Virginia State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Virginia, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Virginia rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
I work for the U.S. Department of State and moved to Virginia partway through the year for a work assignment based elsewhere -- does Virginia tax my whole year of income, and can I still claim credit for tax I paid to my home state?
No -- Virginia only taxes you as a resident from the date you actually move in, not for the whole year, even if you end up physically present more than 183 days total. A State Department employee leas…
The Department audited my construction business and reclassified my independent contractors as employees, hitting me with a withholding tax assessment -- what factors actually decide whether my workers are really independent contractors?
In this case, independent contractor status held up -- and the ruling lays out exactly which factors decided it. The Department evaluates worker classification using the IRS's three-category common-la…
I run my farm as a sole proprietorship, but the agricultural best-management-practices tax credit certificate was issued under the farm's own employer ID number rather than my Social Security number -- can I still claim it on my personal return?
Yes. A sole proprietor can claim Virginia's agricultural best-management-practices tax credit on his personal income tax return even though the credit certificate was issued under the farm's own feder…
My business didn't keep adequate sales records, so the auditor reconstructed our sales from bank deposits and then added a 25% markup on top for undocumented cash sales -- can they do that, and do I still owe the first-time penalty?
Split result: reconstructing sales from bank statements was proper, but the extra 25% markup on top of that and the standard penalty were both removed. A drone, RC vehicle, and toy retailer couldn't p…
I sold stock in a private tech company and claimed Virginia's long-term capital gain subtraction, but the company won't share its revenue figures with me -- can the Department still deny my subtraction just because I can't prove it met the $3 million revenue cap?
Yes -- the taxpayer, not the Department, has the burden of proving a qualifying business met the required revenue threshold, and the Department doesn't have to disprove it on the taxpayer's behalf. A …
My nonprofit is domiciled in Virginia and owns limited-partnership interests that allocate income to other states -- can I exclude that out-of-state income from my Virginia UBTI?
No -- because the Taxpayer is domiciled in Virginia, it can't use its limited-partnership interests' out-of-state income allocations to shrink its Virginia UBTI. Virginia law has no separate-accountin…
I'm a Virginia resident who paid California tax and claimed a credit on my Virginia return -- why did Virginia deny it and tell me to go get the credit from California instead?
Because California is one of a handful of "reverse credit" states (along with Arizona, Oregon, and D.C.), Virginia residents who pay California tax generally must claim their credit on a CALIFORNIA no…
I took a distribution from a 403(b) retirement account, and my contributions to it were taxed by another state when I made them -- can I subtract the ENTIRE distribution from my Virginia income, or only part of it?
Only part of it -- Virginia's retirement income subtraction uses a pro-rata formula, not a full exclusion of the entire distribution. A couple took a distribution from the husband's 403(b) retirement …
My city assessed business personal property tax on equipment that's broken or idle and on a consumable supply item -- do I owe tax on all of it?
It depends on the item, and the taxpayer only partly won. The Tax Commissioner sent one disputed item (equipment the taxpayer claimed was returned to the manufacturer) back to the City for another cha…
We built a clean room inside our leased research facility using pre-fabricated walls -- does that count as tax-exempt research and development equipment, or did it become part of the building (and taxable real property) once installed?
It stayed exempt research-and-development equipment rather than becoming taxable real property -- but only because the taxpayer could show its lease required removing everything at the end of the term…
My airline buys food and beverages from a caterer to serve passengers for free during flights -- does our common-carrier sales tax exemption cover those purchases?
No. Virginia's sales tax exemption for airlines operating as common carriers only covers property used directly in actually transporting passengers -- it doesn't extend to food, snacks, and beverages …
Does raw material that just sits and ages in a Virginia warehouse before being shipped out of state for manufacturing count as being 'used' in Virginia for corporate income tax apportionment purposes?
