New York State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can an out-of-state seller with no New York presence cancel a sales tax registration it took on voluntarily?
Yes — the out-of-state seller may cancel its voluntary registration, because it is not otherwise required to collect New York tax. V. H. Blackington & Co., a Massachusetts manufacturer of uniform insi…
Can a store discard its detailed cash register tapes and keep only daily sales summaries?
No — daily cash register summaries are not an adequate substitute; the detailed cash register tapes must be kept. A CPA, Daniel Goldberg, asked on behalf of a client that makes only taxable sales whet…
Is a transfer of trucks and equipment to a corporation in exchange for its stock tax-free as an organizational transfer, when it happens long after the corporation was formed?
No — the transfer is a taxable retail sale, not a tax-free organizational transfer. New York excludes from 'retail sale' a transfer of property to a corporation upon its organization in exchange for i…
Must an out-of-state catalog seller with New York retailers and employee visits collect New York sales tax on its mail-order sales here?
Yes — the out-of-state catalog seller has nexus with New York and is a vendor that must collect New York sales and use tax on its retail mail-order sales to New York customers. The Orvis Company, a Ve…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-85 (5)I: If a New York corporation elects New York S corporation status and its only income is interest, dividends, and capital gains, is that investment income taxable to a nonresident shareholder even though the same income wouldn't be taxable if the nonresident earned it directly?
Yes. The Department ruled that a nonresident shareholder of an electing New York S corporation must include his pro rata share of the corporation's investment income (interest, dividends, and capital …
Is the admission charge to play a paintball 'survival game' — including the equipment used — subject to New York sales tax?
The admission charge to participate is not taxable, but separately sold extra supplies are. Charging patrons to play a paintball 'survival game' is an admission to a facility for a sporting activity i…
Is the single admission-and-equipment charge to play a paintball 'survival game' taxable, and what about a free t-shirt given to the winner?
The admission to play is not taxable, and the free winner's t-shirt is not taxed to the player, but the operator pays tax on both the equipment and the shirts. Charging a single fee to play a paintbal…
How is a vehicle lessor taxed on the diesel fuel and the various lease charges when it supplies fuel as part of the rental?
When a vehicle lessor supplies diesel fuel as part of the lease, it is treated as consuming its own fuel, and all its lease charges are taxable receipts. Because the lessor stores and dispenses diesel…
Must a college 501(c)(3) faculty-student association collect sales tax on admissions to the theatrical, athletic, recreational, and social events it holds to raise funds?
Mostly exempt, but athletic-event admissions are the key exception. The Jamestown Community College Faculty-Student Association is an IRC 501(c)(3) educational organization, presumed to qualify as a N…
When a gas utility transports natural gas that a customer or producer already owns or has under contract, under New York's 'contract carriage' program, do the utility franchise tax, the gross-income utility tax, MCTD surcharges, and sales tax apply to the fees the utility charges for that transport service?
The franchise tax under Section 186 applies to all contract-carriage fees as gross earnings. The gross-income tax under Section 186-a applies differently depending on the arrangement: if the utility i…
A food manufacturer incorporated in 1976 does a public stock offering that shifts about 36.5% of its shares to public investors -- founders still hold 63.5% -- does that ownership change make it a 'new business' eligible to cash out its unused investment tax credits as an immediate refund, instead of just carrying them forward?
No -- Petitioner is NOT a 'new business' under section 210.12(j) and cannot elect the immediate-refund treatment for its unused investment tax credit carryover. Even though roughly 36.5% of its outsta…
When a New York mutual savings bank converts to stock form -- a federal tax-free 'F reorganization' -- does New York's bank franchise tax and personal income tax follow the same tax-free treatment, both for the bank itself and for its depositors who receive stock subscription rights?
Yes, on both fronts. Because the mutual-to-stock conversion qualifies as a tax-free reorganization under IRC section 368(a)(1)(F) for federal purposes -- with no gain/loss to the bank, carryover basis…
When a New York mutual savings bank converts to stock form as a federal tax-free 'F reorganization,' does the bank owe any New York bank franchise (Article 32) tax on the conversion itself?
