Utah State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in Utah, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Utah rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Was sales tax due when an equipment lessor billed a Utah lessee for the exact personal property tax assessed on that leased equipment?
No. When the lessor merely passed through to its lease customer the exact personal property tax assessed on the specific leased equipment, no sales tax was due on that reimbursement under Tax…
Does a trash compactor bought for an expanded manufacturing facility qualify for Utah's manufacturer's sales tax exemption?
No. The Utah State Tax Commission ruled that a trash compactor purchased for an expanding manufacturing facility does not qualify for the manufacturer's sales tax exemption under Utah Code §…
Does a federal agency keep its sales and transient room tax exemption on employee lodging when a contractor handles the billing?
Yes, but only if the government's own money actually pays the hotel — the check must be made payable to the hotel and traceable to the agency's funds, not simply channeled through a contractor's own…
Were fees to enter and use a children's fitness and play facility subject to Utah sales tax?
No. The Commission treated the children's fitness and play facility as a health club, so fees paid to enter and use it were not subject to sales tax. The business still had to collect tax on…
Did the Utah State Tax Commission decide whether vehicles bought in Utah and immediately transferred to a bottler's out-of-state subsidiaries qualify for the nonresident-purchaser sales tax exemption?
No. The Commission refused to issue an advisory opinion at all, because the taxpayer's exemption question was already pending on appeal before the Commission itself -- ruling in advance would have…
Did an out-of-state aircraft lessor create Utah corporate income-tax nexus when its lessee brought the aircraft into Utah, and how was the lease income apportioned?
Yes. The leased aircraft's presence in Utah during the tax period created sufficient nexus for the lessor, even though the lessee controlled where the aircraft traveled. All three UDITPA factors…
Who owed Utah sales tax on 1-900 telephone charges, revenue-sharing payments, and monthly line-rental amounts?
The caller's telephone company had to collect sales tax on the full amount charged to the end user for the 900 call. The later remittances from the phone company through the service bureau and…
Did a dental laboratory making custom dentures, artificial teeth, and orthodontic appliances qualify for Utah's manufacturing machinery-and-equipment exemption?
No. The Commission classified a dental laboratory making dentures, artificial teeth, and orthodontic appliances to order under SIC 8072, which was not a manufacturing SIC code. SIC 3843 covered…
Were lease payments taxable when a customer sold previously taxed fixed assets to a finance company and leased them back under a financing-style agreement?
Yes. The customer's sale of its used fixed assets to the lessor qualified for the resale exemption, but the leaseback payments were taxable. Utah sales-tax law did not distinguish a lease intended…
Did a computerized advertising and page-makeup workstation used before typesetting qualify for Utah's manufacturing machinery exemption?
Yes. In a revised June 10, 1991 opinion, the Commission reversed its earlier denial and concluded that the computerized ad-makeup workstation qualified as manufacturing equipment, making its…
Did a taxpayer's misclassification of personal property and use of the wrong percent-good factor create an erroneous or illegal assessment under Utah Code § 59-2-1321?
No. The Commission said an erroneous or illegal assessment under § 59-2-1321 required a jurisdictional legal defect, not a mistake in valuation judgment. A taxpayer's misclassification of tangible…
If a company buys a business's assets tax-free as an exempt bulk/isolated sale, but separately leases equipment from the same seller with an option to buy, is the later lease buyout also exempt?
No. Utah sales tax applies to each transaction separately, so exercising an option to buy leased equipment is a distinct, taxable transaction from the earlier exempt bulk-asset purchase -- once the…
Does selling an entire business still qualify for Utah's isolated-or-occasional-sale sales tax exemption when the deal is structured through an asset purchase agreement plus a 20-year lease-with-purchase-option instead of a simple sale?
Yes, with one carve-out. The Utah State Tax Commission confirmed that selling an entire business qualifies for the isolated-or-occasional-sale sales tax exemption (then § 59-12-104(14), Rule…
For an oil field tool rental company, which of its many charges to customers — tool rental, sub-rentals, sales, repairs, freight, supervisor time, mileage, and inspections — are subject to Utah sales tax?
Almost everything is taxable, with two narrow exceptions. Tool rentals (including sub-rentals) are always taxable, and sales are taxable unless they qualify as an exempt interstate sale or a sale to…
Are industrial gasses like oxygen, acetylene, argon, nitrogen, and carbon dioxide exempt from Utah sales and use tax when used in a manufacturing process?
It depends on which gas. Oxygen and acetylene qualify as exempt "fuel" gasses under Utah's manufacturing fuel exemption (then Rule R865-19-35S) and are not taxed when used in a manufacturing process…
Does the sales tax exemption for manufacturing equipment used in new or expanding operations cover high-speed duplicating/photocopy machines at a printing company's satellite locations that have no printing press?
No — not automatically. The Commission applies the manufacturing equipment exemption on a per-location ('establishment') basis. A printing company's central plant, which houses actual offset…
Could a printed-circuit-board manufacturer buy soldering flux tax-free as a component part because some flux residue remained on the finished boards?
