Thad J. Collins

How Judge Collins rules, drawn from 17 signed orders. Every observation links to the order it came from.

Court
U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Iowa
Position
bankruptcy
Appointed by
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
Commissioned
2010-03-29
Education
Macalester College, B.A., 1986; University of Iowa, J.D. with distinction, 1990
Signed orders read
17

How Judge Collins decides

Patterns drawn from this judge's own signed orders. Every observation links to the order it came from.

What persuades

Compensation requests are stronger when billing entries identify the task, its purpose, and the benefit produced for the estate.

“Kennelly & O’Keeffe’s billing entries lack specificity throughout, not just with regard to communications.”

Procedural preferences

The court may resolve a Chapter 11 conversion request before confirmation when delay would consume estate value without a realistic path to reorganization.

“waiting until the case has conclusively foundered on the shoals of confirmation is often expensive and inefficient in the extreme”

Signed rulings

A grounded sample of orders signed by this judge, with the verbatim dispositive language.

In re Keeley and Grabanski Land Partnership
10-31482 · 2016-03-31
Interim application for compensation (G. Donald Haslam) Granted in part

“WHEREFORE, Haslam’s Interim Application for Compensation is GRANTED IN PART. Haslam is awarded $12,150 in fees and $144 in costs.”

Kaler v. Slominski (In re Keeley and Grabanski Land Partnership)
11-07021 (10-31482) · 2013-10-07
Motion for directed verdict (Chapter 7 trustee) Moot / procedural

“The conclusions reached above render this motion moot.”

Motion to reopen case in chief (Louie Slominski) Moot / procedural

“This motion is therefore moot.”

In re Keeley and Grabanski Land Partnership
10-31482 · 2013-05-30
Application to employ attorney (Keeley and Grabanski Land Partnership) Denied

“Debtor=s Application for Approval of Employment of Attorney is denied.”

In re Keeley and Grabanski Land Partnership
10-31482 · 2013-05-30
Objection to claim (Chapter 7 trustee as to G&K Farms claim #12) Granted

“The Court therefore concludes that the Trustee=s objection to the proof of claim of G&K Farms is SUSTAINED.”

Objection to claim (Chapter 7 trustee as to Merlyn and Dolores Grabanski claim #13) Granted

“The Trustee=s objection to the proof of claim of Merlyn and Dolores Grabanski is also SUSTAINED.”

In re Thomas M. Grabanski and Mari K. Grabanski
10-30902 · 2013-04-19
Final application for compensation (DeWayne Johnston) Granted in part

“Attorney Johnston’s Application for Additional Final Compensation is denied with prejudice with the exception of the $3,000 the Court has exercised its discretion to award.”

Objection to compensation (PHI Financial Services, Inc.) Granted in part
Objection to compensation (Hanson-Tallackson parties) Granted in part
Objection to compensation (United States Trustee) Granted in part
In re Thomas M. Grabanski and Mari K. Grabanski
10-30902 · 2013-04-19

This posting is an exact duplicate of the separately cached final-compensation decision.

In re Thomas M. Grabanski and Mari K. Grabanski
10-30902 · 2013-04-19
Motion for relief and sanctions for stay violation (Thomas M. Grabanski and Mari K. Grabanski) Moot / procedural

“Debtors’ Motion for Relief and Sanctions Pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 362(k) is MOOT, and is DENIED to the extent it seeks injunctive relief on their request for attorney’s fees and costs.”

In re Thomas M. Grabanski and Mari K. Grabanski
10-30902 · 2013-04-12
Motions to dismiss (PHI Financial Services, Inc.) Granted

“Based on the foregoing, the Court GRANTS the Motions to Dismiss the case with prejudice.”

Motions to dismiss (United States Trustee) Granted
In re Municipal Corrections, LLC
12-12253 · 2012-12-28
Motion to transfer venue (Irwin County) Granted

“IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Debtor’s Chapter 11 case shall be transferred to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Georgia.”

Ojima Oji, LLC v. Grisley
10-01428 and 11-01132 (10-22371) · 2012-10-24
Objection to discharge (Ojima Oji, LLC and TSG-XII, LLC) Denied

“For the reasons discussed above, the Court overrules Plaintiffs’ objection to discharge under § 727(a)(4)(A).”

PW Enterprises, Inc. v. State of North Dakota (In re Racing Services, Inc.)
06-07020 (04-30236) · 2012-10-19
Preference avoidance claim (PW Enterprises, Inc.) Denied

“For the foregoing reasons, PWE’s Complaint is DISMISSED.”

Fraudulent transfer avoidance claim (PW Enterprises, Inc.) Denied
Equitable subordination claim (PW Enterprises, Inc.) Denied
Waugh Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Daecharkhom
11-01152 (11-13396) · 2012-10-04
Nondischargeability complaint (Waugh Real Estate Holdings, LLC) Denied

“WHEREFORE, judgment is entered in Defendant/Debtor’s favor.”

Draft for Judge Collins with the record in hand

Ezel grounds your drafting and research in this profile: what has persuaded Judge Collins, and what has not, cited to the signed orders.

Opens in Ezel Pro.

  • Grounded in Judge Collins's own signed orders
  • Cites every source it relies on, so you can verify it
  • Chat, drafting and research in one workspace