Did short-term notes escape Georgia IRT when they were included in long-term security instruments, and was the borrower entitled to refunds of the related tax, penalty, and interest?

Short answer No. Georgia upheld all base IRT and penalties because the short-term notes were incorporated into long-term security instruments. It approved only a partial interest refund for two notes whose accrual periods had been overstated, upheld interest on the third, and found separate tax, penalty, and interest due on an untaxed letter-of-credit deed.
State
GA
Ruling
IRT 2012-09-06-01
Tax type
Intangible Recording Tax
Issued
2012-09-06
Issued by
Georgia Department of Revenue
Requested by
A borrower, through counsel, challenging tax, penalty, and interest on several notes and security instruments (identity redacted by the Department)

Apply this to your situation

This page answers the general question as of 2012. Ask about yours and see what current Georgia tax law says, with citations.

Currency note: this ruling is from 2012
Subsequent statutory amendments, regulation changes, court decisions, or later rulings may have changed the analysis. Treat this page as historical context, not current tax advice. Verify current law before relying on any specific rule, rate, or position mentioned here.
Disclaimer: This official Georgia document decides one taxpayer's protest involving several instruments, tax years, and redacted amounts. Its tax, penalty, interest, and letter-of-credit findings depend on that record and 2012 law; do not use the partial refund as a calculation for another taxpayer. This summary is informational only and is not legal or tax advice.
About this page: The plain-English summary, reader guidance, and Q&A below were written by Ezel based on the official state tax ruling. The original ruling (linked on this page as an official web page) is the authoritative source for any reliance.
View original ruling (official page)

Plain-English summary

Georgia upheld all base IRT and penalties on three note-related payments but approved a partial refund of overpaid interest for two notes.

The 2004, 2007, and 2011 instruments each added a nominally short-term note to a long-term security instrument. Georgia applied its mixed-term-note and additional-advance rules: when an instrument secures long- and short-term notes together, tax is due on their combined amounts up to the single-instrument maximum. The Department therefore denied the requested tax refund and full penalty waiver.

Interest was different. For Note A, Georgia ended accrual when a later recorded amendment stated the note had been paid in full, rather than continuing through the 2012 payment date. It also shortened the interest period for Note C. Those corrections produced a partial interest refund. The interest assessed on Note D was upheld.

The Department separately found that a 2005 long-term deed securing a letter-of-credit and reimbursement agreement had never been taxed. It directed payment of tax, penalty, and interest on that instrument and said none of that separate amount could be refunded.

What this means for you

Calling an added note “short-term” does not avoid IRT when the same instrument also secures long-term debt. Review each recording in the chain, but calculate interest by the correct period for each note—an otherwise valid assessment can still contain an interest-period overcharge.

Common questions

Q: Were the three base-tax assessments refunded?
A: No. Georgia found all three correctly imposed.

Q: Were the penalties waived?
A: No. The Department denied the full penalty-waiver request.

Q: Why was some interest refunded?
A: The assessed periods for Notes A and C extended beyond the periods Georgia found applicable.

Q: What happened with the separate letter-of-credit deed? A: Georgia found tax, penalty, and interest still due because no IRT had been paid when that long-term deed was recorded.

Citations and references

  • O.C.G.A. §§ 48-2-40, 48-2-42, 48-6-60, 48-6-61, 48-6-76, and 48-6-77
  • Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. rr. 560-11-8-.06, 560-11-8-.12, and 560-11-8-.13
  • Bankers Trust Co. v. Jackson, 1999 Ga. App. LEXIS 212
  • 1954-56 Op. Att'y Gen. p. 772
  • 1960-61 Op. Att'y Gen. p. 519
  • 1984 Op. Att'y Gen. No. 84-17

Source

Original ruling text

Douglas J. MacHinnitie Department of Revenue Frank M. O'Connell

Commissioner

Director
Administrative Division — Office of Tax Policy

1800 Century Blvd., Suite 15311
Atlanta, Georgia 30345-3205
(404) 417-6649

September 6, 2012

Re: An Intangible Recording Tax Protest and Claim for Refund per O.C.G.A. § 48-6-76(c) in the amount of paid upon recording an “Affidavit Regarding Payment of

Georgia Intangible Recording Tax” with the Clerk of Superior Court, on April 13, 2012. Parties are (Borrower) and (Lender)

I have carefully considered your Protest and Claim fot Refund of intangible recording tax,

penalty, and interest per O.C.G.A. § 48-6-76(c) pursuant to the above-captioned matter. Your Protest and Claim for Refund, and all correspondence with accompanying enclosures were considered in the review. This letter ruling contains the Department’s decision with respect to each aspect of the Protest and Claim for Refund.

