Nonprofit Director Conflict Transaction Approval Rules in California
At a glance
| Governing act and covered transactions | Public benefit § 5233; mutual benefit § 7233; religious § 9243; common directors separately |
|---|---|
| Interest and related-person trigger | Material financial interest for public benefit/religious self-dealing; mutual benefit also directorship interest (§§ 5233(a), 7233, 9243(a)) |
| Disclosure and knowledge | Board knows transaction and interest for public benefit/religious board route; mutual benefit board or members know (§§ 5233(d), 7233(a), 9243(d)) |
| Board or committee approval | Public benefit/religious majority of directors then in office, excluding interested votes, plus benefit/fairness/alternatives review; mutual benefit disinterested vote and just-reasonable test (§§ 5233(d), 7233(a), 9243(d)) |
| Member approval and vote | Mutual benefit disinterested-member § 5034 approval; religious non-director-member § 5034 approval; § 5233 lists AG/court, board and delayed-ratification routes (§§ 7233(a), 9243(d), 5233(d)) |
| Fairness route and time | Public benefit/religious fair and reasonable at entry; mutual benefit just and reasonable at authorization, approval, or ratification (§§ 5233(d), 7233(a), 9243(d)) |
| Interested participation and quorum | Public benefit/religious interested directors count for board quorum but not protected board vote; mutual benefit interested member votes excluded (§§ 5233(d),(g), 7233(a), 9243(d),(g)) |
| Burden, effect, and separate authorization | Public benefit/religious routes bar § 5233/§ 9243 remedies; mutual benefit § 7233 prevents interest-only voidability or assigns validity proponent fairness burden |
| Special coverage and later changes | Common-director rules §§ 5234, 7233(b), 9244; charitable-trust assets import public-benefit standards into mutual benefit (§ 7238) |
Requirements one by one
Public benefit corporations
Section 5233(a) defines a self-dealing transaction by a director's material financial interest, subject to its specific exclusions and approval routes. Its § 5233(d)(2) board route requires corporate benefit, fairness and reasonableness when the corporation entered the transaction, an informed good-faith vote by a majority of directors then in office without interested votes before consummation, and the statutory more-advantageous-arrangement inquiry. Section 5233(d)(1) also recognizes Attorney General or court approval; § 5233(d)(3) allows a later board ratification only after its specified impracticability and committee/person approval conditions. These routes limit the remedies specified in § 5233(h); they are not a general declaration that every contract is valid.
Mutual benefit corporations
Section 7233(a) addresses both a director's transaction and a material financial interest in another entity. Its alternatives are informed, good-faith disinterested-member approval; an informed, good-faith board or committee vote sufficient without interested directors plus a just-and-reasonable transaction; or proof of that just-and-reasonable standard by the person asserting validity. The member route uses § 5034's approval rule, with the interested director's membership excluded from voting. Under § 7238, directors' conduct concerning assets held in charitable trust follows the public benefit conduct standards for those assets.
Religious corporations
Section 9243(d) offers Attorney General or court approval, informed good-faith approval by members other than directors, a board route with corporate or religious-purpose benefit and the specified fairness/alternative-arrangement inquiry, or conditional committee/person approval followed by board ratification. Its § 9243(b) exclusions include director compensation or loan action and certain good-faith public, charitable, or religious program transactions.
What trips people up
A common directorship is a separate branch. Sections 5234 and 9244 allow disclosed disinterested board approval or a transaction that meets their stated just-and-reasonable or religious-purpose test; each excludes transactions governed by its self-dealing section. Mutual benefit § 7233(b) has its own common-director route and excludes transactions covered by § 7233(a). These branches should not be treated as the same material-financial-interest test. Public benefit and religious § 5233(g) and § 9243(g) count interested directors for quorum, while their protected board votes exclude those directors.
Common questions
Does an ordinary member vote cure public benefit self-dealing? Section 5233(d) lists Attorney General or court approval and its specified board and ratification routes; the separate member-approval routes appear in mutual benefit § 7233(a) and religious § 9243(d).
What does “approval of the members” mean here? Section 5034 generally requires a majority of votes represented and voting at a meeting with a quorum, with that affirmative vote also a majority of the required quorum; it also recognizes the specified written-ballot and greater-vote variations.
Statutes and sources
- Cal. Corp. Code § 5233 — “a self-dealing transaction means a transaction to which the corporation is a party and in which one or more of its directors has a material financial interest”. California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 5234 — “This section does not apply to transactions covered by Section 5233.” California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 7233 — “A mere common directorship does not constitute a material financial interest within the meaning of this subdivision.” California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 7238 — “Where a corporation holds assets in charitable trust, the conduct of its directors or of any person performing functions similar to those performed by a director, shall, in respect to the assets held in charitable trust, be governed by the standards of conduct set forth in Article 3 (commencing with Section 5230) of Chapter 2 of Part 2”. California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 9243 — “Interested directors may be counted in determining the presence of a quorum at a meeting of the board which authorizes, approves or ratifies a contract or transaction.” California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 9244 — “This section does not apply to transactions covered by Section 9243.” California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
- Cal. Corp. Code § 5034 — “Approval by (or approval of) the members” means approved or ratified by the affirmative vote of a majority of the votes represented and voting at a duly held meeting at which a quorum is present”. California Legislative Counsel. Accessed 2026-10-02.
Source links
Every statute quoted above, linked, with the date we checked it.
What does California law mean for your facts?
You just read the general rule. Ask your own question and see which parts of current California law apply to your situation, with citations you can check.
Opens in Ezel Pro.
- Starts from the statutes this survey is built on
- Cites every source it relies on, so you can verify it
- Chat, drafting and research in one workspace