Can a South Dakota State's Attorney who is now a full-time county employee still do private legal work on the side, as long as it's not in state court?

Plain-English summary

Custer County recently switched its State's Attorney from a part-time to a full-time position. State's Attorney Kelley asked the AG whether the change cut off his ability to do any private legal work outside the office, or just some kinds.

SDCL 7-16-19 says, for full-time state's attorneys, "the state's attorney may not be counsel or attorney in any action, civil or criminal, in the courts of this state except when acting on behalf of the county or the State of South Dakota." AG Marty Jackley read that text strictly:

• It bars representation of private clients in "actions, civil or criminal" (court proceedings).
• "In the courts of this state" means South Dakota state courts.
• Outside those state-court proceedings, the statute is silent.

The plain text leaves room for a full-time state's attorney to do non-courtroom private legal work (transactional, contract, advisory) and federal-court representation. The opinion contrasts SDCL 7-16-19 with SDCL 1-11-1.1, which says of the Attorney General: "The attorney general shall serve on a full-time basis and may not actively engage in the private practice of law." That statute is a blanket bar on private practice. The legislature wrote a sweeping ban for the AG and a much narrower one for full-time state's attorneys, and the AG opinion respects the difference.

The opinion interpreted only SDCL 7-16-19. It did not discuss the terms of county employment, professional-conduct rules, or the economics of a full-time position.

What this means for you

If you are a South Dakota full-time state's attorney

Per this opinion, SDCL 7-16-19 bars you from being counsel or attorney for a private party in any civil or criminal action in the courts of South Dakota, except when acting on behalf of the county or the State. The AG read the statute as reaching only that conduct: it does not prohibit other private legal work outside the South Dakota courtroom, and the opinion notes the statute also does not prohibit civil or criminal practice in federal court. The opinion does not address the Rules of Professional Conduct, so any conflict-of-interest or disclosure obligations under those rules are a separate question it does not resolve.

If you are a county commissioner or considering a full-time designation

The opinion clarifies what the full-time designation does and does not do under SDCL 7-16-19. A full-time state's attorney is barred from representing private clients in South Dakota state-court proceedings, but the statute itself does not bar that attorney from other private legal practice. The opinion interprets only the statute; it does not address what a county may require by contract or county policy.

Comparison with the Attorney General

The opinion contrasts SDCL 7-16-19 with SDCL 1-11-1.1, which provides that the Attorney General "shall serve on a full-time basis and may not actively engage in the private practice of law." The AG treated that total bar as evidence that the legislature knew how to prohibit private practice outright and chose not to do so for full-time state's attorneys. Changing that would be a matter for the legislature, not this opinion.

Common questions

Q: What is a "full-time state's attorney"?
A: Under SDCL 7-16-19, "in any county of over fifty thousand population and any other county where the board of county commissioners so designates, the state's attorney shall be a full-time position." Larger counties (over 50,000) are automatically full-time. Smaller counties can elect full-time status by board action, as Custer County did.

Q: What exactly is prohibited under SDCL 7-16-19?
A: Acting as counsel or attorney for a private party in any civil or criminal action in any South Dakota state court (Circuit Court, Magistrate Court, Supreme Court, etc.), with the carve-out for representation on behalf of the county or the State.

Q: Can a full-time state's attorney appear as defendant's counsel in a non-criminal SD state-court case (e.g., a divorce, contract dispute)?
A: No, not for a private client. SDCL 7-16-19 applies to "any action, civil or criminal." The bar covers civil cases including domestic, contract, and property disputes in SD state courts.

Q: What about appearing in a SD state court on behalf of one's own family (parent, spouse, child) pro se?
A: Representing a parent, spouse, or child in state court would be representing another private party, which the opinion said SDCL 7-16-19 prohibits for a full-time state's attorney. The opinion did not address an attorney appearing solely on their own behalf.

Q: Can a full-time state's attorney handle a real-estate closing for a friend?
A: Per this opinion, SDCL 7-16-19 does not bar transactional work like a real estate closing, since it is not a civil or criminal action in the courts of the State. (Separate Rules of Professional Conduct questions are outside the opinion's scope.)

Q: Can the state's attorney teach a CLE or write for a law journal?
A: The opinion did not address teaching or writing. It interpreted the statutory restriction on acting as counsel or attorney for private parties in South Dakota state-court actions.

Q: What if the county wants to require the state's attorney to be exclusively dedicated to county work?
A: The opinion does not address that. It interprets only SDCL 7-16-19 and does not speak to what a county may require through employment terms or county policy.

