North Carolina Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in North Carolina, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No North Carolina opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a public hospital system in North Carolina lend operating revenues to a nonprofit hospital corporation it created to run a long-term acute care hospital?
Yes. The Municipal Hospital Act (G.S. § 131E-7(b)) lets public hospitals contract with nonprofit corporations to provide health care and use hospital revenues to fund those contracts. A $1.825 million…
Are a North Carolina legislator's emails and other written communications about redistricting public records the public can inspect, and who is the legal custodian of those records?
It depends on who the communication was with. Communications between a legislator and a legislative employee, including a staff lawyer, are confidential before enactment of a redistricting plan and be…
Can a nonprofit economic development corporation claim a North Carolina property tax exemption on raw, unimproved land it owns for future redevelopment?
No. North Carolina's charitable property tax exemption in G.S. § 105-278.7 covers only buildings, the land they actually occupy, and adjacent land convenient to their use. Unimproved tracts held for f…
Are draft redistricting plans drawn by a North Carolina legislator personally, using the legislature's computer system but without staff help, public records the public can demand to see?
The statutes do not clearly answer the question. G.S. §§ 120-130, 131, and 133 protect plans drawn by legislative employees but say nothing about plans drawn by legislators themselves. Two competing c…
Can North Carolina's NC Flex flexible-benefits program offer state employees a voluntary indemnity health plan that pays fixed-dollar amounts for hospitalization, heart attack, and similar events, and can it offer alternative dependent health coverage?
Yes for the fixed-dollar indemnity plan; depends-on-details for dependent coverage. N.C.G.S. §§ 116-17.2 and 143-34.1(d) prohibit NC Flex from duplicating benefits provided by the State Health Plan, T…
When someone is arrested for a domestic violence crime in North Carolina, can a magistrate set bail right away, or does the defendant have to stay in custody until a judge can act?
A magistrate cannot set conditions of pretrial release during the first 48 hours after arrest for a covered domestic violence crime. Only a judge may set those conditions during that window. If no jud…
Who has the legal authority to select and contract with the midway operator for the North Carolina State Fair: the Department of Agriculture or the Board of Agriculture?
The Department of Agriculture. G.S. § 106-503 says the Board manages the State Fair, but the Executive Organization Act of 1971 transferred the Board to the Department by Type II transfer, putting the…
Does North Carolina law require a county to let the public monitor its 800 MHz radio system in real time, or to record radio traffic that the county is not already recording?
No. The Public Records Act covers records that exist; it does not force a county to create a record. If a county chooses not to record 800 MHz radio traffic, no statute requires it to start, and no st…
When a regional transportation authority asks a North Carolina county to approve a 5% rental vehicle tax, can the county add provisions or amend the tax before approving it?
No. Under G.S. § 105-551, the regional transportation authority sets the tax rate, terms, and effective date. County commissioners must approve or decline the proposal as submitted; they may not amend…
Does the North Carolina Secretary of State have to file a patentable-intellectual-property report before licensing its homegrown business-registration software to other states?
Probably not for the older program, possibly yes for the newer module, and the safer course is to disclose either way. The NC AG concluded in 2002 that the Secretary of State's existing SoSKB software…
How many state employees can a North Carolina agency designate as legislative liaisons after the 2001 lobbying reform law?
Only two. Session Law 2001-424 amended Article 9A of Chapter 120 to (a) define 'legislative liaison personnel' as a state officer or employee whose principal duties in practice or in their job descrip…
Can North Carolina counties be forced to get federal stormwater permits even though the state, not the counties, owns the roads where most stormwater drains?
Yes. Counties can be required to obtain a Phase II NPDES stormwater permit in four scenarios: (1) the county owns or operates an MS4 in an urbanized area discharging directly to receiving waters; (2) …
Can UNC system audiology clinics fit and sell hearing aids to the public, or does the Umstead Act ban that as competition with private hearing aid dealers?
Yes, UNC audiology clinics can fit and sell hearing aids without violating the Umstead Act. Hearing aid fitting is an integral part of the graduate education required for ASHA certification and NCHADF…
When a North Carolina ferry company has docks in two towns but its principal business in just one, which town can tax the ferry boats?
The town where the company has its principal place of business. Bald Head Island Transportation, Inc.'s ferries were taxable on Bald Head Island, not in Southport, even though the ferries docked in So…
When a North Carolina state agency reduces its workforce, who decides whether an affected employee gets discontinued service retirement (DSR) or severance pay: the State Budget Officer or the agency head?
Both have to approve DSR. The State Budget Officer chooses between DSR and severance wages and must consider (but is not bound by) the agency head's recommendation and the State Personnel Director's r…
Under the 2001 North Carolina law authorizing private correctional officers to use force and make arrests, what training do their employers need, how much insurance must they carry, and what powers do these officers actually have?