No. The Commission treated the flux as a taxable consumed supply because it was intended to clean and activate surfaces during soldering, not to become part of the printed circuit board. The…
Is Utah's new petroleum environmental surcharge included in the taxable purchase price when calculating Utah sales tax on petroleum products?
No. The environmental surcharge is treated as an excise tax, not part of the taxable purchase price, so it is not subject to Utah sales tax -- the Commission reasoned by analogy to the Waste Tire…
Did an egg-processing company's new plant and production line qualify for Utah's manufacturing equipment exemption and a refund of tax already paid?
Yes, for qualifying production machinery. The Commission treated egg drying, freezing, and breaking under SIC 2017 as a separate manufacturing establishment at the new plant, so production equipment…
Did qualifying equipment for a new printed-circuit-board plant remain exempt when acquired through direct purchases, leases, sale-leasebacks, and lease-purchase financing?
Yes. Based on the represented uses, qualifying machinery and equipment for the new printed-circuit-board manufacturing facility were exempt whether acquired by direct purchase or through the…
Do audio- and video-tape duplication subsidiaries of a broadcasting company qualify as 'manufacturers' for Utah's sales tax exemption on new manufacturing equipment?
No, according to the Utah State Tax Commission's Advisory Opinion of December 3, 1990. Two subsidiaries of a Utah broadcasting company that mass-duplicated audio cassettes and video tapes for sale…
Did Utah's waste-tire recycling fee apply to tires sold separately or installed on garden tractors and lawn mowers?
No. The Act defined a covered tire by reference to a vehicle designed to transport people or property on a highway. Garden tractors and lawn mowers were not designed for highway transport, so the…
If a Utah parent company contributes its trade name, logo, and proprietary technology to a newly formed IP-holding subsidiary in exchange for stock, is the contribution tax-free, is the new subsidiary automatically part of the parent's unitary group from day one, and is the royalty income the subsidiary earns from licensing that IP back to affiliates (and to outsiders) treated as apportionable business income?
Yes to all three questions, on the facts presented. Contributing the trade name, logo, and proprietary technology solely in exchange for the new subsidiary's stock is a nonrecognition transaction…
Could a fulfillment business buy shipping containers and labels tax-free when it separately billed clients for those materials?
No. The Commission treated the fulfillment business as the consumer of containers, labels, and similar materials used to provide its nontaxable shipping and wrapping service. Separately billing the…
When were instrument calibration services taxable, and did single-use casts for fighter-aircraft parts qualify for Utah's aerospace government-contract exemption?
Calibration was nontaxable only when it was merely a test confirming proper operation and required no adjustment or repair. When calibration included adjustment, fixing, or repair, the entire…
Which of a food-manufacturing plant's capital projects -- new production-line equipment, checkweighers, bar-coding equipment, and computer systems -- qualify for Utah's manufacturing machinery and equipment sales tax exemption?
Mostly yes for the production equipment, no for the two general computer projects. Twelve capital projects -- new or upgraded production-line machinery, checkweighers, bar-coding equipment, and a…
Did an out-of-state mail-order seller have to register and collect Utah tax when Utah customers could place orders by telephone or mail?
Yes. Under the law applied in the revised February 26, 1990 response, a seller taking orders from Utah customers by any method other than direct-mail solicitation had to register and collect tax on…
Does Utah sales/use tax apply when a company withdraws leased equipment from its resale/lease inventory and transfers it to a related company in a reorganization?
Yes. Tax is due when equipment that was purchased tax-free for a resale/leasing inventory is withdrawn from that inventory for a purpose other than sale — including a transfer to a related company…
Could a Utah corporate headquarters use an old authorization number to self-accrue sales and use tax instead of paying tax to vendors?
No. The Commission said Utah law and rules did not authorize a direct-pay permit and it found no written authorization allowing the company to self-accrue tax. The company had to pay tax to vendors…
Were typesetting and typesetting-output services for artists, designers, advertising agencies, and printers subject to Utah sales tax?
No. The Commission said the described typesetting service was exempt from sales tax under the third paragraph of Tax Bulletin 8-89. The service bureau produced typesetting or output from…
Did the Utah State Tax Commission rule on whether newspaper printing/finishing equipment qualifies for the manufacturing sales tax exemption?
No ruling was issued here. A newspaper publisher asked the Utah State Tax Commission to confirm that its facsimile-receiving, stacking, wrapping, and labeling equipment qualified for the…
Are the fuels and electricity a clean-room manufacturer uses to build clean rooms exempt from Utah sales tax, and are 'clean rooms' themselves always exempt manufacturing equipment?
Yes for the manufacturer's own fuel and electricity: the Commission ruled the taxpayer, as a manufacturer of clean rooms, could buy fuel and electricity tax-free for use in manufacturing them. But…
When a company does both manufacturing and non-manufacturing work at the same location, what makes the manufacturing part a separate 'establishment' that qualifies for Utah's manufacturing equipment exemption?
