Is a mutual redevelopment company organized and operating under Article 5 of the Private Housing Finance Law subject to the Article 9-A corporation franchise tax?

Plain-English summary

Sunnylane of Bethpage Redevelopment Company Owners Corp I and II are cooperative housing corporations -- affordable retirement communities in the Town of Oyster Bay -- each formed as a mutual redevelopment company under Article 5 of the Private Housing Finance Law (PHFL). They sought confirmation that they are not subject to the Article 9-A franchise tax.

The Department agreed they are exempt:

• Section 209.4 of the Tax Law provides that housing companies organized and operating pursuant to Article 5 of the PHFL are not subject to Article 9-A.
• A redevelopment company may be created as a corporation under Article 5 (PHFL section 103), with the Business Corporation Law applying except where it conflicts (PHFL section 105).
• Because Corp I and Corp II are organized and operating under Article 5 of the PHFL, they fall squarely within the section 209.4 exemption.

The opinion notes the companies also qualify as cooperative housing corporations under IRC section 216 (so shareholders get the related personal deductions) and operate on a not-for-profit basis under local PILOT arrangements -- but the controlling point is the section 209.4 PHFL exemption.

What this means for you

The exemption is statutory and specific

Article 5 PHFL housing companies are exempt from Article 9-A by the express terms of section 209.4 -- there is no need to analyze "doing business."

Organized and operating under Article 5 is the test

The exemption turns on the company being both organized under and operating pursuant to Article 5 of the PHFL.

Cooperative-housing status is a separate benefit

Qualifying as an IRC section 216 cooperative housing corporation gives the resident shareholders personal-level deductions, but the franchise-tax exemption rests on the PHFL/section 209.4 status.

Common questions

Q: Does an Article 5 PHFL redevelopment company owe Article 9-A franchise tax?
A: No. Section 209.4 exempts housing companies organized and operating under Article 5 of the PHFL.

Q: Does it matter that the company is a Business Corporation Law corporation?
A: No. Article 5 redevelopment companies can be BCL corporations; the Business Corporation Law applies except where it conflicts with Article 5.

Q: Are the shareholders affected?
A: The corporations also qualify as IRC section 216 cooperative housing corporations, so shareholders may receive the related personal deductions.

Citations and references

Statutes, regulations, and authorities:
- Tax Law section 209.4 (exemption for housing companies under Article 5 of the PHFL)
- Private Housing Finance Law Article 5, sections 103 and 105 (redevelopment companies)
- Business Corporation Law section 402 (incorporation)
- IRC section 216 (cooperative housing corporation)
- Sunnylane of Bethpage Redevelopment Company Owners Corp I and II, TSB-A-99(24)C (Sept. 24, 1999)

Source

• Landing page: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/advisory_opinions/corporation_ao_1999.htm
• Opinion: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/advisory_opinions/corporation/a99_24c.pdf

Original ruling text

New York State Department of Taxation and Finance

Taxpayer Services Division
Technical Services Bureau

TSB-A-99(24)C
Corporation Tax
September 24, 1999

STATE OF NEW YORK
COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION AND FINANCE
ADVISORY OPINION

PETITION NO. C990720B

On July 20, 1999, Petitions for Advisory Opinion were received from Sunnylane of Bethpage
Redevelopment Company Owners Corp I, and Sunnylane of Bethpage Redevelopment Company
Owners Corp II, c/o Total Community Management, 2375 Bedford Ave, Bellmore, New York
11710-3620. The Petitions have been consolidated and are addressed in this Advisory Opinion.
The issue raised by Petitioners, Sunnylane of Bethpage Redevelopment Company Owners
Corp I ("Corp I"), and Sunnylane of Bethpage Redevelopment Company Owners Corp II ("Corp II"),
is whether they are subject to franchise tax under Article 9-A of the Tax Law.
Petitioners submit the following facts as the basis for this Advisory Opinion.
Corp I was formed as mutual redevelopment company on or about August 31, 1995 pursuant
to Article 5 of the Private Housing Finance Law of New York State, as amended ("Article 5 of the
PHFL"), and is a corporation organized under section 402 of the Business Corporation Law. Corp
II was formed as a mutual redevelopment company on or about August 28, 1996 pursuant to Article
5 of the PHFL, and is a corporation organized under section 402 of the Business Corporation Law.
The purposes for which Corp I and Corp II, respectively, were formed are as follows:
(a) Acquire one or more areas under a plan or plans, and construct, own, maintain, operate,
sell and convey projects pursuant to the terms and provisions of Article 5 of the PHFL; and
particularly to acquire, construct, own, maintain and operate a residential housing project
know as Sunnylane of Bethpage ("Project"), located in the Town of Oyster Bay ("Town"),
County of Nassau, State of New York, pursuant to the terms and provisions of Article 5 of
the PHFL, and subject to the supervision of the Comptroller of the Town ("Supervising
Agency"); and to provide residences for shareholders of Corp I and Corp II, respectively, by
leasing to them, under proprietary leases, apartments in the buildings owned by Corp I and
Corp II, respectively, and each of the shareholders shall be entitled solely by reason of
his/her ownership of shares in Corp I and Corp II, respectively, to a proprietary lease
entitling him/her to occupy for dwelling purposes an apartment in one of the buildings under
said proprietary leases.
(b) Acquire by purchase, lease or otherwise real estate and rights or interests in real estate,
together with the buildings and appurtenances thereto, and any and all personal property of
whatsoever kind and nature located therein; to hold, operate, manage, sell, exchange,
mortgage or otherwise encumber or dispose of, improve, rehabilitate, renovate, construct,
alter, maintain, develop, repair and lease the same and the several parts and apartments in