No new New York franchise tax results from the conversion itself. Because the mutual-to-stock conversion qualifies federally as a tax-free 'F reorganization' under IRC section 368(a)(1)(F) -- with no …
When a New York subsidiary with an unused net operating loss merges into its out-of-state parent, can the surviving parent carry that loss forward on its own New York corporation franchise tax return?
Yes, but only for the loss the subsidiary generated while it was actually subject to New York tax. Charrette Corporation could include, on its own New York franchise tax return, the net operating loss…
Is a freight forwarder that owns no trucks or planes taxed as a New York transportation corporation under Tax Law Sections 183-184, or as an ordinary business corporation under Article 9-A?
It depends on whether the forwarder acts as a principal or an agent. A freight forwarder that assumes control of and full responsibility for the shipment -- issuing its own bill of lading and paying t…
Can a homebuilder or commercial-building contractor claim New York's investment tax credit on the machinery and equipment it uses to construct homes and buildings?
No. New York's investment tax credit under Tax Law Sections 210.12 (corporations) and 606(a) (individuals) is limited to property principally used in the production of GOODS by manufacturing, processi…
Are a parent scrap-metal corporation and its New York subsidiary in a 'unitary business' for combined reporting purposes, and must the parent file a consolidated report with its separate DISC subsidiary?
Petitioner and its New York subsidiary SH ARE in a unitary business -- both produce ferrous scrap metal (a related line of business) and there are substantial no-charge, no-profit intercorporate servi…
After the 1984 AT&T divestiture, when New York Telephone charges long-distance carriers an 'access charge' to originate or terminate their calls, are those access-charge receipts subject to New York's Section 186-a utility gross income tax?
No. New York Telephone's access charges to long-distance carriers -- both intrastate and interstate/foreign -- are excluded from its Section 186-a tax base as sales for resale, not sales for ultimate …
Can a seller get a sales tax refund or credit for a bad-debt loss when a third-party-financed sale defaults and it repossesses the property?
No — the seller gets no sales tax refund or credit for that bad-debt loss. Heavy Duty Truck Parts sold trucks whose buyers financed through a finance company, with the seller sometimes acting as guara…
Are admission tickets to a music venue exempt as dramatic or musical arts, or taxable as a cabaret because it serves food and drink?
The admission charges are fully taxable as cabaret charges, not exempt as dramatic or musical arts admissions. Tralfamadore Cafe presents live music (Melba Moore, Kris Kristofferson, Stan Getz and oth…
Does a batting-cage operator charge sales tax on batting-practice fees, on bat/helmet rentals, and does it owe tax on the pitching machines?
Batting-practice fees are exempt, but equipment rentals are taxable and the operator owes tax on its machines. Charging customers to use pitching machines for batting practice is a charge for a partic…
A U.S. sales-agent company maintains a New York showroom-sales office exclusively for a related foreign manufacturer -- displaying/selling samples, soliciting orders that are filled entirely from the manufacturer's own out-of-state plant -- but the manufacturer keeps tight control over the office (approving its design, setting all sale terms, controlling hiring/firing). Does maintaining that showroom keep the manufacturer within P.L. 86-272's protected 'mere solicitation' safe harbor, or does it cross the line into taxable New York activity? And is the U.S. sales-agent company itself taxable for providing that agency service?
The related alien manufacturer (Hauserman, Ltd.) IS subject to New York franchise tax -- maintaining the New York showroom-sales office exceeds P.L. 86-272's protected solicitation activities, since t…
Two commonly-controlled subsidiaries of the same parent (one profitable, one running losses) plan a tax-free statutory merger mid-year -- however the merger is structured (whichever entity survives), how much of the loss-making subsidiary's current-year losses can offset the profitable subsidiary's income for that same year, and can older, prior-year net operating losses be used right away too?
Regardless of which subsidiary survives the merger, Techtran Systems' current-year (fiscal 1985) losses may offset the other subsidiary's income earned in that SAME fiscal year only in a PRORATED amou…
Are a distributor's sales of candy to schools and PTAs that resell it for fundraising exempt from sales tax?
It depends on whether title passes to the fundraising organization, and tax applies unless the distributor gets a proper certificate. Miss Chocolate Company sells confectionery to groups like schools …
Is equipment a gravel plant rents from a related corporation to assemble the plant exempt as production machinery, and is the related-party rental taxable?
