NY TSB-A-04(1)C Corporation Tax 2004-02-26

Can a newly formed bank holding company elect to be taxed under Article 9-A, and must it file a combined Article 32 return with its banking affiliates, for its first short year?

Short answer: Yes to the election, and no combined Article 32 return is required. A newly formed wholly owned domestic subsidiary that registers for the first time as a bank holding company and elects financial holding company status -- a banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9) -- may elect under section 1452(j)(2) (as added by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003) to be subject to Article 9-A for its first short taxable year. And under section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) it is not required to file a combined Article 32 return with its Article 32 banking affiliates for that short year.

Disclaimer: This is an official New York State Department of Taxation and Finance Advisory Opinion (TSB-A), issued by the Office of Counsel at a taxpayer's request. It is limited to the facts set forth in it and binds the Department only with respect to the petitioner to whom it was issued, and only if that petitioner fully and accurately described all relevant facts; another taxpayer cannot rely on it. It reflects the law, regulations, and Department policy in effect when issued and may since have changed. Taxpayer-identifying details are redacted. New York State and local sales taxes are administered centrally by the Department. This summary is informational only and is not legal or tax advice. Consult a licensed New York tax professional about your specific situation.

About this page: The plain-English summary, reader guidance, and Q&A below were written by Ezel based on the official state tax ruling. The original ruling (linked at the bottom of this page, or PDF in the sidebar) is the authoritative source for any reliance.

View original ruling (PDF)

Plain-English summary

RBC Holdings (USA), Inc., an indirect wholly owned domestic subsidiary of Royal Bank of Canada (an alien bank), formed Newco on December 8, 2003 by contributing its assets/liabilities for 100% of Newco's stock (an IRC section 351 transfer, not a section 368 reorganization). Newco registered for the first time as a bank holding company (BHC) on December 22, 2003 and elected financial holding company (FHC) status -- making it a banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9). For its first short year (December 2003 to October 31, 2004), Newco would have banking, broker/dealer, and insurance operating subsidiaries, some 65%+ owned Article 32 banking corporations.

The Department held:

Article 9-A election (Issue 1). Under section 1452(j)(2) (added by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003), Newco has the right to elect to be subject to Article 9-A for its first short taxable year beginning December 2003 and ending October 31, 2004.
No combined Article 32 return (Issue 2). Under section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) (as amended by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003), Newco may not be required to file a combined Article 32 return with any Article 32 affiliates (its banking-corporation operating subsidiaries) for that short year.

What this means for you

A newly formed bank holding company can elect into Article 9-A

A new entity that registers as a bank holding company / FHC and is a banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9) can elect under section 1452(j)(2) to be taxed under Article 9-A for its first short taxable year -- it is not locked into Article 32 from the start. This election was added by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003.

The election can break the combined Article 32 return

Having made the new-BHC posture, under section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) the entity is not required to file a combined Article 32 return with its Article 32 banking affiliates for that short year.

Timing and structure matter

The result is tied to a first short taxable year and a first-time BHC/FHC registration following a section 351 (not section 368 reorganization) formation. Confirm the formation mechanics and the short-year timing before relying on the election.

Common questions

Q: Can a newly formed bank holding company elect to be taxed under Article 9-A?
A: Yes. Under section 1452(j)(2) (Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003), a new banking corporation that registers as a BHC/FHC may elect Article 9-A for its first short taxable year.

Q: Must it file a combined Article 32 return with its banking affiliates?
A: No. Under section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B), it is not required to file a combined Article 32 return with its Article 32 affiliates for that short year.

Q: What kind of entity qualifies?
A: A banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9) -- here, a newly formed wholly owned domestic subsidiary registering for the first time as a bank holding company and electing FHC status.

Citations and references

Statutes, regulations, and authorities:
- Tax Law section 1452(j)(2) (election by certain new banking corporations to be taxed under Article 9-A)
- Tax Law section 1452(a)(9) (banking corporation; bank holding company)
- Tax Law section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) (combined Article 32 return requirement)
- Internal Revenue Code section 351 (transfer to a controlled corporation)
- RBC Holdings (USA), Inc., TSB-A-04(1)C (Feb. 26, 2004)

