Arnold Wilson Cowen

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit circuit Retired 2007 · served 1982–2007 Appointed by Lyndon B. Johnson (Democratic) 25 signed orders read

Judge Cowen no longer hears cases. This profile is preserved as a historical record of how they ruled.

How Judge Cowen decides

Patterns drawn from this judge's own signed orders. Every observation links to the order it came from.

What persuades

In contract interpretation, he relied on the parties’ demonstrated pre-dispute understanding of performance.

“allowance of the contractor’s claim would require us to ignore the clearly demonstrated intent of both parties.”

He tested substantial evidence against the whole record, including contrary evidence.

“We “cannot conscientiously find that the evidence supporting [the board’s] decision is substantial, when viewed in the light that the record in its entirety furnishes, including the body of evidence opposed to the Board’s view.””

Cautions

He separated sympathetic presentation from the legal showing needed to overturn denial of veterans benefits.

“Although he has pleaded his case eloquently, Mr. Talon has not established that the denial of his application for a pension violated his constitutional rights, or that the decision below should be reversed on any other ground.”

Signed rulings

A grounded sample of orders signed by this judge, with the verbatim dispositive language.

John T. Brady & Company v. The United States
· 1982-11-18
Appeal (United States) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Donna Carroll v. Department of Health and Human Services
· 1983-04-04
Petition for review (Donna Carroll) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Jesus M. Ceja v. United States
· 1983-06-27
Petition for review (Jesus M. Ceja) Granted

“REVERSED AND REMANDED.”

Norman A. Foster and Charles T. Heimerdinger v. United States, Ronald R. Olson v. United States
· 1984-04-23
Appeal (Norman A. Foster, Charles T. Heimerdinger, and Ronald R. Olson) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Sister Mary K. Samson v. United States
· 1984-09-12
Appeal (Sister Mary K. Samson) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Loftin v. United States
· 1985-06-28
Appeal (William P. Loftin Sr.) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Joseph A. Antal v. Merit Systems Protection Board
· 1985-10-17
Petition for review (Joseph A. Antal) Granted

“REVERSED AND REMANDED.”

American Federation of Government Employees v. United States
· 1986-01-02
Appeal (American Federation of Government Employees and associated plaintiffs) Denied

“AFFIRMED”

Branning v. United States
· 1986-02-14
Appeal (United States) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Broomall Industries, Inc. v. Data Design Logic Systems, Inc.
· 1986-03-17
Appeal (Broomall Industries, Inc.) Granted

“VACATED AND REMANDED.”

Lacy M. Henry D/B/A Qualified Personnel, and Qualified Maintenance and Construction Personnel, Inc. v. United States
· 1986-06-06
Appeal (Lacy M. Henry and the Qualified Personnel businesses) Denied

“AFFIRMED.”

Michael Crivelli v. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration
· 1986-06-18
Petition for review (Michael Crivelli and Stuart Morse) Granted in part

“AFFIRMED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED.”

Caseload & timing

From public federal docket records for this judge.

Not applicable to this circuit-court record.

A historical record

Judge Cowen no longer hears cases. This profile stays available as a record of how they ruled. If you're preparing for a matter, start from the court's current bench.