No -- the Virginia Supreme Court held that raw leaf tobacco simply stored and naturally aging in a Virginia warehouse, with no active steps taken by the company, is not "used" in Virginia within the m…
I'm a Virginia resident who commutes to a job in Maryland and had Maryland tax withheld from my paycheck -- can I claim a Virginia credit for that Maryland tax, or do I need to get it back from Maryland directly? And can Virginia at least waive the interest on my assessment?
No to both. Virginia has a reciprocal tax agreement with Maryland (also West Virginia and Pennsylvania) that exempts Virginia residents who commute into Maryland from Maryland tax on their wages in th…
My spouse took a fixed two-year federal government posting abroad, and we moved our bank accounts, phones, and health insurance there -- but we'd always planned to move to a different U.S. state once the assignment ended. Did we successfully abandon our Virginia domicile?
No -- a temporary, fixed-term overseas work assignment generally doesn't establish a new domicile, especially when the taxpayers' own plan was to move somewhere else entirely once the assignment ended…
My business's sales tax audit found a compliance ratio just under Virginia's 85% threshold, and we've generally filed and paid on time for years -- can we get the compliance and amnesty penalties waived?
No -- Virginia's compliance penalty is mandatory once your audit compliance ratio falls short of the regulatory threshold, and being a generally diligent filer in other years isn't the kind of 'provid…
I sold my business years ago, but the county still assessed ME for tangible personal property tax on it for years after the sale -- can I appeal that dispute to the state Department of Taxation?
No -- not through the Department. The Department's jurisdiction over local business tangible personal property tax appeals is limited to reviewing whether an ASSESSMENT itself (the tax rate, the taxab…
I paid long-term care insurance premiums and listed them on my federal Schedule A, but my total medical expenses were under the deduction floor so I never actually got a federal tax benefit for them -- can I still claim Virginia's deduction? And can I subtract retirement income from an IRA I funded with military pay while filing returns in Pennsylvania?
Split result. Yes on the long-term care premium deduction: Virginia bars it only if you actually CLAIMED a federal deduction for the same premiums, and because this couple's total medical expenses fel…
I moved to another state for a new job, got a driver's license and voted there, but kept my unexpired Virginia driver's license and a car titled with my dad -- did I successfully change my domicile away from Virginia?
Yes -- this taxpayer successfully established a new domicile outside Virginia, a useful contrast to cases where a similar move failed. She took a new job in another state in late 2016 intending to sta…
The IRS increased our federal income and Virginia adjusted our return to match -- so why did our Virginia taxable income go up by MORE than our federal income did?
Because Virginia's age-65 deduction phases out dollar-for-dollar once your adjusted federal adjusted gross income (FAGI) passes $50,000 (single) or $75,000 (married), a federal income increase near or…
I missed Virginia's 90-day appeal deadline for a sales tax audit because the audit notice was mailed to an old business address -- can I still get the assessment corrected?
Not through a normal appeal -- Virginia's 90-day appeal deadline runs from when an assessment is mailed to the address the Department has on file, even if that address is no longer current, because it…
My tax preparer submitted our Virginia Research and Development Expenses Tax Credit application 8 days after the September 1 deadline -- can we still get the credit since the delay wasn't our fault?
No -- Virginia's Research and Development Expenses Tax Credit application deadline (September 1 of the year following the tax year) is enforced with zero discretion, and reliance on a tax preparer's m…
A foreign country withheld tax from my pension but I wasn't required to file a tax return there -- can I still claim Virginia's credit for tax paid to a foreign country without filing that foreign return?
Yes -- this taxpayer won. Virginia's credit for tax paid to a foreign country on pension or retirement income only requires proof that the foreign tax was actually paid, not proof that a foreign tax r…
I moved out of Virginia years ago, but I renewed my Virginia driver's license after the move and didn't switch my voter registration until much later -- does that mean I never actually gave up Virginia domicile for tax purposes?
Yes, on these facts -- renewing (not just holding onto) a Virginia driver's license years after your claimed move date is treated as very strong evidence you never actually abandoned Virginia domicile…
The Department is trying to collect my former employer's unpaid sales and withholding taxes from me personally because I was a shift manager there -- can they do that if I never had access to the bank account or authority over which bills got paid?
