What did Georgia decide when successive modifications converted a short-term loan to long-term debt, added principal without full tax collection, and the borrower requested a refund and penalty waiver?
Apply this to your situation
This page answers the general question as of 2010. Ask about yours and see what current Georgia tax law says, with citations.
Plain-English summary
Georgia denied the refund and required additional IRT and interest, but granted the requested penalty waiver because the clerk had failed to collect the required tax at recording.
The original 2003 instrument secured a short-term note. Modification #4, executed August 1, 2007, set a September 1, 2017 maturity date. That more-than-ten-year term converted the debt to a long-term note, but the clerk did not collect IRT. Modification #5, executed April 25 and recorded June 5, 2008, advanced additional long-term principal without collection of all additional tax. Modification #6 was recorded under protest in July 2009.
Georgia found tax deficiencies for the 2007 and 2008 instruments. It allowed the tax paid under protest to be applied toward the base deficiency, required the remaining tax and interest, and said the foreclosure bar would lift after payment. The Department waived the statutory penalties because the clerk had failed to collect the tax properly when the earlier instruments were recorded.
What this means for you
Review the entire modification chain. A maturity extension can convert short-term debt to long-term debt, and later advances can add tax. A clerk's collection error may affect penalty relief, but it does not erase the underlying tax or interest.
Common questions
Q: What converted the original short-term debt to long-term? A: Modification #4 extended maturity to September 1, 2017, more than ten years after its execution date.
Q: Did a later modification add principal?
A: Yes. Modification #5 advanced additional long-term debt.
Q: Was the refund granted?
A: No. Georgia found additional tax and interest due.
Q: Why were penalties waived?
A: The Department attributed the earlier noncollection of required tax to the county clerk.
Citations and references
- O.C.G.A. §§ 48-2-40, 48-2-42, 48-6-60, 48-6-61, 48-6-76(c), and 48-6-77
- Ga. Comp. R. & Regs. r. 560-11-8-.14(b)
- Bankers Trust Co. v. Jackson, 1999 Ga. App. LEXIS 212
Source
- IRT/RETT search page: https://dor.georgia.gov/search-irt-rett-letter-rulings
- Topic page: https://dor.georgia.gov/modification-agreement
- Original PDF: https://dor.georgia.gov/document/publication/georgia-letter-ruling-no-irt-2010-05-26-01-modification-agreementpdf/download
Original ruling text
é | State of Georgia
Frank MM, ©’ Connell
CO Bart L. Graham DQ ep artment of Revenue Director
Conmnissioner
Ayministratibe Division — Tax Law & Policy
Suite 15311
- 1800 Century lbp.
Atlanta, Georgia 30345-3205
(404) 417-6649
May 26, 2010
Tax Protest and Claim for Refund per O.C.G.A. § 48-6-76(c) in the aid upon recording a Modification Agreement with the Clerk of
on July 15, 2009. Parties are
Re: Intangible Recordin
amount of |
Superior Court, |
Grantee
I have carefully considered your Protest and Claim for Refund of intangible recording tax per 0.C.G.A. § 48-6-76(c) pursuant to the above-captioned matter. Your Protest and Claim for Refund, and all correspondence with accompany enclosures were considered in the review. It is
my determination that your Claim for Refund in the amount of ma is denied. The amount may notberefunded. _—— 7
~ Jalso find that an additional, in intangible recording tax is due and payable plus payment of interest totaling .
In brief, intangible recording tax is an excise tax. It is not an ad valorem tax. It is “paid for the privilege of filing a document to protect,the note secured by the recording of the security
"instrument, and the fact that it is based on the value of the property is only ancillary.” Bankers Trust Co. v. Jackson, Ga. App., 1999 Ga. App. LEXIS 212, S.E.2d (1999).
ra “collecting officer,” a “security instrument,” a
and a “Short-term note secured by real estate.”
art that security instruments must be filed and the
y days from the date of execution by the parties.
0.C.G.A. § 48-6-60 contains definitions fo
“Long-term note secured by real estate,”
0.C.G.A. § 48-6-61 provides in pertinent p
intangible recording tax paid no later than ninet
~~~ Ga, Comp. R. & Regs. r, 560-11-8-.14 Exemptions, at (b), provides in pertinent part that a
An Equal @pportunity Enploper-
Zen, Page Two .
ect to payment of intangible recording tax: (b) “Where any of the
security instrument is not subj
a federal credit union, a state of Georgia chartered credit union, or
following is Grantee [lender]:
a church.” .