It's an either/or test, and 'separate legal entity' does not mean what the taxpayer thought. A combined manufacturing/non-manufacturing operation qualifies as a separate manufacturing establishment…
Should multi-unit residential buildings still under construction on the property tax lien date be taxed at the residential rate or the commercial rate, and will the Commission set a uniform statewide policy?
The Commission DECLINED to issue an advisory opinion on this question, because the underlying dispute was already headed to a county Board of Equalization and could later come before the Commission…
How does the Utah State Tax Commission decide whether a manufacturing activity, performed at the same location as a non-manufacturing business, counts as a 'separate and distinct' establishment eligible for the manufacturing sales tax exemption?
Utah applies a three-step test under Admin. Rule R865-19S-85: (1) if the manufacturing and non-manufacturing activities are run by genuinely separate business entities, they're presumed separate and…
Is a manufacturer's sale and installation of backup power systems exempt from Utah sales tax when the United States government is the direct buyer and pays the manufacturer directly?
Yes. Sales of tangible personal property directly to the federal government are exempt from Utah sales tax, so a manufacturer's sale of backup power systems to a federal agency is exempt as long as…
Does a Utah tour operator have to charge sales tax on guided recreational activities, lodging, meals, and lessons bundled into a multi-day tour?
Yes for most of it. Admissions and user fees for recreational activities, plus charges for guide service, camping, lodging, meals, entrance onto private lands or waters, and equipment/facility use,…
Does an out-of-state vehicle registration exempt a rental car fleet vehicle from Utah property tax, and does the dealer inventory exemption apply to vehicles in active rental service?
This record does not give the requesting county assessor a direct, point-by-point answer to the specific SB 116 dealer-inventory-exemption question asked in the February 27, 1995 letter -- the…
Are items like foam meat trays, soaker pads, plastic wrap, deli containers, and grocery bags exempt from Utah sales tax when a grocery store buys them to package items sold to customers?
Yes. Nonreturnable containers and packaging materials that 'go out the door with the customer' along with the item sold — plastic produce bags, foam trays and soaker pads in the meat department,…
Can I rely on Utah Private Letter Ruling PLR 05-015?
No. The Commission's public archive shows only a notice that Private Letter Ruling 05-015 was reversed by the Tax Commission's Final Order, dated November 6, 2006, in Appeal No. 06-0125. The…
Who was the Utah seller, and who had to register, collect, and remit tax when one company fulfilled and marketed another company's merchandise without taking title?
Company B was the seller because it retained title until transfer to the customer. Company A acted as Company B's agent by processing orders, collecting payments, warehousing and shipping inventory,…
Does a Utah direct sales company owe Utah tax on free 'hostess gift' items it gives to party hosts who live in other states?
Yes. A Utah direct sales company that gives free 'hostess gift' items to people who host home sales parties is the 'donor' of those gifts under Utah Admin. Rule R865-19S-68(A), which treats a donor…
Does an out-of-state internet retailer create Utah sales tax nexus by letting customers pick up online orders at an affiliated Utah store, and if so, how does it collect and report the tax?
Yes. Even though the internet seller is a separate out-of-state legal entity from the Utah store, letting Utah customers pick up their online orders at that store means the internet seller is using…
Which of the various add-on charges on a truck-rental invoice -- insurance, damage waivers, furniture pads, replacement fees, repair costs, citations, cleaning, and IFTA fuel tax reimbursement -- are subject to Utah sales tax?
Personal accident insurance and loss damage waiver charges are taxable because the rental company (not a licensed insurer) is selling an add-on product, not insurance; furniture pad/dolly rentals,…
Can a statutory employee who mostly earns self-employment (Schedule C) income still deduct his own share of health insurance premiums when his employer pays part of the premium?
No. Utah Code Ann. § 59-10-114(3)(e)(ii) disallows the health insurance premium deduction whenever the taxpayer is eligible to participate in a plan funded in whole or in part by an employer — and…
Do out-of-state buses brought into Utah temporarily for a major event need Utah vehicle registration, license plates, or Utah property tax?
It depends on the bus's use and the owner's residency, not simply on being temporarily present. Buses owned by nonresidents and properly registered in their home state generally don't need Utah…
Is a contractor's work insulating oil-field pipes and storage tanks taxable installation labor on personal property, or nontaxable work on real property — and is this ruling still good law?
This ruling was WITHDRAWN by the Utah State Tax Commission on November 16, 2004 and cannot be relied on for current guidance. As issued, it held that insulating short well-to-tank pipe connections…
How did Utah tax teleconferencing services provided by facilities-based carriers or resellers, including separately billed long-distance and call-connection charges?
Utah treated teleconferencing as a taxable telephone feature when associated with an intrastate call and as nontaxable when the service was interstate. Both facilities-based carriers and companies…
Does a Native American tribal member owe Utah sales tax and the uniform fee (in lieu of property tax) when purchasing or leasing a motor vehicle, and did the Commission decide whether tribal members who teach school and live on the reservation owe Utah income tax?
A tribal member is exempt from vehicle sales/use tax if the sale or lease happens on the reservation (or the vehicle is delivered there) AND the buyer/lessee is an enrolled member living on the…
Browse Utah rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by Utah's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.