New York State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
My shopping center lease, originally signed in the 1950s for 75 years, has about 37 years left. We're negotiating to add roughly 30 more years to the term along with a substantial rent increase, but with no purchase option. Does extending an already-long-running lease trigger New York's Real Property Transfer Gains Tax as if we were creating a brand-new 49-plus-year lease?
Yes, taxable -- extending and substantially modifying an existing lease creates a brand-new leasehold for gains-tax purposes, with its term measured starting from the modification's effective date, no…
Is a U.S. corporation's Subpart F income from its foreign subsidiaries treated as a 'dividend' for New York's Article 9-A and Article 33 franchise taxes, and if so, how much of it can be excluded from entire net income?
Yes -- Subpart F income is treated as a deemed dividend for both Article 9-A and Article 33 purposes, following the Department's own 1966 policy and analogous state-court rulings; if the taxpayer owns…
A contractor doing a job for a tax-exempt government agency buys sand to sandblast structures before painting, then leaves the used sand on site as fill. Is the sand exempt from sales tax?
No. Sullivan Humes Painting buys sand to sandblast structures before painting them under contracts with tax-exempt entities, and leaves the spent sand on site as fill. The Department held the sand is …
Equipment is taxed as real property under the Real Property Tax Law. Does that mean selling it is exempt from sales tax as a sale of real property?
Not necessarily. Consolidated Edison plans to sell installed transformers, network protectors, and vaults — items assessed as real property under the Real Property Tax Law — and asked whether that rea…
Does a bed-and-breakfast reservation service that books rooms for travelers have to collect sales tax on its charges?
No — the booking agency itself need not collect sales tax, but the hosts must. Bed & Breakfast U.S.A. lists available bed-and-breakfast homes ('hosts') for travelers ('guests'), makes reservations, ta…
Is machinery a scrap-metal recycler buys to process scrap into resalable material exempt from sales tax?
Partly. C & H Salvage Corp. asked whether machinery used strictly in recycling scrap metals is taxable. Processing scrap metal for sale is 'processing' under Tax Law § 1115(a)(12), so machinery used d…
A utility's customers on public assistance have their bills ultimately paid by a social services agency. Is that an exempt sale to the government?
No — these ordinary public-assistance sales are taxable. Consolidated Edison serves customers on public assistance whose monthly utility bills are ultimately paid by the New York City Human Resources …
Are aerial maps, surveys, and charts a tax-exempt information service, or are they taxable tangible personal property?
They are taxable tangible personal property. Lockwood Support Services makes aerial maps, surveys, and charts and argued they are an exempt information service under Tax Law § 1105(c)(1). The Departme…
When a mutual savings bank converts first from a federal to a state charter and then from mutual to stock form -- both treated as tax-free federal reorganizations -- how does that affect its New York Article 32 bank franchise tax filings?
The conversion is tax-free for Article 32 purposes too, following its federal IRC § 368(a)(1)(F) reorganization treatment -- but converting from a FEDERAL to a NEW YORK STATE charter requires filing t…
If a retailer restructures its fuel supply chain through a related importing corporation, which company owes Article 13-A gross receipts tax, and on what price level?
Whichever related corporation actually imports the petroleum into New York is the one subject to Article 13-A tax on its full gross receipts from selling it -- if the subsidiary imports and resells to…
How is sales or use tax charged when someone buys a mobile home and installs it permanently on New York land — and does living out of state change it?
It turns on new-vs-used, where it's bought, and the buyer's residence. Elsa and Carlos Rosa, New Jersey residents, planned to buy a mobile home and install it permanently on their land in Bethel, New …
Must a bank holding company reduce its Article 32 17% interest / 60% dividend deduction from noncombined subsidiaries by the amount of its own short-term borrowing costs attributable to that subsidiary capital?
No -- Article 32 has no provision requiring the 17% interest / 60% dividend deduction on income from noncombined subsidiaries to be reduced by expenses attributable to the parent's own short-term liab…
For New York's business allocation percentage property factor, does the exclusion for 'real property and related equipment' under construction reach only buildings and building-integrated equipment, or also separate personal property like standalone machinery being installed at the same time?