Inthe instant matter, the original recording between the parties with }
erconnvurrmmt Borrower-Grantor, constituted a short-term note secured ‘by real estate. It
was recorded on January 8, 2003, and evidenced a principal loan amount ae The
parties executed six subsequent “Modification Agreements” although there is no record that the
- first one was ever officially recorded by the Clerk of Superior Court, fF
‘Modification Agreement #4 between the parties was recorded on September 21, 2007. It set
Maturity Date of September 1, 2017, and a
forth a Date of Execution of August 1, 2007, a
— The stated Maturity Date of more than ten years from; the
_ principal loan amount of,
Date of Execution transformed what had been a short-term note secured by real estate into a
ble recording tax was due and payable
long-term note secured by real estate. Accordin ly, intangi
However, the Clerk of Superior Court,
on the security instrument in the amount of
: failed to-collect the tax due upon recording. Therefore, as of October 31, 2007,
e “minety-nrst day” from the Date of Execution, a Bar to Foreclosure was automatically |
- imposed on the instrument ‘n conformance with O.C.G.A. § 48-6-77. In addition to the tax, a
() penalty of 50 percent was thereupon due with interest at the rate of one percent (1%) per month
due and payable until all tax due is paid.
“All penalties imposed by law are part of the tax and are to. be
to colléct the original tax, the tax constituted from penalties
33
O.C.G.A. § 48-2-42 provides that
collected as such. The proceedings
imposed, and the interest shall all be conducted in the same manner....
Modification Agreement #5 between the parties advanced an additional in long-term
- Its Date of Execution was April 25, 2008.
indebtedness when it was recorded on June 5, 2
However, the Clerk of Superior Court, ae: failed to realize that there was an
existing “tax deficiency” on record plus the tact that a ditional intangible recording tax was due
based upon this instrument. Because additional tax in the amount of was not paid by the
. ninety-first day, July 25, 2008, from the Date of Execution, a 50 percent penalty thereupon
became due with interest at the rate of one percent (1%) per month due and payable until all tax
dueispaid.. ,
der Protest on |
The Clerk of
which
The final document, Modification #6, which was also long-term, was recorded un
July 15, 2009. It set forth a stated amount of long-term principal of
Superior Court, carrera ill intangible recording tax due totaling,
is thus the subject of the Instaht matter.
Based upon a careful review of all facts and documents submitted, because
7 is the Borrower-Grantor with respect: to what became a long-term security
instrument subject to tax, your Protest must necessarily be denied. .
An Equal @pportunity Eniploper
_
O
“y
v
Page = i
Because there exists a Bar to Foreclosure dating back to the recording of September 21, 2007,
which has-not yet been remedied by payment of all tax, penalty and interest, plus recordation of a
subsequent Modification Agreement on June 5, 2008,.which also added to the long-term
indebtedness on record, with added penalty and interest still outstanding for that instrument, my
findings with respect to this. entire matter are as follows:
- 1) There is a deficit. in the intangible recording tax in ‘the amount of; with
~ to the long-term instrument recorded on September 21, 2007, at
2) There is a deficit in the intangible recording tax in the amount of with respect
to the Modification Agreement recorded on June 5, 2008, at
under protest may
Therefore,
3) The amount of ae in intangible recording tax that was pg)
be applied toward the base amount of the delinquent tax due which totals.
additional intangible tax of aps! be paid to the Clerk of Superior Court,|
4) Penalty at the rate specified in O.C.G.A. § 48-6-77 totaling J ae: due on
Modification #4 and Modification #5 described above;
_ payment of ap accordance with the statute.
5) Interest at the rate specified in O.C. GA. § 48-2-40 totaling a : due ‘on
Modification #4 and Modification #5 as described above. ce
Based upon the failure of the Clerk of Superior Court, to properly collect all ;
intangible recording tax due upon the recording of what had become a long-term instrument on
"September 21, 2007, plus additional intangible recording tax due upon recording of a
Modification Agreement recorded on June 5, 2008, the request for a Penalty Waiver by claimant
is hereby granted.
Upon payment of the amount still due and owing of in intangible recording tax, plus
payment of interest totaling | Bar to Foreclosure upon the instrument will be lifted.
A copy of this decision is being provided to the Clerk of Superior Court, Camden County so that
the instructions herein-may be processed expeditiously. The Clerk is instructed to distribute the
protested amount, along with the additional intangible recording tax and the interest
Sincerely,
. Keak
Phaelt H O’Connell
cc: Clerk of Superior Cour,
An Equal Opportunity Employer
What does the law say today, for your facts?
This ruling is from 2010. Ezel checks current Georgia tax law against your situation and cites the authority it relies on.
Try Ezel Pro free for 7 days. Cancel anytime before the trial ends and you pay nothing.
- Checks the law as it stands today, not only this page
- Cites every source it relies on, so you can verify it
- Chat, drafting and research in one workspace