Equipment used directly to assemble the plant may qualify for the production exemption, but the related-corporation rental is still taxable. Gernatt Asphalt, a gravel producer, rented welding and eart…
Is a country club's separately stated mandatory monthly gratuity charge taxable as club dues, even the portion paid to employees?
Yes — the mandatory monthly gratuity charge is taxable club dues, and the food-and-drink gratuity exclusion does not help. Park Country Club is a 'social or athletic club' because its members control …
Are hostess personal-service fees taxable when charged by an establishment that also sells beverages?
Yes — the hostess personal-service fees are taxable, along with the beverage sales. WHK Restaurant Corporation sells alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages and charges patrons a personal-service fee fo…
If a bulk-sale purchaser defaults and returns the business assets to the seller in lieu of foreclosure, is she released from liability for the seller's unpaid sales taxes?
No — returning the business assets did not cancel the sale, and the purchaser remains liable for the seller's unpaid sales and use taxes under the bulk-sale rules. Susan Jane Jankowski bought a bar an…
Is a customer's purchase order marked 'tax exempt' enough to support an exempt sale, or must the customer give the vendor a properly completed exemption certificate on the prescribed form?
A customer's purchase order marked 'tax exempt' is not a valid exemption certificate — the vendor should collect tax unless the customer furnishes a properly completed certificate on the form the Tax …
Must an out-of-state computer seller with no office, employees, salespeople, or advertising in New York collect New York sales tax on computers shipped to New York buyers?
No — as described, the out-of-state seller has no obligation to collect New York sales tax, because it neither maintains a place of business nor solicits business in New York; but its New York custome…
How is a charter fishing/hunting 'package deal' taxed — item by item — and what happens if the whole trip is billed as one flat fee?
It depends on how the bill is written: itemize, and each part is taxed under its own rule; charge one flat fee without separating the parts, and the entire fee is taxable. Outdoor Pursuits, Inc. arran…
Is the sale and installation of a wood or coal burning stove — and its chimney and masonry — a tax-exempt capital improvement to real property?
The stove itself and its installation stay taxable, but the permanent masonry work — a brick chimney, fireproofing, and concrete base — is an exempt capital improvement; a metal chimney depends on how…
May a prepared-food seller accept resale certificates instead of collecting sales tax, and credit its customers' remitted tax against its own liability?
No — there is no resale exemption for prepared food taxed under 1105(d), so accepting resale certificates was improper and the seller owes the tax it failed to collect; it cannot simply credit its cus…
My 1982 lease and companion interim lease with a tenant, both signed before the gains tax's March 28, 1983 grandfather cutoff, contain purchase options and have been amended several times since. We now want to fix a firm commencement date for the main lease and separately convert the interim lease into essentially a full net lease with the purchase option removed, plus have the tenant take over certain operating responsibilities in exchange for a lump-sum payment. Do any of these amendments cause us to lose the pre-1983 grandfather exemption, and does the lump-sum payment or the interim-lease conversion itself count as a taxable transfer?
It depends on which amendment. 52 Habitat Co., landlord of a Manhattan office building under a 1982 Net Lease and companion Interim Lease with Morgan Guaranty Trust Company (both containing purchase o…
Are the membership dues of a public beach club taxable as dues of a 'social or athletic club,' when a permanent-member board can override the elected members' committee?
Yes — the beach club is a 'social or athletic club' and its membership dues are taxable, because the members control the club's activities through an elected governing committee. The Silver Gull Club,…
Does the production exemption cover the equipment and supplies a company uses to demolish railroad bridges and cut up the resulting scrap for sale?
No — the equipment and supplies are used predominantly for demolition, which is not production, so the production exemptions do not apply and the purchases and rentals are fully taxable. Sheldon Const…
Can a company claim the resale exemption on aircraft it also used to fly its own personnel before reselling them?
No — because the company used the aircraft to transport its own personnel before reselling them, the resale exemption is lost, and both planes are taxable. John B. Pike and Son, Inc. bought a Rockwell…
Can a travel-agency cooperative's headquarters treat 'override commissions' generated by its out-of-state member agencies' bookings as non-New York receipts for franchise tax allocation purposes, on the theory that they're really royalty-like income?