Source

Original ruling text

New York State Department of Taxation and Finance

Office of Tax Policy Analysis
Technical Services Division

TSB-A-04(1)C
Corporation Tax
February 26, 2004

STATE OF NEW YORK
COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION AND FINANCE
ADVISORY OPINION

PETITION NO. C031028A

On October 28, 2003, a Petition for Advisory Opinion was received from RBC Holdings
(USA), Inc., 1 Liberty Plaza, New York, New York 10006.
The issues raised by Petitioner, RBC Holdings (USA), Inc., are:
1. Whether, pursuant to section 1452(j)(2) of the Tax Law, a newly formed wholly owned
domestic subsidiary corporation of Petitioner has the right to elect to be subject to tax under
Article 9-A of the Tax Law for its first short taxable year beginning in 2003 and ending on
October 31, 2004.
2. Whether, pursuant to section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) of the Tax Law, the subsidiary described
in Issue 1, which will also register for the first time as a bank holding company and elect
financial holding company status upon its formation, is required to file a combined
Article 32 return with any Article 32 affiliates (e.g., operating subsidiaries) for its short
taxable year beginning in 2003 and ending on October 31, 2004.
Petitioner submits the following facts as the basis for this Advisory Opinion.
Petitioner is an indirect wholly owned domestic subsidiary of Royal Bank of Canada, an
alien bank, and a fiscal year taxpayer doing business in New York. Petitioner’s fiscal year, and the
fiscal year of its subsidiaries, begins on November 1 and ends on October 31 of each year.
Petitioner indirectly acquired a greater than 5% but less than 65% interest in the domestic
banking subsidiaries of Royal Bank of Canada in 2003, during its taxable year ending October 31,
2003. As a result, Petitioner both (i) registered as a bank holding company (BHC) under the Federal
Bank Holding Company Act of 1956, as amended, (the Act) and (ii) elected financial holding
company (FHC) status during its taxable year ending October 31, 2003.
In addition to its current status as a BHC and FHC, Petitioner is a banking corporation as
such term is defined in section 1452(a)(9) of the Tax Law. Petitioner is not a corporation described
in paragraphs (1) through (8) of section 1452(a) of the Tax Law.
For its taxable year ended October 31, 2002, Petitioner filed a combined franchise tax return
under Article 32 of the Tax Law with Bull & Bear Securities, Inc., its Article 32 subsidiary. Bull
& Bear Securities, Inc., was dissolved during the taxable year ending October 31, 2003, and as a
result, Petitioner no longer has any 65% or more owned operating subsidiaries that are both doing
business in New York and subject to Article 32 of the Tax Law.

-2
TSB-A-04(1)C
Corporation Tax
February 26, 2004

Currently, Petitioner’s 65% or more owned operating subsidiaries consist primarily of
broker/dealer and insurance related entities. To the extent these other entities are doing business in
New York, they are properly subject to taxation under either Article 9-A or Article 33 of the Tax
Law.
For its taxable year ended October 31, 2003, Petitioner remained an Article 32 taxpayer.
Petitioner formed Newco on December 8, 2003, by contributing all of the assets and
liabilities currently owned by Petitioner to Newco in exchange for 100% of the stock of Newco in
a transaction that qualifies under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 351 for federal income tax
purposes.
Newco registered for the first time as a BHC on December 22, 2003, and elected FHC status
on December 29, 2003. From a bank regulatory perspective, Newco will be principally engaged in
activities that are described in section 4(k)(4) or 4(k)(5) of the Act. In addition to being a BHC and
FHC, Newco will be a banking corporation as defined in section 1452(a)(9) of the Tax Law, and
will not be described in paragraphs (1) through (8) of section 1452(a) of the Tax Law.
Through various restructurings or changes in business operations that may occur in its
taxable year beginning in December 2003 and ending October 31, 2004, Newco may have, in
addition to broker/dealer and insurance related entities as operating subsidiaries, 65% or more
owned operating subsidiaries that are banking corporations doing business in New York that are
subject to Article 32 of the Tax Law.
Applicable law
Section 1452(j)(2) of the Tax Law, as amended by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003, provides:
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this section, a corporation
formed on or after January first, two thousand three and before January first, two thousand
four may elect to be subject to tax under this article or under article nine-A of this chapter
for its first taxable year beginning on or after January first, two thousand three and before
January first, two thousand four in which either (i) sixty-five percent or more of its voting
stock is owned or controlled, directly or indirectly by a financial holding company, provided
the corporation whose voting stock is so owned or controlled is principally engaged in
activities that are described in section 4(k)(4) or 4(k)(5) of the federal bank holding company
act of nineteen hundred fifty-six, as amended and the regulations promulgated pursuant to
the authority of such section, or (ii) it is a financial subsidiary.
An election under this paragraph may not be made by a corporation described in
paragraphs one through eight of subsection (a) of this section or in subsection (e) of this
section. In addition, an election under this paragraph may not be made by a corporation that
is a party to a reorganization, as defined in subsection (a) of section 368 of the internal