Private correctional services providers must adopt the same minimum pre-employment and training standards used for State correctional officers (whether from DOC, CJETSC, or State Personnel Commission)…
When the North Carolina Utilities Commission orders a public utility to pay for an audit of itself, does the Commission have to follow the state's purchasing and consultant-contract procedures to pick the auditor?
No. When the Commission acts in its quasi-judicial capacity by issuing an order under N.C.G.S. § 62-37(b) requiring an auditor at the utility's expense, no state funds are spent and the utility pays t…
If a young pregnant girl in North Carolina got a marriage license before the October 1, 2001 age-raise but tried to use it after that date, was her marriage valid?
If the parties solemnized the marriage on or after October 1, 2001, the new age rules in N.C.G.S. § 51-2 (as amended by Session Law 2001-62) applied, even if the license was issued before that date. T…
When the North Carolina Insurance Commissioner retains experts at an insurance acquirer's expense to review a proposed acquisition of control, does the state's consultant contracting law apply?
Yes. Article 3C of Chapter 143 (state consultant services) applies to contracts the Insurance Commissioner makes under N.C.G.S. § 58-19-15(f) to retain attorneys, actuaries, economists, accountants, o…
Can North Carolina charter schools use the state's Private Capital Facilities Finance Act to raise capital for school buildings?
Yes. Charter schools are eligible to participate in Article 2 of Chapter 159D, the Private Capital Facilities Finance Act. The Act applies to 'institutions for elementary and secondary education,' def…
After the U.S. Supreme Court took federal jurisdiction off isolated North Carolina wetlands, can the state's Environmental Management Commission step in with its own permit rules, and can it do so on an emergency temporary-rule basis?
Yes to both. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the Environmental Management Commission has statutory authority under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-215.1 and § 143B-282 to require permits for activities impacti…
Does a newly incorporated North Carolina town have to actually deliver four municipal services to qualify for Powell Bill street-aid money, or is budgeting for them enough?
Budgeting is enough. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 136-41.2(c) requires only that 'funds have been appropriated' for at least four of eight designated services, not that services …
When a North Carolina insurance corporation files a conversion plan, can the Commissioner of Insurance hire outside experts to review it without going through the state's normal consultant-contract approval process?
Yes. Section 58-65-131(e) of the NC General Statutes specifically exempts the personal professional service contracts the Commissioner uses to review insurance corporation conversion plans from Articl…
Does the North Carolina State Health Plan have to get the Governor's written approval before hiring outside consultants to help negotiate its preferred provider networks?
No, not when the consultant is helping with preferred provider work. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 135-40.4(a) exempts the Teachers' and State Employees' Comprehensive Major Medic…
Can a North Carolina district bar use mandatory dues from every attorney in the district to pay for a counseling program that also helps attorneys' family members?
Only in a limited form. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that a district bar can lawfully fund BarCARES with mandatory dues only if the program is restricted to attorney members and is directly related to …
Can a licensed North Carolina attorney notarize a document for a client and then represent that client in a legal matter about the same document?
Yes. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that no statute prevents this practice. An older 1988 AG opinion (58 N.C.A.G. 35) had advised against it, but that opinion rested on N.C. Gen. Stat. § 47-8, which the …
When North Carolina's Department of Health and Human Services and its mental health Division work alongside locally-run area mental health programs, who is the HIPAA covered entity and who is responsible for compliance with the federal medical privacy rules?
The 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that DHHS as a whole is a HIPAA 'hybrid entity' because some of its components (notably Medicaid and the state psychiatric hospitals) perform 'covered functions' under…
Are the licensing fees collected by the North Carolina Board of Nursing considered 'State funds,' and if so, does that mean Board members must be paid the standard $15-per-day per diem that applies to state board members generally?
Yes and no. The 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that fees the Board of Nursing collects are 'State funds' under the Executive Budget Act, N.C.G.S. § 143-1, because that statute defines State funds to inc…
Does HIPAA's 'health plan' definition cover North Carolina state agencies like the Divisions of Aging, Vocational Rehabilitation, and Services for the Blind?
No, not most of them. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that after the federal HIPAA Privacy Regulations took effect on April 14, 2001, the definition of 'health plan' specifically excluded government-funde…
Does the Good Funds Settlement Act let a North Carolina closing attorney disburse loan proceeds right away when the funds come in on a check from Carolina Farm Credit or another federally chartered agricultural credit association?
Maybe. The NC AG said in 2001 that the statute was ambiguous. The Good Funds Settlement Act allows immediate disbursement on checks drawn on the State of North Carolina, the United States, or a 'polit…
Can the North Carolina Governor sweep money from a dedicated wireless 911 fee fund to plug a state budget hole?
