AUTOMATED DECISION APPEAL PROCESS

DOCUMENT CONTROL

1. PURPOSE AND SCOPE

1.1 Purpose

This Automated Decision Appeal Process ("Process") establishes procedures for individuals to:

• Challenge decisions made wholly or substantially by automated systems
• Request human review of automated decisions
• Provide additional information or context
• Receive explanations of how automated decisions were made
• Obtain corrections to erroneous decisions

1.2 Regulatory Basis

This Process is established in accordance with:

☐ GDPR Article 22 (Right not to be subject to automated decision-making)
☐ EU AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689) human oversight requirements
☐ Colorado AI Act (SB 24-205) appeal and explanation rights
☐ California privacy laws (CCPA/CPRA)
☐ Illinois AI employment laws
☐ NYC Local Law 144 (automated employment decision tools)
☐ Other applicable regulations: [SPECIFY]

1.3 Scope

This Process applies to:

☐ Decisions made solely by automated processing
☐ Decisions where automated processing is a substantial factor
☐ Profiling that produces legal or similarly significant effects
☐ High-risk AI system decisions affecting individuals

Decision Categories Covered:

☐ Employment decisions (hiring, promotion, termination)
☐ Credit and lending decisions
☐ Insurance underwriting and claims
☐ Service eligibility and access
☐ Pricing and terms offered
☐ Educational assessments
☐ Healthcare access decisions
☐ Housing decisions
☐ Government benefit determinations
☐ Other: [SPECIFY]

1.4 Exclusions

This Process does NOT apply to:

☐ Decisions required by law or contract
☐ Decisions where explicit consent was obtained
☐ Purely administrative or operational automation
☐ [OTHER EXCLUSIONS]

2. DEFINITIONS

Appellant: An individual who submits an appeal under this Process.

Automated Decision: A decision made wholly or substantially through automated processing, including AI, machine learning, algorithms, or other automated systems, without meaningful human involvement.

Consequential Decision: A decision that has a material legal or similarly significant effect on an individual, such as affecting employment, credit, insurance, housing, education, or access to services.

Human Review: Substantive review of an automated decision by a qualified human reviewer who has authority to override the decision.

Meaningful Human Involvement: Human participation that involves genuine assessment and discretion, not merely rubber-stamping automated outputs.

Reviewer: A qualified individual designated to conduct human review of automated decisions.

3. INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS

3.1 Right to Information

Individuals have the right to:

☐ Be informed when an automated decision is made
☐ Receive meaningful information about the logic involved
☐ Understand the significance and potential consequences
☐ Know what data was used in the decision

3.2 Right to Human Review

Individuals have the right to:

☐ Request human review of automated decisions
☐ Have the decision reconsidered by a qualified human
☐ Have the human reviewer consider additional information
☐ Receive a decision from the human review

3.3 Right to Express Views

Individuals have the right to:

☐ Submit a written appeal
☐ Provide additional context or information
☐ Explain personal circumstances
☐ Correct factual errors in the data used

3.4 Right to Explanation

Individuals have the right to:

☐ Understand the main factors in the decision
☐ Know which data elements influenced the outcome
☐ Understand why the decision was made
☐ Receive an explanation in plain language

3.5 Right to Correction

Individuals have the right to:

☐ Have incorrect data corrected
☐ Have the decision reconsidered with corrected data
☐ Receive notice if the decision changes

4. APPEAL PROCESS

4.1 Process Overview

┌─────────────────┐
│ 1. Notification │ Individual informed of automated decision
└────────┬────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────┐
│ 2. Appeal Filed │ Individual submits appeal request
└────────┬────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────┐
│ 3. Acknowledge │ Receipt acknowledged within [X] days
└────────┬────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────┐
│ 4. Review │ Qualified human conducts review
└────────┬────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────┐
│ 5. Decision │ Decision communicated to individual
└────────┬────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────┐
│ 6. Escalation │ (If applicable) Second-level review
└─────────────────┘

