California Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in California, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No California opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Did a LoJack tracking device count as a theft deterrent in a financed car sale?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the described LoJack tracking and early-warning systems were theft deterrent devices for conditional car-sale disclosure. The seller had to…
When could a funeral director require a county coroner to take unclaimed remains?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the director could require the coroner to take remains after determining that burial was not provided for by the decedent or estate and that no…
Could the Native American Heritage Commission delegate sacred-site investigations to its executive secretary?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the executive secretary could investigate, hold hearings, and prepare recommended findings. The commission had to retain final judgment and…
Did a San Francisco supervisor’s disputed residency justify a court challenge?
The California Attorney General granted leave in 2007 to sue in quo warranto over whether Edmund Jew met District Four residency requirements. The opinion found a substantial question and a public…
Did a student trustee have to quit a part-time job at the community college district?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the district did not have to terminate the student’s employment on appointment to its governing board. The employment-termination rule for…
Did granting a conservation easement for mitigation credits require a subdivision map?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the described grant did not trigger the Subdivision Map Act. The company kept ownership and possession of the land, and neither the easement…
Could a sheriff give a civilian an honorary badge?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that a badge could not falsely imply peace officer authority or, with the sheriff’s knowledge, falsely imply membership in a predominantly law…
Did a dealer need a repossession license to collect a voluntarily returned leased car?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the dealer needed a repossession-agency license when collecting an expired-lease car for the lessor under contract, even though the lessee…
Could a superintendent bar an employee from a public board meeting about his demotion?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the superintendent could not stop the employee from attending the public school board meeting or speaking during public comment on the agenda…
Could the public inspect a county receipt showing documentary transfer tax?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that the recorder did not have to copy a separate tax-amount paper before returning it with the recorded deed. If the recorder kept an accounting…
Could a county contribute to CalPERS health coverage for retired supervisors with short service?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that a county could contribute for a retired supervisor who was a CalPERS member and otherwise eligible for coverage, even where the supervisor did…
Could a water district manager represent the district on a county water authority board?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that a general manager or department head of a member water agency, or a city manager or department head of a member city, could sit on the county…
Could California State University screen design-build bidders before inviting bids, and when did subcontractor protections attach?
The California AG said CSU could use selection criteria before inviting design-build bids, but had to tell qualified prospective contractors the criteria and their weighting and evaluation. Once…
Could one person sit on both the Metropolitan Water District and Water Replenishment District boards?
No. The California AG concluded in 2007 that the Metropolitan Water District seat representing West Basin Municipal Water District was incompatible with a Water Replenishment District directorship…
Could an unpaid volunteer investigator appointed by a district attorney be a peace officer?
The California Attorney General concluded in 2007 that unpaid status alone did not prevent peace officer classification. The volunteer had to perform investigator duties and meet all legal…
Could a common interest development use a pellet gun to control rabbits damaging its landscaping, including at night or near a home?
The California AG concluded in 2007 that an association employee could use air powered pellets against cottontail rabbits materially damaging the association’s landscaping. State hunting…
Would the California AG authorize a quo warranto suit over disputed seats on the Indio Housing Development Corporation board?
No. The AG declined to authorize the suit because the nonprofit corporation’s directors were not public officials, a corporation-election remedy was available, and the dispute did not warrant…
Could a city sign subdivision improvement and reimbursement agreements with a developer who employed a city council member?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the city could sign the specified Subdivision Map Act agreements if the council member disclosed the interest and abstained from voting on any matter…
Could CalPERS spread the cost of retroactive pension benefits beyond the affected employees’ average remaining work years?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that CalPERS could use a longer amortization period without necessarily violating its constitutional pension duties. The opinion examined a 20-year schedule and…
Did California’s preliminary and clear speech-language pathology credentials meet federal Medicaid reimbursement standards?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that both newly specified credentials met the federal speech pathologist standards for Medicaid reimbursement. The preliminary credential matched the…
Could a city give money to a nonprofit chamber of commerce whose president was a council member and whose employee was that member’s spouse?