-2­
TSB-A-99(24)C
Corporation Tax
September 24, 1999

any building owned by Corp I and Corp II, respectively, and in any replacements thereof or
additions thereto.
(c) Do and perform every act required or permitted by law to be done or performed in the
construction, erection, maintenance, operation, repair, rehabilitation and renovation of such
buildings; to acquire, construct, maintain and operate all necessary or customary
conveniences such as lighting, heating and refrigeration in connection with the operation of
any and all of the aforesaid buildings; and manufacture or otherwise acquire and to sell,
supply or otherwise furnish or dispose of other conveniences and services of every kind and
description for tenants/shareholders of property owned or operated by Corp I and Corp II,
respectively.
(d) Purchase, acquire, hold and dispose of shares or rights to subscribe thereto, bonds and
other obligations; to possess and exercise in respect thereto all the rights, powers and
privileges of individual holders or owners thereof, and to exercise any and all voting power
thereon.
(e) Borrow or raise monies for any of the purposes of Corp I and Corp II, respectively, in
accordance with the provisions of Article 5 of the PHFL; issue bonds, debentures, notes or
other obligations of any nature, or in any manner, for monies so borrowed and to secure the
payment thereof and the interest thereon by mortgage upon or pledge or conveyance or
assignment in trust of the whole or any part of the property of Corp I and Corp II,
respectively, real or personal, provided the same be permitted by law.
(f) Do and transact all other lawful business incident to, necessary, and suitable or advisable
for, or in any way connected with, said purposes for which Corp I and Corp II, respectively,
are formed.
(g) The foregoing clauses hereto shall be construed as stating both purposes and powers, but
nothing herein contained shall be deemed to limit or exclude any power, right or privilege
given to Corp I and Corp II, respectively, by law.
The principal business office of Corp I and Corp II, respectively, is located within the Town
of Oyster Bay, County of Nassau, State of New York. Corp I and Corp II, respectively, have been
organized to serve a public purpose, and are subject to the supervision and control of the Supervising
Agency, except as provided in Article 5 of the PHFL, so long as such Article 5 remains applicable
to any project of Corp I and Corp II, respectively; and all real and personal property acquired by
Corp I and Corp II, respectively, and all structures erected by Corp I and Corp II, respectively, were
acquired or created for the promotion of the purposes of such Article 5. No salary or other form of
compensation is paid to any director or officer of Corp I and Corp II, respectively, for services
rendered.

-3­
TSB-A-99(24)C
Corporation Tax
September 24, 1999

Corp I and Corp II, respectively, are affordable retirement communities with 136 and 164
housing units, respectively. As such, the communities represent a significant addition to the housing
facilities available to meet the needs of the retired and elderly. Purchases of the units must meet both
age and income limit requirements.
Corp I and Corp II, respectively, qualify as a "cooperative housing corporation" under section
216 of the Internal Revenue Code, and the tenant/shareholders receive the benefit of the deductions
at the personal level facilitated by that section of the Tax Law.
The local municipality has granted certain real estate tax abatements and freezes facilitated
by state and local law under an arrangement known as PILOT (Payment in Lieu of Taxes.)
All the income and earnings of Corp I and Corp II, respectively, are used exclusively for
corporate purposes and no part of the net income, net earnings or assets of Corp I and Corp II,
respectively, will inure to the benefit or profit of any private individual, firm, corporation or
association. Corp I and Corp II, respectively, operate exclusively for the benefit of persons meeting
the occupancy requirements of the by-laws by meeting the stringent qualifying ownership
requirements prior to purchase of shares.
Discussion
Section 209.4 of the Tax Law provides that housing companies organized and operating
pursuant to Article 5 of the PHFL are not subject to tax under Article 9-A of the Tax Law.
Section 103 of Article 5 of the PHFL provides that a redevelopment company may be created
as a corporation by three or more persons. Section 105 of Article 5 of the PHFL provides that the
provisions of the business corporation law shall apply to redevelopment companies which are
corporations, except where such provisions are in conflict with the provisions of such Article 5.
Accordingly, since Corp I and Corp II, respectively, are organized and operating pursuant
to Article 5 of the PHFL, Corp I and Corp II, respectively, are not subject to the franchise tax
imposed under Article 9-A of the Tax Law pursuant to section 209.4 of such Article 9-A.

DATED: September 24, 1999

NOTE:

/s/
John W. Bartlett
Deputy Director
Technical Services Bureau

The opinions expressed in Advisory Opinions are
limited to the facts set forth therein.