4.2 Step 1: Notification of Automated Decision

When an automated decision is made:

(a) Information Provided:

☐ Clear statement that an automated decision has been made
☐ Summary of the decision and its effect
☐ Main factors that influenced the decision
☐ Information about the right to appeal
☐ How to submit an appeal
☐ Timeframe for appealing
☐ Contact information for questions

(b) Notification Method:

☐ Written notice (letter, email)
☐ In-application notification
☐ Verbal notification with written follow-up
☐ Other: [SPECIFY]

(c) Timing:

Notification provided: ☐ At time of decision ☐ Within [X] days of decision

4.3 Step 2: Filing an Appeal

(a) How to Appeal:

Appeals may be submitted via:

(b) Required Information:

The appeal should include:

☐ Appellant's name and contact information
☐ Reference number or identification of the decision
☐ Date of the decision being appealed
☐ Reason(s) for the appeal
☐ Supporting information or documentation
☐ Desired outcome

(c) Appeal Timeframe:

Appeals must be submitted within: [NUMBER] days of receiving the decision

☐ Late appeals may be considered at [ORGANIZATION NAME]'s discretion for good cause

(d) Assistance:

☐ Assistance is available for individuals who need help filing appeals
☐ Accessibility accommodations available upon request
☐ Language assistance available for: [LANGUAGES]

4.4 Step 3: Acknowledgment

(a) Upon receipt, [ORGANIZATION NAME] will:

☐ Acknowledge receipt within [NUMBER] business days
☐ Provide a reference number for the appeal
☐ Confirm the expected timeline for review
☐ Request additional information if needed

(b) Acknowledgment will include:

☐ Confirmation of what is being appealed
☐ Explanation of the review process
☐ Expected timeframe for decision
☐ Contact for questions

4.5 Step 4: Human Review

(a) Reviewer Qualifications:

Human review will be conducted by individuals who:

☐ Have appropriate training and expertise
☐ Were not involved in the original automated decision
☐ Have authority to override the automated decision
☐ Understand the relevant policies and criteria
☐ Are trained on bias recognition and mitigation

(b) Review Process:

The reviewer will:

☐ Examine the original data and automated decision
☐ Consider the appellant's stated reasons for appeal
☐ Review any additional information provided
☐ Apply relevant policies, criteria, and professional judgment
☐ Determine whether the decision should be upheld, modified, or reversed
☐ Document the review and rationale

(c) Standard of Review:

The reviewer will evaluate:

☐ Whether the automated decision was accurate
☐ Whether the data used was correct and complete
☐ Whether the decision was consistent with applicable policies
☐ Whether individual circumstances warrant a different outcome
☐ Whether any errors or biases affected the decision

(d) Timeline:

Human review will be completed within: [NUMBER] business days

☐ Complex cases may require additional time with notice to appellant

4.6 Step 5: Decision Communication

(a) The review decision will be communicated:

☐ In writing (letter, email)
☐ Within [NUMBER] business days of completing review
☐ In plain language understandable to the appellant

(b) The decision communication will include:

☐ The outcome (upheld, modified, reversed)
☐ Explanation of the reasoning
☐ If upheld: why the original decision stands
☐ If modified/reversed: what the new decision is
☐ Information about further appeal rights (if any)
☐ Contact information for questions

4.7 Step 6: Escalation (Second-Level Review)

(a) Availability:

☐ Second-level review available for: [SPECIFY CIRCUMSTANCES]
☐ No second-level review available

(b) If Available:

5. EXPLANATION OF DECISIONS

5.1 Initial Explanation

With the automated decision, individuals receive:

(a) General Information:
☐ That an automated system was used
☐ The type of system used
☐ The purpose of the system
☐ How the system generally works

(b) Decision-Specific Information:
☐ The main factors that influenced the decision
☐ The data elements that were significant
☐ The general logic or criteria applied
☐ The outcome and its effects

5.2 Detailed Explanation Upon Request

Upon request, individuals may receive:

☐ More detailed information about the decision logic
☐ Information about specific data points used
☐ Relative importance of different factors
☐ How changing certain inputs might affect the outcome
☐ Information about the automated system's performance and limitations

5.3 Limitations on Explanations

Explanations may be limited where disclosure would:

☐ Reveal trade secrets or proprietary algorithms
☐ Compromise security or enable gaming of the system
☐ Violate legal restrictions
☐ Infringe third-party rights

In such cases, we will provide the maximum feasible explanation.

6. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES

6.1 Organizational Roles

6.2 Contact Information

6.3 Training Requirements

Personnel involved in the appeal process must complete:

☐ Training on this Process
☐ Training on relevant automated systems
☐ Bias awareness training
☐ Data protection training
☐ Customer service/communication training
☐ [OTHER TRAINING]

7. TIMELINES

7.1 Summary of Timelines

7.2 Extensions

☐ Timelines may be extended for complex cases with notice to appellant
☐ Extensions require approval from [ROLE]
☐ Maximum extension: [X] additional days

7.3 Expedited Review

Expedited review may be available when:

☐ Significant ongoing harm
☐ Time-sensitive circumstances
☐ [OTHER CRITERIA]

To request: [PROCESS FOR REQUESTING EXPEDITED REVIEW]

8. DOCUMENTATION AND RECORDS

8.1 Records Maintained

For each appeal, the following records will be maintained:

☐ Appeal submission and all correspondence
☐ Original automated decision and data used
☐ Reviewer notes and analysis
☐ Final determination and rationale
☐ Timeline tracking
☐ Communications with appellant

8.2 Retention Period

Appeal records retained for: [PERIOD]

8.3 Confidentiality

Appeal records are confidential and accessible only to:

☐ Personnel involved in processing the appeal
☐ Oversight and audit functions
☐ As required by law

8.4 Audit Trail

An audit trail is maintained showing:

☐ Who accessed the appeal record
☐ What actions were taken
☐ When actions occurred

9. MONITORING AND REPORTING

9.1 Metrics Tracked

9.2 Reporting

Reports on appeal activity are provided to:

9.3 Continuous Improvement

☐ Appeal trends analyzed for systemic issues
☐ High overturn rates trigger system review
☐ Feedback used to improve automated systems
☐ Process improvements implemented as needed

10. SPECIAL CIRCUMSTANCES

10.1 Vulnerable Individuals

For appeals involving vulnerable individuals:

☐ Additional support and assistance available
☐ Extended timeframes may apply
☐ Accessibility accommodations provided
☐ Representatives may act on behalf of individuals

10.2 Employment Decisions

For appeals of employment-related automated decisions:

☐ Reviewed by HR and/or legal as appropriate
☐ Compliance with employment laws ensured
☐ Confidentiality maintained within organization
☐ [ADDITIONAL EMPLOYMENT-SPECIFIC PROCEDURES]

10.3 Financial Decisions

For appeals of credit, lending, or financial decisions:

☐ Compliance with fair lending laws
☐ Adverse action notice requirements followed
☐ Credit bureau dispute procedures coordinated
☐ [ADDITIONAL FINANCIAL-SPECIFIC PROCEDURES]

10.4 Group Appeals

If multiple individuals appeal similar decisions:

☐ May be reviewed together for efficiency
☐ Individual circumstances still considered
☐ Systemic issues addressed organization-wide

11. EXTERNAL RESOURCES

11.1 Regulatory Authorities

Individuals may also contact relevant regulatory authorities:

11.2 Legal Assistance

Individuals seeking legal advice may contact:

☐ Legal aid organizations
☐ Consumer protection agencies
☐ Private legal counsel

12. PROCESS REVIEW AND UPDATES

12.1 Review Schedule

This Process will be reviewed:

☐ Annually
☐ When significant regulatory changes occur
☐ After significant operational changes to automated systems
☐ After significant appeal volume or pattern changes