No -- this taxpayer won. Virginia can only convert a corporation's unpaid tax debt to an individual 'responsible officer' if all four parts of a strict statutory test are met: the person willfully fai…
The IRS never questioned my Schedule C vehicle expense deduction -- can Virginia still audit and disallow it if I can't produce documentation when asked?
Yes -- Virginia generally relies on the accuracy of your federal return, but it keeps independent authority to demand supporting documentation for any deduction and to disallow it if you don't provide…
I lived and worked in Virginia all year but funded my IRA years earlier in a state with no income tax, and I treated half of it as my spouse's community property -- can I subtract any of my Virginia IRA distribution, and can I get interest waived because a Department employee gave my preparer wrong advice over the phone?
No to all three arguments. Virginia's retirement-income subtraction only covers IRA distributions to the extent the original contributions were actually taxed by another state -- since this taxpayer's…
I filed my Virginia return more than three years late because of personal issues, and I thought I automatically had until November to file -- can I still get my overpayment refunded?
No -- because these taxpayers never actually filed their return within Virginia's automatic six-month extension period either, the extension was negated entirely and the three-year refund clock ran fr…
The IRS accepted our Schedule C and Form 2106 deductions across three tax years with no questions -- can Virginia still audit and disallow them for all three years if we can't produce documentation when asked?
Yes -- Virginia's independent authority to demand documentation for a federal-form deduction applies year after year, and this ruling shows it enforced across three full tax years at once. These taxpa…
I was converted a responsible officer for my restaurant company's unpaid sales tax, and I have records that would lower the assessment -- but I haven't been able to get them together yet. Can I still get the assessment corrected?
No -- promising to gather supporting documentation isn't the same as actually providing it, and this taxpayer's assessment was upheld because he never followed through. He was the president and minori…
I moved out of Virginia and set up a home, license, and voter registration in another state, but I never gave up my Virginia driver's license or voter registration -- have I actually changed my domicile for tax purposes?
No -- changing your domicile requires both abandoning your old home state AND establishing a new one, and here the husband only showed the second half. He had real ties to his new state (State A) -- p…
The IRS adjusted my 2013 return back in 2016, but I never reported it to Virginia because I believe (and am still contesting with the IRS) that their adjustment itself was made after their own deadline had passed -- can Virginia still assess me years later?
Yes -- once a taxpayer fails to file an amended Virginia return reporting a federal change, Virginia can assess the resulting tax at any time, with no statute-of-limitations shield, and the Department…
When a customer's leased equipment is totaled and they pay us a settlement under the lease's total-loss clause, does Virginia sales tax apply to that payment?
Yes, generally -- a payment a lessee makes under an equipment lease's total-loss clause is taxable in its entirety as part of the lease's gross proceeds, with no deduction allowed for the property's c…
An auditor is disallowing exemption certificates from several of my automotive customers because some are undated, some are dated well after the sale, and one is from a volunteer fire department -- which of these actually hold up?
It's a mixed result that turns on the specific certificate and customer, not a blanket rule. Undated exemption certificates and ones dated well after the sale don't get automatic good-faith protection…
My cold storage facility chills and freezes food products for customers -- does that count as industrial processing so I can buy equipment and pallets tax-exempt?
No -- to qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing/processing sales tax exemption, a business must be classified as 'industrial in nature' under the SIC/NAICS-based test in Va. Code § 58.1-602, …
The auditor estimated my underreported sales by comparing my federal and state tax returns, and I submitted my bank deposit records to challenge it -- why wasn't that enough to fix the assessment?
Because the bank records this retailer submitted only covered credit card deposits and left out cash sales entirely, they couldn't reliably show the true total of sales -- so they didn't meet the burd…
I moved out of Virginia for work years ago but kept my old house as a rental, a car co-registered with my mother, my Virginia driver's license until recently, and an old inactive voter registration -- did I still manage to change my domicile out of Virginia?