It is followed by “Additional Findings of Fact” that relate to the overall issues presented.

In brief, intangible recording tax is an excise tax. It is not an ad valorem tax. It is “paid for the privilege of filing a document to protect the note secured by the recording of the security instrument, and the fact that it is based on the value of the property is only ancillary.” Bankers Trust Co. v. Jackson, Ga. App., 1999 Ga. App. LEXIS 212, S.E.2d (1999),

  • O.C.G.A.. § 48-6-60 contains definitions for a “collecting officer,” a “security instrument,” a

“Long-term note secured by real estate,” and a “Short-term note secured by real estate,” respectively. O.C.G.A. § 48-6-61 provides: that security instruments must be filed and the intangible recording tax paid no later than ninety days from the date of execution by the parties. The tax is imposed on each instrument at a rate of $1.50 per $500.00 or fraction thereof of the face amount of the note secured by the instrument.

An Equal Opportunity Employer

O

Page Two

O.C.G.A. § 48-6-76 concerns the procedure for filing a Protest of intangible recording tax. In brief, the Protest must be filed contemporaneous with recording of the instrument and payment of the tax (and penalty and interest, if applicable). It cannot be filed ex post.

O.C.G.A. § 48-6-77 is titled, Failure to pay intangible recording tax bars action on indebtedness;

removal of bar: penalty; conditions under which penalty waived: acquisition of instrument by holder exempt from tax.

O.C.G.A. § 48-2-40. Rate of interest on past due taxes. “Except as otherwise expressly provided by law, taxes owed the state or any local taxing jurisdiction shall bear interest at the rate of 1

percent per month from the date the tax is due until the date the tax is paid. For the purposes of this Code section, any period of less than one month shall be considered to be one month... . ”

O.C.G.A. § 48-2-42 is titled, Nature of penalties. “All penalties imposed by law are part of the tax... . The proceedings to collect the original tax, the tax constituted from penalties imposed,

and the interest shall all be conducted in the same manner.”

An “Opinion of the Attorney General” holds, “When any of debt is repayable more than three years from date, it is all long-term and subject to the rates applicable thereto.” 1960-61 Op.

Att’y Gen. p. 519.

The entire class of intangible recording tax regulations were legally promulgated and became effective on July 7, 1996. Since that date they have never been changed or amended in any way.

A brief list of relevant regulations may prove instructive.

Rev. Reg. 560-11-8-.06 — Additional Advance, provides in pertinent part that in the case of a new note or a modification of a preexisting note, representing an additional extension of credit to be secured by a previously recorded instrument which otherwise requires no further recording, the intangible recording tax is determined according to the terms of the new note. This regulation contemplates that in the case of future advances, the collecting official will collect any additional

tax due based upon the increased indebtedness.

Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 560-11-8-.12 Instrument Securing Short-Term and Long-Term Notes, states: “Where a single instrument secures both long-term and short-term notes, intangible © recording tax is due on the sum of the amounts of both the long-term and short-term notes, up to

the maximum tax allowed per instrument.”

Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 560-11-8-.13 Secured Lines of Credit, provides that intangible recording tax is due and payable on an instrument that secures a long-term revolving line of credit secured by real estate, line of credit, or equity line of credit. It is based upon the total amount of the line of credit whether advanced or not. The $25,000 maximum amount of intangible recording tax will apply with respect to the total amount of credit contemplated... . No additional tax will due on subsequent advances as long as the principal outstanding at any one time does not exceed the maximum amount permitted to be outstanding as determined from

the face of the instrument.

Page Three

This Protest and Claim for Refund concerns three separate payments of intangible recording tax, penalty and interest. They will be referred to hereinafter as the “2004 payment,” the “2007 payment,” and the “2011 payment.” A brief summation concerning each follows below.

2004 payment

The Clerk of Superior Court imposed a total of MMB on the “2004 payment.” This security instrument combined (what will be hereinafter referred to as) Note A [a short-term note executed in 2002 but never recorded; when it was added to a 2004 instrument securing Note B, which was

' long-term and for which intangible tax was paid (recorded on F ebruary 4, 2004; maturity date of
_ January 1, 2009), a “Note to the Clerk” on the face of the instrument stated that no tax was due

on Note A because it was a short-term note] and Note B. The amount of Note A was It thus remained unsecured from its Date of Execution until April 13, 2012, a.k.a. the date the tax was paid.

