership account, potentially across multiple distributor locations. Virginia compared that total…
Should a one-time end-of-lease equipment purchase be removed from a Virginia audit sample when the taxpayer cannot identify the property on the lease or invoice?
Not on this record. Virginia agreed that a one-time end-of-lease purchase could be nonrepresentative and clarified that property need not be booked as a fixed asset before it may be removed from a sam…
Could a cigarette retailer overturn reconstructed sales, penalty, and interest by asserting below-cost rebate sales when it supplied no sales or inventory records?
No. Distributor records showed cigarette cartons bought tax-free for resale far exceeded the cigarette sales the retailer reported. Virginia notified the retailer, requested purchase, resale, and tax-…
Which construction purchases stayed taxable when a Virginia contractor challenged tax on building parts, school equipment, signs, hardware, and markerboards?
Virginia reached a mixed result. Prefabricated metal building parts stayed in the audit because tax paid by the Virginia seller to its own manufacturer did not prove tax on the separate sale to the co…
Were amusement-center party packages taxable in full when they combined gaming admissions with food, and could phone advice erase the assessment?
Yes, the full package charge was taxable. Standalone admissions or participation charges may be exempt, but Virginia's admissions rule taxes a cover or minimum charge that includes food, drinks, or ot…
Could a sign manufacturer remove service, billboard, freight, and church transactions from audit without documents proving the claimed exemptions?
No. Virginia upheld all twelve invoice adjustments. Labor, surveys, permits, removal, and a second-trip charge were treated as services connected with sales of signs, power supplies, or other property…
Were coordination and computer-time charges tied to graphics taxable, and was a copier maintenance agreement that could supply parts taxed in part?
Yes. The custom exhibit company sold services together with graphics, and Virginia found the true object was production of tangible graphics. Coordination labor, artist time, and computer time connect…
Did buying all assets of one division qualify as an exempt occasional sale when the seller continued operating and separate-division proof was missing?
Not on the evidence provided. A sale of all or substantially all assets of a separate and distinct division can qualify even when the larger company continues operating. But Virginia evaluates whether…
Did Virginia reconsider a denied satellite-equipment refund because the regulation's broadcasting definition supposedly changed the law?
No. Reconsideration required a timely showing that applicable law changed for the refund period or that Virginia misapplied policy in a way that would change the result. The equipment retailer argued …
Could Virginia extend the three-year refund deadline for tax paid after the 2013 rate increase when the purchaser did not know the refund process?
No. The medical provider's March 2013 equipment contract and July 2013 delivery fit the Department's transition window for the July 1 rate increase, but any refund still had to be requested within the…
How did Virginia treat an incomplete resale certificate, later trade-in rebates, out-of-state purchases, and audit penalty in a Navy contractor audit?
Virginia reached mixed results. An undated resale certificate missing the supplier name could not be accepted in good faith, and the customer was registered for consumer use tax rather than retail sal…
Could a water-system contractor buy lining and repair materials for resale to governments or claim pollution-control exemption without project certification?
No. Rehabilitated water and wastewater pipes and systems became real-property fixtures, so Va. Code § 58.1-610(A) treated the contractor as the user or consumer of lining and repair materials, not a r…
Could a Virginia subsidiary recover use tax on parent-company software support allocations by proving electronic delivery, and could foreign VAT offset Virginia tax?
The software refund remained possible if documented; the VAT credit did not. Charges between separately incorporated related entities can be taxable sales because intercompany accounting entries const…
Browse Virginia rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Virginia's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.