The exclusion is broader than the taxpayer argued -- it also reaches personal property under construction that is functionally tied to the real property construction, such as an assembly line built to…
Is a nonprofit patent-holding corporation exempt from New York's corporate franchise tax if it's a STOCK corporation whose only shareholder is a tax-exempt university?
No -- New York's not-for-profit corporate franchise tax exemption is available only to corporations that have NO stock or shares at all; because Cornell Research Foundation is a STOCK corporation (eve…
Is building a ski lift a tax-exempt capital improvement to real property, or a taxable installation of equipment?
It splits. Peek 'n Peak Recreation asked whether building a ski lift at its resort is an exempt capital improvement to real property. The Department held it is not, except for the foundations. A capit…
Does equipment used to design and develop computer hardware and software products qualify for New York's investment tax credit and research and development credit, and can an unprofitable startup get the investment credit refunded rather than carried forward?
Yes to both credits -- equipment used to design and develop computer software (following the federal treatment of software costs as research expenditures under Revenue Procedure 69-21) and computer ha…
If a taxpayer doesn't contest an erroneous notice of deficiency disallowing part of an investment tax credit, and that year later becomes a closed period under the statute of limitations, can the taxpayer still claim the full investment tax credit carryforward from that closed year when a later, open year is audited?
Yes -- even though the taxpayer can no longer directly contest the closed year's deficiency (both the 90-day protest window and the statute of limitations have run), the Tax Commission can still redet…
I'm a gasoline distributor licensed in Ontario, Canada. Can I buy gasoline in New York State tax-free if I'm exporting it straight to Ontario for resale there?
Yes, by policy. New York law lets a New York distributor sell gasoline tax-free (and get a credit or refund) when selling to a purchaser who is a duly registered or licensed distributor in another U.S…
Is an out-of-state fuel distributor subject to New York's corporate franchise tax merely because its New York-based parent company keeps its books and provides a shared officer, when the subsidiary itself has no New York office or employees -- but does take title to petroleum within New York before shipping it out of state?
Having a parent-company officer maintain a New York office, and having the parent's own employees keep the subsidiary's books in New York, are NOT by themselves enough to create nexus -- but the subsi…
Once the IRS actually confirms that Bank Negara Malaysia is a tax-exempt foreign government under IRC section 892 with no U.S. trade or business, does that change the earlier New York ruling that its franchise tax is capped at the $250 minimum?
No -- the result stays the same. This modified opinion appends the IRS's actual March 31, 1987 ruling (that Petitioner is a tax-exempt foreign government under IRC section 892, with its U.S. investmen…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-87 (4)I: May amounts in a Tax Law § 612(k) qualified higher education fund be used, tax-free, to fund a college's prepaid alumni tuition plan, and does the section 612(c)(17) tuition deduction apply to such payments?
Yes to the first question, no to the second. The Department ruled that Clarence and Barbara Tobin could use amounts held in their qualified higher education fund to establish a prepaid Canisius Colleg…
Does manufacturing equipment used to physically produce and reproduce computer hardware and software products (as opposed to just designing/developing them) qualify for New York's investment tax credit, and does a general-purpose office computer used for project management also qualify?
Yes for the manufacturing/reproduction equipment -- taking a blank tape or disk and imprinting a software program onto it, and manufacturing the physical hardware connector products, both constitute '…
For a printing company's New York receipts factor, should printed materials shipped in bulk to a customer's New York locations be sourced to New York even if the CUSTOMER isn't itself based in New York, and how should mailings to third-party consumers (not the direct customer) be sourced?
Yes -- receipts from books, magazines, and catalogs are sourced to New York whenever the printed goods are actually shipped (via common carrier, company truck, or mail) to a point in New York, regardl…
When a utility agrees to transport a customer's own natural gas (contract carriage) and separately reimburses an upstream pipeline for transportation costs, is the utility's own transportation fee taxable under sections 186 and 186-a, and does simply passing along reimbursement payments to the upstream pipeline count as taxable income to the utility?
The utility's own contract-carriage fee for transporting the customer's gas IS taxable gross earnings/gross income under both section 186 and section 186-a; amounts the utility collects from the custo…
Does reincorporating from Delaware to New York State (without formally electing federal F-reorganization treatment) terminate a company's existing New York S corporation election?