Yes -- this taxpayer successfully changed his domicile away from Virginia, even though he kept several Virginia connections, because the Department found credible, non-domicile-driven explanations for…
As a federally recognized Indian tribe, are we exempt from Virginia retail sales tax on purchases we make off our reservation for goods we bring back to use on the reservation?
No -- federal recognition and tribal sovereignty protect a tribe's activities within its own reservation boundaries, but once a tribe or its members go beyond the reservation to make a purchase, they'…
I'm a Virginia resident who owns a stake in a partnership or LLC that elected Maryland's entity-level 'PTE SALT cap workaround' tax -- can I claim a Virginia credit for the tax Maryland collected from the entity?
It depends entirely on what kind of pass-through entity you own. If you're a Virginia resident shareholder of an S-corporation that elects Maryland's entity-level PTE tax, Virginia law specifically tr…
The auditor disallowed my student loan interest adjustment, my employee business expenses, and almost all my itemized deductions -- I sent copies of my tax bills and medical invoices, so why wasn't that enough?
Because invoices and bills only show what you OWED, not that you actually PAID it -- and Virginia requires proof of payment (receipts, cancelled checks, or similar) to substantiate deductions like pro…
I paid DC's Unincorporated Business Franchise Tax on my business income -- can I claim Virginia's credit for taxes paid to another state to avoid being taxed twice on the same income?
No -- the District of Columbia's Unincorporated Business Franchise Tax (UBFT) is specifically excluded from Virginia's credit for taxes paid to another state, and that's true even though denying the c…
We got a refund of the Virginia tax withheld from my wife's wages when we filed our part-year-resident return, but Virginia later assessed us on those same wages -- can we still use that withholding to pay the new bill?
No -- once withholding has already been refunded, it can't be used a second time to offset a later assessment on the same wages. A married couple filed a joint part-year Virginia return for 2018 repor…
My Form W-2 lists 100% of my wages as Virginia state wages because I asked my employer to withhold Virginia tax as a convenience, but I only actually worked a small fraction of my days in Virginia -- can I still allocate my wages based on actual days worked instead?
Yes -- this taxpayer won. A nonresident's Virginia wages should be allocated using the ratio of actual days worked in Virginia to total days worked everywhere, and the state-wages box on a Form W-2 is…
I moved back to Virginia partway through the year and filed a part-year return -- can I exclude the income I earned before my move when computing Virginia's low-income credit?
No -- a part-year resident's income earned before moving to Virginia still counts toward the income threshold for Virginia's low-income credit, even though only the post-move income is actually taxed …
My sales tax appeal was postmarked just 9 days after the 90-day deadline -- can the Department still consider it?
No -- Virginia strictly enforces its 90-day appeal deadline with no exception for a short delay, and this appeal was barred even though it missed the deadline by only 9 days. The taxpayer's sales and …
My timeshare association collects cleaning fees from unit owners and pays them straight through to an outside cleaning company -- can we exclude those fees from our BPOL gross receipts as a pure pass-through?
No -- because the timeshare owners themselves had no direct contractual relationship with the cleaning vendor, the association wasn't acting as their legal agent, so the fees it collected and passed a…
We're a cable company subsidiary that's already lost this exact BPOL situsing argument for earlier tax years in two prior published rulings -- can we get a different result for later years by raising a new federal court case?
No -- with no meaningful change in the company's actual operations, the Department reached the exact same conclusion it had already reached twice before for this same taxpayer's earlier tax years: all…
My timeshare association collects cleaning fees from unit owners and pays them straight through to an outside cleaning company -- can we exclude those fees from our BPOL gross receipts as a pure pass-through?
No -- because the timeshare owners themselves had no direct contractual relationship with the cleaning vendor, the association wasn't acting as their legal agent, so the fees it collected and passed a…
The county hasn't issued a final decision on my manufacturing property tax appeal in over a year -- can I go around the county and appeal directly to the state, and will my manufacturer exemption still hold up?
