Can an existing Georgia job qualify for the job tax credit only because its pay later rises above the wage threshold, and are unrelated job gains and losses in different counties treated as transfers?
Apply this to your situation
This page answers the general question as of 2024. Ask about yours and see what current Georgia tax law says, with citations.
Plain-English summary
The taxpayer operated multiple Georgia facilities and offices. After reviewing compensation, it raised salaries for some employees whose existing positions had not met the job-tax-credit wage threshold when created. It asked whether those positions could begin generating credits once their pay rose above the required minimum. It also asked how to treat separate staffing decisions: creating a job at one location while removing a similar job at a different location in another county.
The Department gave two answers:
- A later raise does not make an old position a new qualifying job. The determination is made when a new or expanded operation is first staffed. Because the positions failed the pay requirement when created, they could not generate a credit in the creation year or in a later year when their salaries finally met the threshold.
- Unrelated changes in different counties were not job transfers. The taxpayer could claim credits for jobs created at one Georgia location even though it removed similar jobs at another Georgia location, because the addition was not caused or affected by the removal.
What this means for you
Employers reviewing pay levels
Check every element of the statutory definition when a position is created. Under this ruling, raising an existing employee's salary above the minimum wage threshold later does not reset the position's creation date or make it a new full-time employee job.
Multi-location employers
Similar job gains and losses in different counties are not automatically transfers. The Department focused on whether the business decisions were connected: the jobs at Location A were treated as new because their creation was separate from, and was not caused or affected by, the removal of similar jobs at Location B.
Accountants and tax professionals
Document the year each position was created, its hours and pay at that time, its physical establishment, and the business reason for contemporaneous staffing changes elsewhere. The cited regulations define a new job at the time a new or expanded operation is first staffed and distinguish it from replacement or transferred employment.
Common questions
Q: An existing position was below the wage threshold when created but now pays enough. Can it start earning the credit?
A: No. The Department said the pay requirement must be met in the year the job is created; no cited exception allowed a later salary increase to make the old position qualify.
Q: Does Georgia Form IT-CA's use of qualified jobs change that result?
A: No. The taxpayer raised that form-based argument, but the Department applied the statutory and regulatory definition of a new full-time employee job and denied the credit for positions that failed the pay requirement when created.
Q: If we add a job in one county and remove a similar job in another, is the added job necessarily transferred?
A: No. On these facts, the decisions were separate and unrelated, and the added jobs were not caused or affected by the removals, so no transferred jobs occurred.
Q: What is a transferred job under the cited regulation?
A: It includes a job relocated by a business or related businesses from one Georgia establishment to another, or a substantially similar job created after a Georgia location ceased operations for six months or less. The regulation also contains location- and duty-specific rules reproduced in the original text below.
Q: Can another taxpayer rely on this ruling?
A: No. The ruling limits its conclusions to the requesting taxpayer's specific facts and transactions, and says changed or omitted facts, later rule or statutory changes, or judicial interpretations may change the result.
Citations and references
Statutes and regulations:
- O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40(a)(2) and § 48-7-40.1(a)(2) -- qualifying business enterprise and establishment definitions
- O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40(a)(5) and § 48-7-40.1(a)(3) -- new full-time employee job definitions
- Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(d) -- establishment
- Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(g) -- new full-time employee job and special circumstances
- Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(q) -- transferred job
- Revenue Regulation 560-7-8-.36(3)(a) -- use of the Community Affairs definitions
- Georgia Employment and Wages Averages Report of the Department of Labor -- county wage source identified by the job definitions
Source
- Landing page: Georgia Income Tax Letter Rulings
- Original PDF: LR IT-2024-01
Original ruling text
Georgia Letter Ruling:
Topic:
Date Issued:
LR IT-2024-01
Job Tax Credit
May 1, 2024
This letter is in response to your letter emailed to the Department of Revenue (the “Department”) on
Facts as Presented by the Taxpayer
Your letter to the Department states: “For more than
guidelines set forth in GA Form IT-CA, positions that newly meet the ‘qualified’ criteria due to salary adjustments would generate job tax credits. However, these positions [w]ere not created during the reporting period but have existed for many years but, instead, have attained a ‘qualified’ status based on their updated salary figures. “In summary, we seek guidance on whether a newly ‘qualified’ GA job due to salary adjustments that are not otherwise new positions can be included in the new job tax credit calculation on GA Form IT-CA. “On a similar, yet unrelated issue. We seek clarification from the Department on whether you consider unrelated staffing changes across multiple facilities (different counties) to be new jobs or merely transfer of jobs. Taxpayer has multiple locations in multiple counties and tiers throughout the state. Many times, Taxpayer will create a new job and hire a new employee(s) in a certain location (Location A) that is part of the operational plan for Location A. However, completely unrelated to Location A, they may also reduce jobs & lose an employee (same job title) in another location (Location B) because it is no longer part of the operational plan in Location B. Specific to the GA Job Tax Credits provided by [O.C.G.A.] § 48-7-40 and [O.C.G.A.] § 48-7-40.1, this scenario would appear to have a new qualified job in Location A, a loss of one job in Location B, and a net zero job count impact overall. Can you please