CCA 1040007: Foreign tax credits for shareholder-level withholding taxes

Plain-English summary

Chief Counsel Advice addressed foreign tax credits when a foreign corporation pays a dividend to a domestic corporate shareholder that owns at least 10 percent. Corporate-level foreign taxes that are the subsidiary's legal liability may be treated as paid by the shareholder under IRC § 902. A withholding tax on the dividend is instead the shareholder's legal liability and may qualify for a direct credit under IRC § 901, but it is not included in the subsidiary's section 902 tax pool. If the subsidiary pays that shareholder-level tax instead of withholding it, the payment may be treated as additional dividend income and as a tax paid by the shareholder. The advice also explains that the result may depend on whether an amount retained by the subsidiary is credited as a gross or net capital contribution.

Ruling snapshot

• Question: How are foreign taxes treated when a foreign subsidiary pays a dividend and shareholder-level withholding tax?
• Outcome: Advice given
• Key authorities: IRC §§ 901 and 902; Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(f)(1)

Full text (IRS public release)

ID: CCA_2010090118440635 Number: 201040007
Release Date: 10/8/2010
Office: ----- ----------
UILC: 902.01-02, 901.02-01

From: --------------------
Sent: Wednesday, September 01, 2010 6:44:08 PM
To: -----------------------
Cc:
Subject: RE: Quick question

When a foreign corporation pays a dividend to a domestic corporate 10% shareholder, section 902 treats
foreign taxes paid by the foreign subsidiary with respect to the earnings out of which the dividend is paid
as deemed paid by the U.S. shareholder. See section 902(a). Deemed-paid taxes include only
corporate-level taxes paid by the distributing foreign corporation--taxes for which the subsidiary has legal
liability. See section 902(c)(2) and (c)(4)(A). A withholding tax imposed on the dividend, even if collected
and remitted by the distributing corporation, is considered paid by the US shareholder and eligible for a
direct credit under section 901. See Treas. Reg. 1.901-2(f)(1). It is not included in the section 902 tax
pool of the foreign subsidiary, because it is a legal liability of the shareholder imposed on the
shareholder's dividend income, not a tax imposed on the corporate-level profits of the foreign subsidiary.

If, rather than withholding tax from the shareholder's dividend income, the foreign subsidiary itself pays a
foreign tax that is the legal liability of its U.S. shareholder, in addition to paying out the full dividend, then
under general U.S. tax principles the shareholder will have additional income in the amount of the tax
paid on its behalf. This income will generally be characterized as additional dividend income to the
shareholder if the payment is not compensatory or otherwise a transfer for value. The shareholder may
compute a deemed-paid credit for subsidiary-level tax paid with respect to the earnings used to pay this
constructive dividend. The deemed-paid credit is in respect of the additional cash dividend constructively
received by the shareholder from the subsidiary that is considered used by the shareholder to pay the
shareholder-level withholding tax. Because the withholding tax is the shareholder's legal liability, when the
subsidiary pays the tax it is considered to have paid a dividend to the shareholder, and the shareholder is
considered to have paid the tax for purposes of section 901.

When shareholder-level withholding tax is paid by the foreign distributing subsidiary in respect of a
dividend or other gross income amount due the shareholder that is not paid in cash to the shareholder,
but instead is retained by the distributing corporation, the amount of income constructively received by the
shareholder may depend on whether the amount credited as a capital contribution is the gross amount of
the original inclusion (in which case the tax payment constitutes additional income to the shareholder) or
the net amount after deduction for the withholding (in which case the tax payment could be considered
made out of the original gross inclusion).

Please feel free to call if you have further questions.