It depends entirely on whether the federal S election survived the reincorporation -- if the change qualifies for tax-free federal F-reorganization treatment (per Revenue Ruling 64-250) and the FEDERA…
My partnership built an office building at 126 East 56th Street in two stages, finishing the base building in 1983 and completing individual tenant floor build-outs through 1985. Can I allocate construction-period interest, real property taxes, insurance, security, and specifically identified indirect project costs to each floor by square footage, for gains-tax original-purchase-price purposes?
Yes, as long as it's an equitable allocation. Tower 56 Partners, a New York partnership that built and leased an office building at 126 East 56th Street in Manhattan, financed by National Bank of Nort…
Can a broadcaster allocate the sales tax on its production purchases based on where its viewers are, since the audience is in and out of New York?
No. Showtime Entertainment prepares videotape programs for satellite broadcast and asked whether the sales and use tax on its purchases of tangible personal property, editing/dubbing processing servic…
Can a pay-per-view movie company take over the hotel's responsibility to collect and pay the sales tax on in-room movie charges?
No. Spectradyne installs and maintains pay-per-view movie equipment ('Spectravision') in hotels and asked whether it could assume the hotel operator's liability to remit the sales tax collected on in-…
Are the fees a health club charges for aerobics classes and workout machines taxable as club dues or admission charges?
No. Donald B. Schwartz asked whether the fees a 'health club' charges — for aerobic exercise classes and the use of workout machines by dues-paying members, with showers but no pool — are taxable unde…
Can a caterer buy paper cups, napkins, tablecloths, and plastic tableware tax-free as items bought for resale?
Only partly. Festive Caterers Inc. asked whether its purchases of paper cups, napkins, tablecloths, and plastic tableware are exempt as items bought for resale because they become part of a customer's…
In a multi-tier structure -- a nonresident individual owning an S corporation, which is a general partner in a New York partnership, which is itself the managing partner of a foreign partnership doing 35% of its business in New York -- how does New York tax flow through each layer down to the individual, and how is the New York-source share of income determined at each level?
Nothing is taxed at the partnership or S-corporation entity level itself (each tier only files an informational return) -- New York-source income flows up through each tier using that tier's own books…
A typesetter sells imprinted film used to print catalogs. Is that a taxable sale of property or an exempt typesetting service?
It is a taxable sale of property unless the buyer certifies an exempt use. Stibo Datagraphics, a commercial typesetter, produces imprinted film used by printers to make catalogs and sells the film dir…
Can a corporate partner in a partnership claim its allocable share of the partnership's investment tax credit on production equipment the PARTNERSHIP purchased, even though the partnership has no Article 9-A tax liability of its own and a partner's interest is technically just intangible personal property rather than a direct share of partnership assets?
Yes -- even though a partnership has no Article 9-A tax liability to apply a credit against, and a partner's interest is technically intangible personalty rather than a direct share of partnership ass…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-87 (2)I: In the year they change status from nonresident alien to resident alien (or vice versa), may Japanese treaty traders claim the New York standard deduction and 'married filing jointly' status even though federal law denies the federal standard deduction and forces 'married filing separately'?
Partly yes, partly no, for the 1986 taxable year. The Department ruled that Japanese treaty traders may claim the New York standard deduction in their dual-status year even though federal law forces t…
Is installing a home water distillation unit a tax-free capital improvement, and how are the sale and installation taxed?
Yes — it is a capital improvement. Alfred E. Luckette Jr. (Alfran Modern Home Products) asked whether selling and installing a home water distillation unit is a capital improvement to real property. T…
My partnership is constructing an office building at 33 Whitehall Street, with the base building completed in a first stage and individual floors built out for tenants in a second, ongoing stage running into 1989. Can I allocate construction-period interest, real property taxes, insurance, security, and specifically identified indirect project costs to each floor by square footage, for gains-tax original-purchase-price purposes?