The California AG said in 2006 that the council could make the donation under a remote-interest exception if the member disclosed the financial interest, the council recorded it, and the member did…
Could a tribe conduct Class III gaming on an individual Indian’s trust allotment outside a reservation or on land it began governing after 1988?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that either situation could qualify only in limited circumstances. Outside a reservation, trust or restricted title alone was insufficient: a tribe also had to…
Would raising school districts’ CalSTRS employer contributions automatically raise California’s Proposition 98 school-funding minimum?
No. The California AG concluded in 2006 that raising the employer contribution rate paid by school districts to CalSTRS would not, by itself, increase the state’s Proposition 98 funding obligation.…
Could a California county give trash haulers exclusive areas and set rates, and which planning meetings had to be open?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a county could assign exclusive collection areas and set maximum rates. The board had to allow public comment before acting, but staff meetings with haulers…
Where did CalPERS have to deposit and spend Medicare Part D retiree drug subsidies, and who received Medicare Advantage payments?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that Retiree Drug Subsidy payments for CalPERS supplemental plans belonged in the Public Employees’ Contingency Reserve Fund for specified uses benefiting the…
Can a police officer refuse internal-affairs questions about a spouse by claiming marital privilege?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the confidential-marital-communications privilege did not apply during the internal affairs interrogation it examined. After warning that refusal could lead…
Can a community college board renegotiate faculty health benefits when one trustee receives matching retiree benefits?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the board could renegotiate the benefits, but the financially interested trustee had to stay out of all discussions, negotiations, and decisions.
Could a California prosecutor release database criminal histories in response to a public records request?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the prosecutor could not release the requested database records or compiled criminal histories. Limited current information from investigatory files still…
Could California parole officials house multiple registered sex offender parolees in a licensed small residential care facility?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation could place two or more such parolees in a residential facility serving six or fewer people, as defined by…
Could a city approve a condominium subdivision improvement agreement when a council member rented a unit and could receive tenant assistance?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the city could enter the agreement on the stated facts: the tentative map and assistance program predated the member’s tenancy, the agreement carried those…
Could California’s Prison Industry Board create a second civil-service-exempt job for its executive officer?
No. The California AG concluded in 2006 that the board had already used its single constitutional exempt employee position for the Prison Industry Authority’s general manager, so it could not create…
Could a county keep special education property taxes when a school district took over the program?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the county superintendent could retain the taxes if they funded other special education programs while access countywide was maintained. State and federal…
Who appoints planning commissioners in a California general law city with an elected mayor?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the elected mayor selected planning commissioners, but each appointment required city council approval.
Could a California LAFCO make city incorporation depend on voter approval of a general tax, and approve that condition by majority vote?
Yes. The California AG concluded in 2006 that a local agency formation commission could condition incorporation on the proposed city’s voters approving a general tax. The commission could adopt that…
Could a California online charter school receive state funding for students living outside its county and adjacent counties?
No. The California AG concluded in 2006 that an online charter school could not claim state funding for students outside its chartering county and neighboring counties, because online nonclassroom…
How did a California general law city calculate a council salary increase after several years, and could it raise a mayor’s extra pay midterm?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the authorized annual percentage was applied to the salary actually being received for the years since the last adjustment, without compounding on unreceived…
Could one California county officer serve as treasurer, auditor, and tax collector and also sit on the county retirement board?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the three finance offices could be consolidated by ordinance despite their ordinarily conflicting audit duties. A treasurer who was also auditor could serve…
Could a California services district stop road and snow work after property owners rejected an assessment increase?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the district could end road maintenance and snow removal in the affected zone when owners rejected the needed assessment increase. It could dissolve the zone…
Could a city stop its chamber of commerce from posting a political sign on city-leased land?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the city could not bar the independent chamber’s political message on its sign under the silent lease and visitors-bureau contract described. The chamber…
Did California’s 2006 limits on city council commission payments reduce the pay of members already serving a term?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the amendments did not reduce compensation already received by council members during terms begun before January 1, 2006. The new limits applied to terms…
Could a lender collect on an auto dealer’s surety bond when the dealer failed to repay a loan used to buy a car at auction?