The Clerk assessed _the following amounts on Note A: Tax
Penalt Interest ;
2007 payment

The Clerk of Superior Court imposed a total of QB on the “2007 payment.” A “First Amendment to a Georgia Security Deed and Security Agreement” was recorded on F ebruary 17, 2009. Repeating the pattern described above, this document encompassed Note A, Note B, and (what will be hereinafter referred to as) Note C, a short-term note in the amount of

with a Date of Execution of March 28, 2007. Given that no tax was ever paid as part of its inclusion in the First Amendment, Note C thus remained unsecured from its Date of Execution

until April 13, 2012, a.k.a. the date the tax was paid.

The Clerk _assessed_the following amounts on Note C: Tax
Penalt Interest- QD ;

2011 payment

The Clerk of Superior Court imposed a total of GD on the “2011 payment.” A “Second Amendment” to the above long-term Security Deed, with a Date of Execution of October 20, 2011, was recorded on November 16, 2011. Repeating the pattern described above, it advances

principal to the Borrower via (what will be hereinafter referred to as) Note D in the amount of aE A “Note to the Clerk” on the face of the instrument states that because Note D is a

short-term note, that no intangible recording tax is due. _

It is also relevant that on page 2, the Security Deed states that Note A [upon which no tax had

ever been paid up to this time, November 16, 2011] in the [original] amount fa had been paid in full. |

The Clerk_assessed_these amounts on the 2011 payment: Tax- QD Penalt Interest- aD

an Equal Opportunity Employer

f

\

O

Page Four

With respect to the instant protest and claim for refund, counsel for claimant is requesting: .

  • Arefund of @BBin intangible recording tax paid.

— A full nia Waiver (of all penalties paid totaling a.

— A refund of in accrued interest.

Findings of Fact

Intangible Recording Tax

Based upon statutory law and Department Regulations, all amounts of the base of intangible recording tax assessed by the Clerk of Superior Court, QB conceming each of the three separate payments described above were correctly imposed. Each of the documents recorded in 2004, 2007, and 2011 meets the definition of a security instrument under the Code. As provided by 560-11-8-.06 Additional Advance, in the case of a new note or a modification of a preexisting note, representing an additional extension of credit. . . intangible recording tax is determined according to the terms of the new note. In the case of future advances the collecting official should collect any additional tax due based upon the increased indebtedness.

A review of the recordings at issue reveals that each one asserts via a “Note to the Clerk” on the face page that no additional tax is due because the new note being secured is short-term and therefore not subject to tax. Based upon Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 560-11-8-.12 Instrument Securing Short-Term and Long-Term Notes, as well as a corresponding “Opinion of the Attorney General” as cited on page 2, intangible taxes were legally due. .

Therefore, it is my finding that claimant’s request for a refund of GD in intangible tax is denied. The amount may not be refunded.

Penalty

Based upon the finding immediately above concerning intangible tax, all amounts of Penalty were imposed correctly according to statute by the Clerk of Superior Court, GD

Therefore, it is my finding that claimant’s request for a full Penalty Waiver representing in penalties is denied. The amount may not be refunded.

Interest

The 2004 payment

When the “Second Amendment to Georgia Security Deed and Security Agreement” (the final

document in the chain of recordings at issue) was recorded on November 16, 2011 [Deed Book

987, Pages 1-10], page 2, paragraph 3 of the instrument states: “The term loan by Lender to evidenced by that certain Promissory Note dated September 3, 2002, made by

to the order of Lender in the original principal amount OB has been paid in

fullf.]”

O

Page Five

Although no tax was paid on Note “A” at the time of recording on February 4, 2004, it became subject to collection of intangible tax due to its being incorporated into a long-term security instrument. Note “A” thus became subject to payment of penalty and interest on the 91* day

from the date of recording: May 5, 2004.

Therefore, based upon the date range of May 5, 2004, until November 16, 2011, when the Second Amendment was legally recorded and states Note “A” had been paid in full, it is my finding that collection of interest due on Note “A” should terminate as of November 16, 2011-a total of 91 months from the 91" day from the date of recording. (And not through April 13, 2012, the date that the tax was paid and the Protest filed.) Using 91 months as the applicable

aD th for calculation of interest (@1% per month per the base of the tax, or

, the result is Total Interest Due off This is QED less than the amount assessed.

The 2007 payment

Interest assessed upon Note “C”, a short-term note in the amount of QB should be treated precisely as Note “A” above because the essential facts and circumstances mirror each

other.