Yes, as long as it's an equitable allocation. Broad Financial Center Partners, a New York partnership building an office building at 33 Whitehall Street in lower Manhattan, financed first by Manufactu…
My partnership is constructing an office building at 32 Old Slip in lower Manhattan, with the base building finishing in phases (elevator banks completed on different dates) and individual floors being built out for tenants as leases are signed. Can I allocate construction-period interest, real property taxes, insurance, security, and specifically identified indirect project costs to each floor by square footage, for gains-tax original-purchase-price purposes?
Yes, as long as it's an equitable allocation. Assay Partners, a New York partnership building an office building at 32 Old Slip in Manhattan financed by Bankers Trust Company, was completing the build…
Is a market-research firm's sale of customized retail sales and inventory reports a taxable information service?
Yes. Putnam Associates sells reports charting inventory levels and sales of retail products (cosmetics, fragrances, dinnerware) in nationwide stores, and argued it provides a consulting service furnis…
Is an out-of-state national bank subject to New York's Article 32 bank franchise tax merely because it serves as trustee for a New York industrial development bond, when all its substantive trustee work is performed at its out-of-state headquarters except for a single one-day trip to sign documents and deliver securities in New York?
No -- a national bank with no New York office, employees, or property, whose only New York contact is signing a trust agreement and hand-delivering bond documents during a single one-day visit (with a…
How is a car dealer taxed on vehicles it loans to customers as courtesy cars, especially if it depreciates them as business assets?
It depends on how the dealer holds and uses the cars. Crestview Cadillac loans courtesy cars to customers whose vehicles are being serviced and asked how they are taxed. The Department explained the d…
I'm constructing an office building floor-by-floor as tenants sign leases, rather than all at once. For gains-tax purposes, can I allocate construction-period interest, real property taxes, insurance, security, and specifically identified indirect project costs to each floor in proportion to that floor's share of the building's total square footage, counting costs only through the date each floor's construction is finished?
Yes, as long as it's an equitable allocation. 45 Broadway Atrium Partners was constructing an office building at 45 Broadway in Manhattan in two stages -- a first stage completing the foundation, shel…
Does an out-of-state manufacturer that sells only through independent (non-employee) commissioned sales representatives lose the protection of federal P.L. 86-272 -- which shields mere order-solicitation from state income tax -- because it rented a New York showroom for those representatives' convenience for part of the year?
Yes -- P.L. 86-272 protects a company whose ONLY in-state activity is soliciting orders that are approved and filled from outside the state, but renting even a small showroom in New York (here, at the…
As the New York State Teachers' Retirement System, I invest a significant portion of my pension funds in first mortgages on New York real property. Are those mortgages exempt from New York's mortgage recording tax based on my status as a state agency, even though I'm not listed among the specific statutory exemptions in Tax Law §§ 252 and 252-a?
Yes. The New York State Teachers' Retirement System, a public pension fund created under Education Law Article 11 that invests a significant portion of its assets in first mortgages on real property (…
Is an out-of-state mortgage banking subsidiary of a national bank subject to New York's Article 32 bank franchise tax once it opens a New York loan-origination office, must it file combined with its parent, and are its receipts from selling mortgage-backed securities on the secondary market taxable New York receipts?
Yes, it's a taxable 'banking corporation' once it opens the New York office (as a subsidiary 65%+ owned by a national bank, engaged in bank-related mortgage business); whether it must file combined wi…
Is installing in-ground water pipe to a property a tax-free capital improvement?
Yes. Thompson's Mobile Manor, a trailer park, hired a contractor to install in-ground water pipe from the existing main line to and throughout the park (the pipe becomes town property once installed).…
Are my single-axle mobile home toters classified as "trucks" or "tractors" for New York's highway use tax, and does it matter that they usually run empty on the return trip?
Mobile home toters are classified as "tractors," not "trucks," for New York's highway use tax -- and they are taxable vehicular units either way. Under 20 NYCRR § 470.3, a "tractor" is a self-propelle…
When a syndicate sends newspapers photocopies of a comic strip to publish, is it selling a reproduction right or taxable property?
It is a taxable sale of tangible personal property — not a tax-free reproduction right. The Hearst Corporation's King Features Syndicate mails newspapers photocopies of six daily installments of a com…
Can a corporation subtract from its New York entire net income the amount of stock it contributes to a federal tax-credit employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), which isn't deductible for federal income tax purposes?