No, not under the unpaid-seller provision the California AG analyzed in 2006. The auction seller had been paid; the lender’s loss was a separate loan default. The opinion left open claims under…
Could a city airport commissioner rent a public hangar and vote on proposed rental rates?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that commissioners could rent city hangars on the same first-come, set-rate terms as other users. A renter generally could not take part in a rate decision…
Could a California teacher retiree direct part of a pension payment to a political action committee?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that CalSTRS could make a member-requested deduction and send it to a political action committee if the committee paid any added administrative cost.
Must a California local board report a closed-session vote to keep an employee it considered firing?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a board that rejected a proposed dismissal and retained the employee did not have to publicly report that decision or each member’s vote or abstention under…
Could California city council members redirect city-paid health benefits into deferred compensation without exceeding their salary cap?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that council members could make this switch under the city plan it examined. The city offered the same benefits to employees, and the redirected funds became a…
Could California police demand press credentials before releasing an arrestee address for a journalism request?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a sworn declaration of journalistic purpose sufficed under the provision it examined; police could not insist on press credentials or publication records. A…
Could a California city reserve toddler playground equipment for young children?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a city could restrict use of small-child play equipment in a park’s tot lot to young children. The age limit served the stated safety and…
Did California’s Megan’s Law website rule make registered sex offenders a protected housing class?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the ban on misusing website information for housing decisions did not by itself make registrants a protected class under the Fair Employment and Housing Act.…
Which local governments and projects qualified for California tribal casino impact grants in 2006?
The California AG read “local government jurisdiction” for proximity-based nexus grants as a city’s or county’s territory, excluding special districts from that grant category. Eligible projects had…
Could a hospital district keep contracting with partnerships partly held by a director’s spouse’s IRA, or buy out that interest?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the district could not make or renew contracts with the partnerships while the spouse’s IRA held the interests, despite their small size. A sale to an…
Did a California school speech-language services credential by itself qualify its holder as a federal Medicaid speech pathologist?
No. The California AG concluded in 2006 that the credential’s requirements were not equivalent to the federal standard because they lacked a comparable specialized exam and a post-graduate mentored…
Did the California AG authorize a quo warranto case over a disputed appointment to the Mojave Water Agency board?
Yes. The AG granted leave to sue in 2006 because competing claims about whether the earlier board vote filled the vacancy raised substantial factual and legal questions in the public interest. It…
Could a California city modify a water-company lease when a council member worked for the company?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the city could modify the lease under the remote-interest exception if the company and council member met its conditions, the interest was disclosed and…
Did the California AG authorize a court challenge to a community services district director’s disputed residence?
Yes. In 2006 the AG granted leave for a quo warranto suit because the director’s eligibility and claimed district domicile raised substantial factual and legal questions. It did not decide whether…
Can the public inspect grading and soils reports as soon as a California city receives a building-permit application?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that interim geology, compaction, and soils reports submitted with a building-permit application were open to inspection and copying when the building department…
Could a California doctor prescribe a device sold by a company the doctor owned in part?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a physician generally could prescribe such a device if investment returns followed proportional ownership and required disclosures were made. A company in…
Could a county use Mental Health Services Act funds to pay the usual staff of a mental health court?
No. The California AG concluded in 2006 that the Act did not fund customary court staff, including judges, clerks, prosecutors, and public defenders, even under an approved county mental health…
Could a California city and county exchange property tax revenue without changing their boundaries?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a city and county could agree to change their shares of property tax revenue without a boundary or service change, if the statutory procedures and conditions…
Could California enforce vehicle registration and driver-license rules against tribal members on reservation roads?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that the two state requirements could not be enforced against tribal members on roads within their reservation. It classified those requirements as civil…
Could a California school district buy permanent modular school buildings through another agency without bidding?
The California AG concluded in 2006 that a district could not use the public-agency purchasing provision to avoid advertised bids for factory-built components destined for permanent school buildings.
Browse California opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in California are written by the California Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.