12.2 Version History

APPENDIX A: APPEAL FORM

AUTOMATED DECISION APPEAL FORM

Section 1: Your Information

Name: _________________________________

Email: _________________________________

Phone: _________________________________

Mailing Address: _________________________________

Preferred Contact Method: ☐ Email ☐ Phone ☐ Mail

Section 2: Decision Information

Decision Reference Number (if known): _________________________________

Date of Decision: _________________________________

Type of Decision:
☐ Employment (hiring, promotion, termination)
☐ Credit or lending
☐ Insurance
☐ Service eligibility
☐ Other: _________________________________

Brief Description of Decision:

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

Section 3: Reason for Appeal

Please explain why you believe the decision should be reviewed:

☐ The decision was based on incorrect information
☐ Relevant information was not considered
☐ The decision does not reflect my circumstances
☐ I believe the decision was unfair or biased
☐ Other: _________________________________

Detailed Explanation:

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

Section 4: Supporting Information

Please describe any additional information you would like considered:

_________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

☐ I have attached supporting documents (list): _________________________________

Section 5: Desired Outcome

What outcome are you seeking?

_________________________________________________________________

Section 6: Acknowledgment

☐ I confirm the information provided is accurate to the best of my knowledge
☐ I understand my appeal will be reviewed by a human reviewer
☐ I consent to [ORGANIZATION NAME] processing my personal data for the appeal

Signature: _________________________________ Date: _____________

Submission:

☐ Email to: [EMAIL]
☐ Mail to: [ADDRESS]
☐ Online at: [URL]
☐ In person at: [LOCATION]

APPENDIX B: ACKNOWLEDGMENT LETTER TEMPLATE

[DATE]

[APPELLANT NAME]
[ADDRESS]

RE: Appeal Acknowledgment - Reference #[NUMBER]

Dear [NAME],

Thank you for submitting your appeal regarding the [TYPE OF DECISION] dated [DATE].

Appeal Reference Number: [NUMBER]

Please use this reference number in all future correspondence about this appeal.

What Happens Next:

1. Your appeal will be reviewed by a qualified human reviewer who was not involved in the original decision.

2. The reviewer will examine the original decision, consider the reasons you provided for your appeal, and review any additional information you submitted.

3. You will receive a written decision within [NUMBER] business days.

If You Have Questions:

Contact: [NAME/DEPARTMENT]
Email: [EMAIL]
Phone: [PHONE]

Thank you for bringing this matter to our attention.

Sincerely,

[NAME]
[TITLE]
[ORGANIZATION]

APPENDIX C: DECISION LETTER TEMPLATE

[DATE]

[APPELLANT NAME]
[ADDRESS]

RE: Appeal Decision - Reference #[NUMBER]

Dear [NAME],

We have completed our review of your appeal regarding the [TYPE OF DECISION] dated [DATE].

Decision: ☐ Original Decision Upheld ☐ Decision Modified ☐ Decision Reversed

Explanation:

[PROVIDE CLEAR EXPLANATION OF THE DECISION AND REASONING]

[If Upheld]:
After careful human review, we have determined that the original decision was correct because:
[EXPLANATION]

[If Modified/Reversed]:
Based on our review, we have changed the decision. The new decision is:
[NEW DECISION AND EXPLANATION]

Next Steps:

[EXPLAIN ANY NEXT STEPS]

Further Appeal Rights:

☐ This decision is final
☐ You may request a second-level review by [DEADLINE] by [METHOD]
☐ You may contact [REGULATORY AUTHORITY] if you remain dissatisfied

Questions:

Contact: [NAME/DEPARTMENT]
Email: [EMAIL]
Phone: [PHONE]

Sincerely,

[NAME]
[TITLE]
[ORGANIZATION]

This Automated Decision Appeal Process template is provided for informational purposes. Organizations should customize based on their specific automated systems, applicable regulations, and legal counsel advice.