No -- New York's Article 9-A only allows a specific subtraction for wages disallowed under IRC § 280C (the targeted jobs credit provision), and the ESOP stock contribution here is disallowed under a D…
Is adding to a warehouse conveyor system a tax-free capital improvement if the conveyor can be removed without damaging the building?
No. McKesson Drug Company asked whether an addition to its existing warehouse conveyor system is a capital improvement excluded from sales tax. The addition is welded and bolted to the building, engin…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-87 (1)I: Must a private banking partnership add back, under section 612(b)(4) of the Tax Law, interest deducted on indebtedness incurred in the ordinary course of its banking business, where the partnership also holds tax-exempt U.S. Treasury securities?
No, not for its ordinary banking-business interest. The Department ruled that Brown Brothers Harriman, a private banking partnership holding a portfolio of tax-exempt U.S. Treasury securities, does no…
When an affiliate produces computer reports for a company, who owes sales tax on the paper — and does it depend on whether the reports are taxable?
It turns on whether the reports are a taxable information service. Norstar Leasing asked whether it owes sales tax on computer printout paper it receives, as reports, from its affiliate Data Company, …
Does equipment used solely to install connecting pipeline linking a newly drilled gas well to the existing pipeline system qualify for New York's investment tax credit as equipment used in natural gas 'extraction'?
No -- installing pipeline to connect a newly drilled well to an existing pipeline system is a transportation-related service, not part of the extraction operation itself, and since the pipeline isn't …
Does a direct-mail company owe sales tax on the mailing lists it rents, or can it claim an exemption?
The mailing lists remain taxable; no exemption applies. The D.M. Group, a direct-mail firm, rents mailing lists (as electronic tapes or gummed labels) to distribute promotional material it produces fo…
Does someone owe sales tax when a corporation gives them a car for free, with no money or other consideration changing hands?
No — a genuine gift of a car is not taxed, but you must document it. Richard W. Scott asked whether he would owe sales tax on a 1984 Chevrolet Suburban that his son and daughter-in-law's corporation w…
If a lessee gives an exemption certificate to the leasing company, does that same certificate also cover an affiliate that later takes over billing and collection?
No — the assignee needs its own certificate. Norstar Leasing leases tangible personal property, then may assign the lease to an affiliate ('Assignee') to finance, bill, collect rent, and remit sales t…
Is the admission charge to watch a roller derby exhibition subject to New York sales tax?
Yes — roller derby admission is taxable. Rollermania Inc. asked whether the charge to attend a roller derby exhibition is subject to sales tax. Under § 1105(f)(1), admission charges over ten cents to …
For a mail-order seller, does New York sales tax depend on where the product is delivered or on where the buyer lives?
Delivery point controls, not residence. Peter Knych, who sells tangible personal property by mail, asked two questions: must he collect New York sales tax when a Vermont resident has the product deliv…
Is a service that files loose-leaf update pages into a client's subscription publications taxable, even if the company only inserts and removes pages?
Yes — the filing service is taxable. L.G. & S.G. Inc. files the loose-leaf update services (e.g., Commerce Clearing House, Prentice Hall) that publishers send directly to its clients; its employee vis…
Can forward foreign-currency sale contracts, entered into purely to hedge currency-fluctuation risk on equity investments in foreign subsidiaries, themselves be counted as part of 'subsidiary capital' (investments in subsidiary stock) for New York franchise tax purposes?
No -- forward currency contracts, even when purchased specifically and exclusively to protect the value of an existing stock investment in a foreign subsidiary, are not themselves 'investments in the …
I'm selling my 45% shareholder interest in a corporation whose only asset is New York real property, as part of a deal where the buyer will also acquire another shareholder's 50% interest (making the buyer's total acquisition a controlling interest). The price I'm actually getting for my shares is nominal, but the buyer is also assuming and satisfying a lot of debt. Is the 'consideration' for gains-tax purposes just the cash and debt relief I personally receive, or something else?
Something else -- consideration is the apportioned fair market value of the underlying real property, not the price actually paid for the shares. Miller Buckley Overseas Limited (MBO), a 45% sharehold…
Browse New York rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by New York's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.