provide guidance on whether this is a new job for Location A or essentially a job transfer to Location A?” Issue #1 Do jobs that did not constitute new full-time employee jobs under O.C.G.A. §§ 48-7-40 and 48-740.1 in prior years become new full-time employee jobs in the current year due to an increase in salary, but without any other change in job function or structure for such positions? Issue #2 Do jobs constitute new full-time employee jobs or transferred jobs under O.C.G.A. §§ 48-7-40 and 48-7-40.1 when the organization makes separate and unrelated business decisions to create jobs in one location and to remove similar jobs in another location? Authorities O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40(a)(2) provides: “Business enterprise” means any business or the headquarters of any such business which is engaged in manufacturing, including, but not limited to, the manufacturing of alternative energy products for use in solar, wind, battery, bioenergy, biofuel, and electric vehicle enterprises, warehousing and distribution, processing, telecommunications, broadcasting, tourism, research and development industries, biomedical manufacturing, and services for the elderly and persons with disabilities. Such term shall not include retail businesses.
Businesses are eligible for the tax credit provided by this Code section at an individual establishment of the business based on the classification of the individual establishment under the North American Industry Classification System. For purposes of this Code section, the term “establishment” means an economic unit at a single physical location where business is conducted or where services or industrial operations are performed. If more than one business activity is conducted at the establishment, then only those jobs engaged in the qualifying activity will be eligible for the tax credit provided by this Code section. O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40(a)(5) provides: “New full-time employee job” means a newly created position of employment that was not previously located in this state, requires a minimum of 35 hours a week, and pays at or above the average wage earned in the county with the lowest average wage earned in this state, as reported in the most recently available annual issue of the Georgia Employment and Wages Averages Report of the Department of Labor. O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40.1(a)(2) provides: “Business enterprise” means any business or the headquarters of any such business which is engaged in manufacturing, including, but not limited to, the manufacturing of alternative energy products for use in solar, wind, battery, bioenergy, biofuel, and electric vehicle enterprises, warehousing and distribution, processing, telecommunications, broadcasting, tourism, biomedical manufacturing, and research and development industries. Such term shall not include retail businesses. Businesses are eligible for the tax credit provided by this Code section at an individual establishment of the business based on the classification of the individual establishment under the North American Industry Classification System. For purposes of this Code section, the term “establishment” means an economic unit at a single physical location where business is conducted or where services or industrial operations are performed. If more than one business activity is conducted at the establishment, then only those jobs engaged in the qualifying activity will be eligible for the tax credit provided by this Code section. O.C.G.A. § 48-7-40.1(a)(3) provides: “New full-time employee job” means a newly created position of employment that was not previously located in this state, requires a minimum of 35 hours a week, and pays at or above the average wage earned in the county with the lowest average wage earned in this state, as reported in the most recently available annual issue of the Georgia Employment and Wages Averages Report of the Department of Labor. Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(d) provides:
Establishment -- means an economic unit at a single physical location where business is conducted or where services or industrial operations are performed. This is specifically where an employee's job is performed. Note that if more than one business activity is conducted at the establishment then only those jobs engaged in a qualifying activity will be eligible. For example, a retail establishment which also has a distribution activity serving the southeast will only be eligible for the jobs engaged in the qualifying distribution activity and not for any retail jobs. Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(g) provides: New Full-Time Employee Job (also "New Job") -- means a newly created position of employment by a Georgia employer, requires a minimum of 35 hours worked each week, and pays at or above the average wage earned in the county with the lowest average wage in the most recently available annual issue of the Georgia Employment and Wages Averages Report of the Department of Labor, but does not mean a job classified for federal tax purposes as an independent contractor. This determination occurs when a new or expanded operation is first staffed and does not include staff replacement or transfer. 1) Part-time jobs that become full-time jobs shall be considered new full-time employee jobs for the purposes of the Job Tax Credit Program. Part-time jobs may not be aggregated to establish full-time equivalents for the purposes of the Job Tax Credit Program. 2) Leased employees will, for the purposes of the Job Tax Credit Program, be considered employees of the company using the services of the leased employees. Leased employees and other employees may be counted toward new job totals for purposes of determining a business enterprise's job tax credit when such employees otherwise meet the definition of full-time job contained herein. Leased employees and other employees that do not meet the definition of full- time job contained herein may not be counted toward job totals. (Note that only the business enterprise using the services of leased employees may claim credit for such employees so long as the business enterprise retains control of the business location and does not delegate such control to the leasing company.) 3) Special circumstances affecting the ability for employees to count new full-time employee jobs include the following: (i) When a business purchases or leases existing assets and uses those assets for a substantially different process than their immediate prior use, the rule does not apply, and no approval is required from the commissioner of community affairs.