Yes. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the Governor has constitutional authority under Article III, Section 5 to keep the state budget balanced, and that authority extends to ordering a transfer from t…
Do North Carolina's qualifications-based selection rules for architects and engineers reach private subcontracts and design-build projects?
No on both. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the Mini-Brooks Act (N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-64.31) applies only to procurement by state and local government entities, not to subcontracts let by private fi…
Can North Carolina insurance companies just decide not to sell insurance in certain ZIP codes or counties, and can the General Assembly force them to cover the whole state?
Yes companies can choose, and yes the legislature can force them to write statewide, with limits. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that insurance companies can choose not to write insurance or appoint agen…
If a North Carolina court expunges a DWI charge that was dismissed, does the Division of Motor Vehicles have to wipe out the 30-day civil license revocation too?
No. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the criminal expungement statute, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-146, did not reach civil drivers license revocations under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-16.5. The criminal case and…
Does North Carolina's old swine-keeping ban around state institutions also keep hog farms a quarter-mile away from local public schools and churches?
No, on both counts. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143-153, enacted in 1909, did not apply to churches because they are not 'State' entities, and likely did not apply to local publ…
When a state agency's incentive bonus program produces budget savings, and the underlying funding source is a 'Special Fund' rather than the General Fund, where do those savings go: back to the Special Fund per its own statute, or to the General Fund under the general incentive-bonus statute?
It depends on what the Special Fund statute says. If the Special Fund statute directs how surplus or unspent money is to be handled, that direction controls. If the Special Fund statute is silent on w…
If a North Carolina city's attorney gave the council legal advice about an employee five years ago, does the local newspaper have a right to see that advice now?
Not if the advice contains confidential personnel information. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-168(a), the municipal personnel-file confidentiality statute, supersedes the thre…
Can the North Carolina Rural Internet Access Authority give grant money to for-profit companies to set up telecenters in rural counties?
Yes. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the Rural Internet Access Authority (RIAA), a state agency, can award telecenter grants from its MCNC contributions to for-profit applicants. North Carolina const…
When an asphalt plant company started construction work before getting its air quality permit from the Division of Air Quality, did Henderson County's local building inspector have to revoke the building permit under the mandatory-revocation provisions of state law?
No. The 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that the local Inspections Department was not required to revoke Tar Heel Paving's building permit for its asphalt plant. The reasoning rested on two definitional …
Can the Governor of North Carolina appoint people who already work for the state to the State Board of Education, or are state employees disqualified the way they are from the UNC Board of Governors?
Yes, the Governor can appoint state employees to the State Board of Education. The 2001 NC AG opinion read N.C.G.S. § 115C-10 carefully and found that it disqualifies only a narrow set of people: (1) …
Can a school nurse in North Carolina refer a student to the local Health Department for confidential medical care (like STI testing, pregnancy services, substance abuse help, or mental health care) without notifying the student's parents, and can a school board prohibit those referrals?
Both yes. The 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that N.C.G.S. § 90-21.5 lets a minor consent on their own to medical services for venereal disease, pregnancy, substance abuse, and emotional disturbance, an…
When a North Carolina citizen review board reviews a police disciplinary case, can the city release the officer's prior misconduct records and the underlying facts to the board and to the complainant?
Partly. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that the local Act creating the Charlotte/Mecklenburg Citizen Review Board permits (but does not require) the City Manager or Chief of Police to disclose to the CRB…
Are landscape architects in North Carolina legally allowed to design street and storm water drainage systems for subdivision developments, or is that work limited to licensed professional engineers?
Engineering work, generally. The 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that detailed drawings and accompanying calculations for street design and storm water drainage systems, including subsurface piping and c…
Can a Smart Start local partnership board member vote on a grant to a nonprofit if she also sits on that nonprofit's board?
Generally yes, when the dual-service is institutional rather than personal. Smart Start board members serving on a nonprofit's board because of their county jobs (and gaining no personal financial ben…
Can a public hospital trustee also serve on a nonprofit's board if the public hospital is considering making a grant to that nonprofit?
Generally yes, as long as no individual personally pockets money from the grant. The criminal conflict-of-interest statute (N.C.G.S. § 14-234) is triggered by personal financial benefit to the public …
When a NC council of governments dissolves and gives up federally funded equipment bought with Older Americans Act subgrants, who decides what happens to the equipment: the state Division of Aging or the COG?
The state, applying state surplus property rules. The AG concluded that 45 C.F.R. § 92.32(b) controlled because the federal grant from HHS had gone to the State of North Carolina (the Division of Agin…
Can a NC county board abolish its statutorily-created county police department and roll its duties into the sheriff's office?