Note “C” was executed on March 28, 2007. The maturity date was March 20, 2008. It remained unsecured even after Note “C” was appended to the “First Amendment to Georgia Security Deed and Security Agreement,” recorded on February 17, 2009, because no tax was ever paid on Note “C”. It remained unsecured until April 13, 2012, the date that the tax was paid and the Protest

filed. The amount of Interest assessed was

Note “C” became subject to payment of penalty and interest, however, on the 91% day from the date of recording: May 19, 2009. Therefore, based upon the date range of May 19, 2009, through April 13, 2012, a total of 35 months represents the applicable period/timeframe for calculation of interest (@1% per month per the base of the tax, or . The result is Total Interest Due et] This is GHD tess than the amount assessed.

The 2011 payment

Contrary to counsel’s statement on page 5 of his letter dated April 13, 2012, interest in the amount (fam was correctly calculated and imposed on Note “D” (the 2011 payment), a short-term note upon which no tax was paid at the time of recording.

Summation of Interest Portion

Based upon an overpayment of interest for Note “A” totaling and an overpayment of interest for Note “C” toting aa it is my finding that a total o in-interest was overpaid with respect to those two notes.

Accordingly, counsel for claimant’s request for a refund of interest totaling GD is approved — plus an additional im oo

An Equal Opportunity Employer

_.(“Bank”)[.] The value of the

Page Six

Conclusion

The Clerk of Superior Court, QD is directed to refund to claimant a total _

from the special escrow account into which the protested amount {a was placed according to statute.

The Clerk of Superior Court, is also hereby authorized to remove the remaining protested amount of from the special escrow account and distribute it according to

Georgia law.

Additional Findings of Fact

Based upon documents provided upon request from the Clerk of Superior Court,

it is also relevant to the instant matter that a long-term Deed to Secure Debt was recorded in Georgia on December 29, 2005. The Date of Execution is December 1. 2005. As |

stated on page 4 of the Deed, the Maturity Date is December 1, 2022. The Deed secures a

“Letter_of Credit and Reimbursement Agreement” in the maximum principal amount_of

Its Date of Execution is December 1, 2005. The Deed lists

as “Borrower” with

captioned as °

“Owner”, and

page of the Letter of Credit documents a:
These “Opinion{s] of the Attorney General” may prove instructive:

Whether instrument is bond or long-term note is a fact question. — Determination of whether an instrument is a bond or a long-term loan secured by real estate for purposes of determining which intangibles tax provisions shall apply is a fact question. 1954-56 Op. Att’y Gen. p. 772.

Tax held applicable. — Intangible recording tax imposed by O.C.G.A. § 48-6-61 is applicable to a long-term note secured by real estate held by a lender who was enabled to make the loan through the deposit of the proceeds of revenue bonds issued by a local housing authority and which deposit was conditioned upon the lender making the loan. 1984 Op. Att’y Gen. No. 84-17.

Although no tax was ever paid upon this recording, it is my determination that Intangible Tax based upon the stated Letter of Credit amount of remains due. Consequently, intangible tax o is due and payable to the Clerk of Superior Court,

Additionally, applicable Penalty based upon the statutory rate is also due in the amount o

With respect to Interest (@ 1% per month), using the Date of Recording of December 29, 2005, as the starting point, the 91° day from that date is March 30. 2006. Therefore, Interest that remains due and payable in the amount o is predicated upon a 78-month timeframe, or March 30, 2006, through no later than September 30, 2012 (a.k.a. the “date the tax [will have

been] paid”).

O

Page Seven

Thus, the corresponding amounts due and payable (CD «ith respect to the Letter of Credit are as follows:

Tax

Penalty Interest. TOTAL AMOUNT DUE ie

No part of the total amount due may be refunded.

Conclusion

Payment of should be remitted in full by the claimant to the Clerk of Superior Court, no later than September 30, 2012. Should any part of that amount fail to be paid,

then interest will continue to accrue at the statutory rate.

As the “collecting officer” under the Code, the Clerk of Superior Court, QE is hereby directed to process that payment expeditiously and distribute it according to Georgia law.

Sincerely, —

-/ Prank O’Connell
FOC/RJL/me

cc: Clerk of Superior Court,
Clerk of Superior Court,

An Equal ®pportunity Enployer

What does the law say today, for your facts?

This ruling is from 2012. Ezel checks current Georgia tax law against your situation and cites the authority it relies on.

Try Ezel Pro free for 7 days. Cancel anytime before the trial ends and you pay nothing.

  • Checks the law as it stands today, not only this page
  • Cites every source it relies on, so you can verify it
  • Chat, drafting and research in one workspace