(ii) When a seasonal business purchases or leases existing assets, the assets must have been out of service for one year or longer unless otherwise approved by the commissioner of community affairs. (iii) Any time a business is uncertain whether or not new jobs have been created based on this paragraph, the business shall seek a ruling from the commissioner of community affairs before claiming any credits. Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01(6)(q) provides: Transferred Job -- means a job that is relocated by a business or related businesses from one Georgia establishment to another, or a job that is created by a business or related business that is substantially the same as a previously existing job of such business or related business at a location in Georgia that has ceased operations for six months or less. Because the Job Tax Credit is calculated by taxpayer, by county or census tract area, jobs that are relocated from one establishment to another within the same county or census tract area by the same taxpayer are not considered transferred jobs. If the duties of a transferred job are substantially different from those at the former location, the business may request in writing that the commissioner of community affairs determine whether or not the job is a new job for the purposes of the Job Tax Credit Program. Only after the commissioner of community affairs has determined that the job is a new job may any credits be earned. Similarly, new jobs that are transferred during years one through five from their original location to another county or less developed census tract area may not earn credits after their transfer unless otherwise approved by the commissioner of community affairs. Revenue Regulation 560-7-8-.36(3)(a) provides: Terms Defined in Community Affairs Regulation. The terms "business enterprise," "less developed area," "less developed census tract area," "new job," "average wage," "wages," "transferred job," and "replacement job," as used in this regulation are defined in Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01. Ruling Ruling on Issue #1 Based on the facts stated herein, it is the opinion of the Department that Taxpayer cannot claim the job tax credit for any taxable year for jobs that did not meet the pay requirements of a new fulltime employee job in the year of the job creation even though such pay requirements are met in a subsequent taxable year. Specifically, Taxpayer was correct to not claim the job tax credit for jobs that did not meet the pay requirements at the time of creation. Additionally, Taxpayer cannot claim
the job tax credit for these jobs that only met the pay requirements in a later taxable year following the year of the job creation. Revenue Regulation 560-7-8-.36 and Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01 require that the determination of a new full-time employee job occurs when a new or expanded operation is first staffed and does not include staff replacement or transfer. These regulations also provide exceptions to certain Georgia employer requirements and hours-worked requirements of a new full-time employee job, but no exception is provided for jobs that do not meet the pay requirements in the year of the job creation. Ruling on Issue #2 Based on the facts stated herein, it is the opinion of the Department that Taxpayer can claim the job tax credits for jobs created in a Georgia location in one county even though similar jobs are removed in a Georgia location in a different county. No “transferred jobs” 1 occurred because the addition of jobs by Taxpayer in one Georgia location was not caused or affected by the removal of jobs in another Georgia location. The opinions expressed in this ruling are based upon the information contained in your request and limited to the specific transactions, facts, circumstances, and taxpayer in question. The facts herein are those presented by the taxpayer and the Department accepts them as true for this ruling. If the facts presented herein change, are not true, are different, or material facts have been omitted, the conclusions reached in this ruling may change. In addition, subsequent statutory or administrative rule changes or judicial interpretations of the statutes or rules upon which this advice is based may subject similar future transactions to a different tax treatment than that expressed in this ruling.
1
See Revenue Regulation 560-7-8-.36 and Community Affairs Regulation 110-9-1-.01
What does the law say today, for your facts?
This ruling is from 2024. Ezel checks current Georgia tax law against your situation and cites the authority it relies on.
Try Ezel Pro free for 7 days. Cancel anytime before the trial ends and you pay nothing.
- Checks the law as it stands today, not only this page
- Cites every source it relies on, so you can verify it
- Chat, drafting and research in one workspace