No. The AG concluded that the Gaston County Board of Commissioners cannot abolish the Gaston County Police Department or assign its duties to the sheriff's office without a new act of the General Asse…
When a small NC town contracts with a private 'special police' company instead of hiring its own officers, can those private officers enforce traffic laws on town streets?
No. The AG concluded that NC Special Police (NCSP) officers, who hold their authority as company police officers under Chapter 74E, are limited by § 74E-6(c) to law enforcement on their employer's rea…
Can a North Carolina county adopt a local ordinance adding its own late-payment penalty or administrative fee on top of the statewide property tax interest schedule?
No. The AG read the Machinery Act in Subchapter II of Chapter 105 as a comprehensive, integrated statewide scheme that fully occupied the field of delinquent property tax penalties. The Act already im…
Can a North Carolina state senator take a marketing job with a nonprofit institute and earn commissions on sales it makes to local governments, other states, and private parties without violating the state's public-contracting conflict-of-interest law?
Yes, likely. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that Senator Stephen Metcalf could probably accept a Director of Development position with Mars Hill Institute and receive compensation tied to sales of the In…
When does a business in North Carolina need to have an air-pollution permit in hand: when it finishes building a new pollution source, or when it starts construction?
Start of construction. The 2001 NC AG opinion interpreted N.C.G.S. § 143-215.108(a)(2) to require an air-permit before any on-site assembling of materials that will constitute a 'source' of air contam…
Can a North Carolina town hire a private company police agency, by contract, to act as the town's police force on public streets and inside private businesses, or are those officers limited to their employer's own property?
No. AG Mike Easley's office concluded that company police officers, as defined in N.C.G.S. § 74E-6(c), have law enforcement authority only on the real property of their employer (or property the emplo…
Can a North Carolina county require carbon monoxide alarms in new homes if the State Building Code does not, or does state law preempt that?
Only partly. The NC AG concluded in 2001 that Mecklenburg County's ordinance requiring carbon monoxide alarms was likely unenforceable as applied to new construction because the State Building Code fr…
When the federal Environmental Protection Agency shares draft hazardous-site rankings or other pre-decisional documents with North Carolina's environmental department, do North Carolina's open records laws require the state to release them to the public, or can the state keep them confidential under federal Freedom of Information Act exemptions?
The state can keep them confidential, but only by using a specific statutory channel. The 2001 NC AG opinion explained that N.C.G.S. § 130A-304(a)(2), added in 1991 at the EPA's request, makes informa…
Could North Carolina successfully challenge the federal open-container law in court, on the theory that Congress overstepped its spending power by conditioning federal highway funds on states adopting that specific drunk-driving rule?
No, the 2001 NC AG opinion concluded that a constitutional challenge to the federal open container requirements in 23 U.S.C. § 154 would not likely succeed. The 1987 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Sou…
Can the North Carolina Board of Mortuary Science still enforce its long-standing rule against funeral home advertising of discounts and credits, given recent U.S. Supreme Court cases protecting commercial speech under the First Amendment?
Yes, but only carefully. The 2000 NC AG opinion drew a sharp distinction. When N.C. Gen. Stat. § 90-210.25(e)(1)f is applied to prohibit funeral home licensees from paying actual referral fees or comm…
When a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge is elected in 1998 to fill a vacancy left by a retiring judge, is the elected term eight years or only the unexpired remainder of the prior judge's term?
Eight years. AG Mike Easley's office concluded that under N.C. Gen. Stat. § 163-9(b)'s second paragraph, when a vacancy occurs in a multi-judge superior court district located entirely in a county not…
Can the elected mayor of a North Carolina town also serve as Tribal Chairman of the Lumbee Indian Tribe, or does North Carolina's dual office holding rule force the mayor to give up one of the positions?
Yes, the mayor can do both. The 2000 NC AG opinion concluded that Mr. Milton R. Hunt, the elected mayor of Pembroke, could also serve as Tribal Chairman of the Lumbee Tribe without violating North Car…
When a county board fires an entire hospital authority and there are no remaining hospital commissioners to nominate replacements, who can appoint the new commissioners?
The AG declined to issue an advisory opinion because the same issue was already being litigated in Onslow County Superior Court. The AG's office said it ordinarily declines to opine on matters that ar…
If six Chapel Hill police officers should have been enrolled in their retirement system in mid-1984 but weren't enrolled until November 1984 by mistake, can they now buy that omitted service and retroactively qualify for the Bailey tax exemption on their retirement benefits?
No. AG Mike Easley's office concluded that the Bailey tax exemption depends on whether the employee was vested in the retirement system on August 12, 1989, when the General Assembly first taxed those …
Browse North Carolina opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in North Carolina are written by the North Carolina Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.