No. Petitioner's override commissions are not analogous to royalty income -- they're payment for services Petitioner itself performs (negotiating commission packages for member agencies and providing …
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-88 (13)I: Issues raised are (1) whether upon the death of a nonresident, the spouse and sole beneficiary of the deceased nonresident is entitled to a stepped-up basis for an installment sale thereby eliminating any future taxable gain for purposes of the personal income tax imposed under Article 22 of the Tax Law and (2) whether interest paid to a nonresident on an installment sale is taxable for purposes of the personal income tax imposed under Article 22 of the Tax Law.
No step-up in basis for the surviving spouse: because she filed a joint return with the decedent and personally signed the section 654(c)(4) agreement, she remains personally liable for the full tax o…
East River Savings Bank's mutual-to-stock conversion was already ruled tax-free for New York franchise tax purposes -- does it also matter, for New York purposes, whether IRC section 382(b) limits the converted bank's federal net operating loss carryovers as a result of the reorganization?
No, it's immaterial for New York purposes. This is a MODIFIED Advisory Opinion -- it appends a new discussion to the original Advisory Opinion issued to East River Savings Bank on June 11, 1985, addre…
Is transferring trucks from a dissolved partnership to a corporation owned by the former partners taxable, when no stock or payment changes hands?
No — if the books document it as a genuine contribution to capital with no stock or other consideration, the transfer is not a taxable retail sale. Anacola Trucking Service, Inc. is a refuse-collectio…
Must a village collect sales tax on the sewer user charges it bills residents, when it hires a private firm to run the treatment plants?
No — the village's sewer user charges are exempt, because a municipal instrumentality is not required to collect tax on a service not ordinarily sold by private persons, and hiring a private operator …
Are a trucking company's vehicles exempt from sales/use tax as interstate commerce when its NY-to-NY trips merely pass through other states?
No — trips that begin and end in New York are intrastate even if they pass through other states, so the trucks are not used in interstate commerce and are subject to sales and use tax. S.T.L. Transpor…
For a regulated investment company whose entire New York taxable income for a year consists solely of foreign taxes withheld on foreign investments, must the investment allocation percentage be computed using ALL of the company's investment capital, or only the specific foreign investments that produced that income?
All of the company's investment capital, not just the specific foreign investments that produced its taxable income. Tax Law Section 210.3(b)(1) requires the investment allocation percentage to be com…
When a New York mutual savings bank converts to a FEDERALLY chartered stock savings bank (crossing from state to federal charter, not staying state-chartered), is the conversion still tax-free for New York bank franchise tax, and does the bank's change in regulatory charter affect its New York filing obligations?
The reorganization itself is tax-free for New York Article 32 franchise tax purposes, same as a same-charter mutual-to-stock conversion -- Article 32 has no modification addressing an IRC section 368(…
Does New York's rule requiring interest paid to a more-than-5%-stockholder to be added back to income also reach interest a corporation pays to its 'grandparent' corporation -- the parent of its direct parent?
No. Tax Law Section 208.9(b)(5) requires an add-back only for interest paid on debt owed to a stockholder owning more than 5% of the taxpayer's own capital stock, or to a subsidiary of such a stockhol…
Does New York's rule requiring interest paid to a more-than-5%-stockholder to be added back to income also reach interest a corporation pays directly to its 'grandparent' corporation -- the parent of its direct parent?
No. Commercial Credit Business Services, Inc. was a second-tier subsidiary, wholly owned by Commercial Credit Business Loans, Inc., which was itself wholly owned by Commercial Credit Company. Petition…
If a subsidiary switches from borrowing through its direct parent to borrowing directly from its 'grandparent' corporation, does New York's related-party interest add-back rule apply to the interest it now pays?
No. Commercial Credit Financial Services, Inc. was a second-tier subsidiary, wholly owned by Textile Banking Company, Inc., which was itself wholly owned by Commercial Credit Company. Since January 1,…
We're a nonprofit that runs an intermediate care facility for people with developmental disabilities, and we just recorded a mortgage to build it. Do we qualify for either of the mortgage recording tax's nonprofit exemptions -- as a 'voluntary nonprofit hospital corporation' or as a 'community mental health service company'?