-3
TSB-A-04(1)C
Corporation Tax
February 26, 2004

revenue code of 1986, as amended, of a corporation described in paragraph one of this
subsection if both corporations were sixty-five percent or more owned or controlled, directly
or indirectly, by the same interests at the time of the reorganization. An election under this
paragraph must be made by the taxpayer on or before the due date for filing its return
(determined with regard to extensions of time for filing) for the applicable taxable year. The
election to be taxed under article nine-A of this chapter shall be made by the taxpayer by
filing the report required pursuant to section two hundred eleven of this chapter and the
election to be taxed under this article shall be made by the taxpayer by filing the return
required pursuant to section fourteen hundred sixty-two of this article. Any election made
pursuant to this paragraph shall be irrevocable and shall apply to each subsequent taxable
year beginning on or after January first, two thousand three and before January first, two
thousand four, provided that the stock ownership requirements described in subparagraph
(i) of this paragraph are met or such corporation described in subparagraph (ii) of this
paragraph continues as a financial subsidiary.
Section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) of the Tax Law, as amended by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003,
provides:
Notwithstanding any provision of this paragraph other than clause (A) of this
subparagraph, the commissioner may not require a bank holding company which, during a
taxable year beginning on or after January first, two thousand and before January first, two
thousand four, registers for the first time during such taxable year under the federal bank
holding company act, as amended, and also elects to be a financial holding company, to
make a return on a combined basis for any taxable year beginning on or after January first,
two thousand and before January first, two thousand four with a banking corporation
sixty-five percent or more of whose voting stock is owned or controlled, directly or
indirectly, by such bank holding company.
Section 351(a) of the IRC provides, in part:
General Rule. – No gain or loss shall be recognized if property is transferred to a
corporation by one or more persons solely in exchange for stock in such corporation and
immediately after the exchange such person or persons are in control ... of the corporation.
Section 368(a)of the IRC provides, in part:
Reorganization. –
(1) In general. – For purposes of parts I and II and this part, the term “reorganization”
means –

-4
TSB-A-04(1)C
Corporation Tax
February 26, 2004

(C) the acquisition by one corporation, in exchange solely for all or a part of
its voting stock (or in exchange solely for all or a part of the voting stock of a
corporation which is in control of the acquiring corporation), of substantially all of
the properties of another corporation, but in determining whether the exchange is
solely for stock the assumption by the acquiring corporation of a liability of the other
shall be disregarded;
*

(2) Special rules relating to paragraph (1). –
*

(G) Distribution requirement for paragraph (1)(C). –
(i) In general. – A transaction shall fail to meet the requirements of
paragraph (1)(C) unless the acquired corporation distributes the stock,
securities, and other properties it receives, as well as its other properties, in
pursuance of the plan of reorganization. For purposes of the preceding
sentence, if the acquired corporation is liquidated pursuant to the plan of
reorganization, any distribution to its creditors in connection with such
liquidation shall be treated as pursuant to the plan of reorganization.
(ii) Exception. – The Secretary may waive the application of clause
(i) to any transaction subject to any conditions the Secretary may prescribe.
Opinion
Petitioner is a banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9) of the Tax Law and is a BHC
and a FHC. On December 8, 2003, Petitioner formed Newco by contributing all of the assets and
liabilities currently owned by Petitioner in exchange for 100% of Newco’s stock. This transaction
will qualify under IRC section 351, and does not appear to be a reorganization under IRC section
368(a).
Newco registered, for the first time, as a BHC on December 22, 2003, and elected FHC status
on December 29, 2003. Newco will be principally engaged in activities that are described in section
4(k)(4) or 4(k)(5) of the Act, and will be a banking corporation under section 1452(a)(9) of the Tax
Law. For its first taxable year beginning in December 2003 and ending October 31, 2004, Newco

-5
TSB-A-04(1)C
Corporation Tax
February 26, 2004

may have, in addition to broker/dealer and insurance related entities as operating subsidiaries, 65%
or more owned operating subsidiaries that are banking corporations doing business in New York
that are subject to Article 32 of the Tax Law.
Accordingly, with respect to Issue 1, Newco has the right, pursuant to section 1452(j)(2) of
the Tax Law, as added by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003, to elect to be subject to tax under
Article 9-A of the Tax Law for its first short taxable year beginning in December 2003 and ending
on October 31, 2004.
With respect to Issue 2, pursuant to section 1462(f)(2)(iv)(B) of the Tax Law, as amended
by Chapter 62 of the Laws of 2003, Newco may not be required to file a combined Article 32 return
with any Article 32 affiliates (e.g., operating subsidiaries that are banking corporations subject to tax
under Article 32) for its short taxable year beginning in December 2003 and ending on October 31,
2004.

DATED: February 26, 2004

NOTE:

/s/
Jonathan Pessen
Tax Regulations Specialist IV
Technical Services Division

The opinions expressed in Advisory Opinions are
limited to the facts set forth therein.