Yes -- when a locality lets a BTPP tax appeal sit for more than a year without issuing a final determination, the taxpayer can go over its head and appeal directly to the Department, as long as it giv…
I work and live abroad most of the year for my job, but my family has been steadily building up Virginia ties -- a condo, driver's licenses, voter registration, a business -- while I mostly just visit in summers. Am I a Virginia resident for tax purposes?
Based on the specific facts presented, probably not yet a Virginia domiciliary resident -- but this is an unusually cautious ruling in which the Department expressly declined to give a firm, final ans…
I'm an artist who painted a custom mural on canvas panels that were installed into a train station -- is my entire charge for the artwork and installation subject to Virginia sales tax?
Yes -- because the customer's whole purpose was to end up with the physical painted canvasses installed in the building, not just to purchase the artist's creative services in the abstract, the entire…
My company mostly markets and services loans for an out-of-state bank, but a city reclassified my whole business as 'financial services' and denied my out-of-state deduction because the loan-related tax I pay is a Utah franchise tax, not technically an income tax -- is that right?
No to both of the city's moves -- the company won on appeal. A company ran an online financial wellness program from its only Virginia office, marketing and servicing loans issued by a Utah bank (abou…
I was only a minority shareholder when my corporation fell behind on its taxes, then later became the sole owner -- can Virginia hold me personally liable for taxes from before I owned the whole company?
It depends on when you actually became a 'responsible officer' under Virginia's four-part legal test -- and the answer can split by time period for the same person. A Virginia corporation was assessed…
I took a temporary federal job requiring me to live near Virginia for years and even registered a vehicle there -- does that mean I became domiciled in Virginia for tax purposes?
Not automatically -- living somewhere for work, even for years, isn't domicile unless you actually abandon your old home state with no intent to return. A federal employee took a temporary position re…
My cold storage business freezes and chills customers' food products before shipping them out -- does my refrigeration equipment qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing and processing sales tax exemption?
No -- a business whose predominant activity is refrigerated storage, not manufacturing, doesn't qualify, even if it also does some freezing. A Virginia cold storage company asked whether an industrial…
My cold storage business freezes and chills customers' food products before shipping them out -- does my refrigeration equipment qualify for Virginia's industrial manufacturing and processing sales tax exemption?
No -- a business whose predominant activity is refrigerated storage, not manufacturing, doesn't qualify, even if it also does some freezing. This ruling is Virginia's word-for-word duplicate publicati…
My use tax compliance ratio came out to 0% on a second sales tax audit because of heavy employee turnover during the audit period -- does that turnover excuse the penalty?
No -- employee turnover doesn't excuse a mandatory compliance penalty, though the underlying tax bill itself could still be reduced with the right paperwork. A utility inspection services company was …
A federal Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS) retiree sued Virginia a second time over its tax treatment of his pension -- what happened, and does it help anyone else make the same argument?
It was dismissed at trial before the court ever reached the merits. This is the bare Circuit Court of the City of Richmond Order in a federal Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS) retiree's second la…
The county estimated my business tangible property and merchant's capital tax using a PRIOR owner's sales and inventory numbers, and its final determination didn't clearly explain how it calculated my bill -- do I have to accept that?
No -- not when the locality's own explanation doesn't clearly show how it reached its numbers. A business failed to file complete business tangible personal property (BTPP) and merchant's capital tax …
I bought used business equipment from another company -- can the city value it based on what I actually paid, or does it have to use the ORIGINAL owner's purchase price when the equipment was new?
The city has to use the original purchase price paid by the FIRST owner when the property was new -- not what you paid to acquire it used. A business bought used tangible personal property from anothe…
I already claimed Virginia's historic rehabilitation tax credit on my building -- can I still claim the separate land preservation tax credit within five years if my conservation easement includes façade restrictions, as long as an appraisal shows those restrictions don't add any value to the easement?
Yes -- if a qualified appraisal actually shows the building-façade portion of the easement adds no value, the building doesn't count as part of the land preservation credit's basis, so the five-year e…
Browse Virginia rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Virginia's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.