No exemption on either theory. United Cerebral Palsy and Handicapped Children's Association of Chemung County, Inc. executed a $2,436,800 mortgage in December 1982 to build an intermediate care facili…
I own three contiguous residential buildings that are legally, structurally, and operationally separate (separate systems, entrances, tax lots, and registrations), and I'm selling all three to the same buyer by separate deeds. Do I have to add the sale prices together when testing against the $1 million exemption threshold for New York's Real Property Transfer Gains Tax, or does each building's price stand on its own because the buildings are legally distinct?
Aggregated -- because they were used for the same purpose. 340 West 89th Corporation owned three contiguous residential rental buildings (345, 347, and 349 West 87th Street) that were legally and phys…
Must an exempt organization that sells books through a room with a cash register and by mail collect sales tax, and can it refund tax it already collected to customers?
The organization must collect tax because it is operating a shop or store, and tax it already collected must be paid over to the State — it cannot be refunded to customers by the organization. The C.G…
Are custom-modified computer programs the vendor tailors to each customer's ATM system taxable, or exempt intangible property?
Under the rule in effect at the time, the programs are exempt intangible personal property, because the vendor must analyze each customer's requirements and modify the actual program for that customer…
We're structuring a complex sale-and-leaseback of a Manhattan property: the seller sells the land and building to a master lessor and separately sells the remainder interest in the land to another buyer, and then leases the whole thing back through a chain of a master lease, a sublease back to the seller, and a possible future ground lease -- with purchase options built in at multiple levels. Which pieces of this get taxed under the Real Property Transfer Gains Tax, and how is 'consideration' calculated for the leases themselves?
The Legislature intended the gains tax to apply to a simultaneous sale-and-leaseback only on the SALE aspect, not to tax the leaseback itself as a second full transfer. Metromedia, Inc. sold its Manha…
When a New York mutual savings bank converts to stock form as a federal tax-free 'F reorganization,' does the bank owe any New York bank franchise (Article 32) tax on the conversion itself?
No new New York franchise tax results from the conversion itself. Because the mutual-to-stock conversion qualifies federally as a tax-free 'F reorganization' under IRC section 368(a)(1)(F) -- with no …
Is the energy a shopping-mall landlord bills a tenant as 'additional rent' taxable, and is the landlord's 20% administrative markup taxable too?
Yes to both — the energy the mall bills the tenant is taxable even though the lease calls it 'additional rent,' and the landlord's 20% administrative markup is taxable as part of the receipt. The Rich…
Are the common-area maintenance charges a shopping-plaza owner bills tenants as 'additional rent' subject to sales tax?
No — common-area maintenance charges billed to tenants as 'additional rent' are receipts from the rental of real property and are not subject to sales tax. Northtown Inc. owns a shopping plaza and lea…
Is natural gas used to heat a factory's production area exempt as used 'directly and exclusively' in manufacturing, if that heat is also needed for employee comfort?
No — the gas is taxable, because heat the manufacturer would need for employee comfort anyway is not used 'exclusively' in production. MOD-PAC Corp. manufactures packing cartons by cutting, folding, g…
When a lessee exercises an option to buy leased equipment, is the 'finance charge' added at that point taxable, or is it non-taxable interest?
It is taxable — the 'finance charge' is part of the total option purchase price, not exempt interest, because the underlying deal was a lease rather than an extension of credit. L.B. Smith, Inc. sells…
Do a plant's energy-management system, machine-signaling/reporting system, and finished-goods conveyor qualify as production machinery exempt from sales tax under section 1115(a)(12)?
None of the three systems qualifies — all are taxable. Syracuse China Corporation asked whether a Markman Energy Management (MEM) System, a Datacom System, and a Rapistan Conveyor System were machiner…
Does a Computer Aided Drafting (CAD) system used to design and test custom equipment qualify for the sales-tax exemption for property used in research and development under section 1115(a)(10)?
It qualifies only if over 50% of the CAD system's use is testing whether a design meets function and reliability requirements; mere design or redesign does not qualify. Sybron Corporation's Pfaudler D…
Browse New York rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by New York's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.