Q: Does this opinion apply to part-time state's attorneys?
A: The restriction quoted in the opinion expressly concerns full-time state's attorneys. The AG did not analyze what other rules govern part-time prosecutors' private practice.

Background and statutory framework

The opinion describes state's attorneys as elected or appointed officials who prosecute or defend actions involving the state or county and advise county offices. Custer County's state's attorney position changed from part-time to full-time before the election mentioned in the request.

SDCL 7-16-19 prohibited a full-time state's attorney from representing private parties in civil or criminal actions in South Dakota state courts. Jackley found no wider private-practice ban in its text. The opinion did not explain the Legislature's motive for drawing that line.

The opinion's comparison with SDCL 1-11-1.1 is the analytical move. The Attorney General position is the model of an exclusive full-time legal role: the AG cannot do any private practice at all. If the legislature wanted state's attorneys treated the same way, it would have used the same statutory language. It did not. So full-time state's attorneys have a narrower prohibition than the AG.

The opinion did not address professional-conduct rules, county employment terms, or particular conflicts of interest. Its answer was confined to the statutory ban in SDCL 7-16-19.

Citations and references

Statutes:

• SDCL 7-16-19 (full-time state's attorney restriction)
• SDCL 1-11-1.1 (AG full-time bar)

Cases on statutory interpretation:

• Olson v. Butte County Comm'n, 2019 S.D. 13, 925 N.W.2d 463
• In re Wintersteen Revocable Trust Agreement, 2018 S.D. 12, 907 N.W.2d 785
• Reck v. S.D. Bd. of Pardons & Paroles, 2019 S.D. 42, 932 N.W.2d 135

Source

• Landing page: https://atg.sd.gov/OurOffice/OfficialOpinions/opinionhtml.aspx?id=1763
• Original PDF: https://atg.sd.gov/OfficialOpinions/Official%20Opinion%2024-01.pdf

Original opinion text

OFFICIAL OPINION No. 24-01

Re: Official Opinion Concerning the Ability of Full-Time State's Attorneys to Engage in the Private Practice of Law

Dear State's Attorney Kelley,

In your capacity as the State's Attorney for Custer County you have requested an official opinion from the Attorney General's Office on the following question:

QUESTION:

Does SDCL § 7-16-9 prohibit full-time state's attorneys from engaging in the private practice of law, outside of their state's attorney's position, whether done with or without compensation?

ANSWER:

No. SDCL § 7-16-19 only prohibits a full-time state's attorney from representing a private party in a civil or criminal proceeding pending in the courts of the State. SDCL § 7-16-9 does not prohibit a full-time state's attorney from otherwise engaging in the private practice of law.

FACTS:

State's attorneys are elected or appointed officials that prosecute and defend, on behalf of the State or county, all civil or criminal actions or proceedings where the state or county is an interested party. State's attorneys also provide legal opinions and advice to their county commission and other county offices.

Historically, the Custer County state's attorney has been a part-time position, but was changed to a full-time position prior to the last election. The question has arisen concerning your ability to perform work outside of your duties as a full-time state's attorney.

IN RE QUESTION:

You have requested an interpretation of the following statutory language:

In any county of over fifty thousand population and any other county where the board of county commissioners so designates, the state's attorney shall be a full-time position and the state's attorney may not be counsel or attorney in any action, civil or criminal, in the courts of this state except when acting on behalf of the county or the State of South Dakota.

SDCL § 7-16-19.

When interpreting a statute to determine its meaning, "'the language expressed in the statute is the paramount consideration.'" Olson v. Butte County Comm'n, 2019 S.D. 13, ¶ 5, 925 N.W.2d 463, 464 (quoting Goetz v. State, 2001 S.D. 138, ¶ 5, 636 N.W.2d 675, 68). "When the language in a statute is clear, certain and unambiguous, there is no reason for construction." In re Wintersteen Revocable Trust Agreement, 2018 S.D. 12, 907 N.W.2d 785, 789 (internal citation omitted). When the intent of the statutory language is unclear, "the intent of the legislature is derived from plain, ordinary and popular meaning of the statutory language." Id.

The plain language of SDCL § 7-16-19 prohibits full-time state's attorneys from representing anyone, except their county or the State, in a civil or criminal action in the courts of this State. Considering this, it is my opinion that the statute only restricts a full-time state's attorney from representing private clients in those civil or criminal proceedings that are pending before courts in South Dakota. I find no prohibition in the language of the statute prohibiting a full-time state's attorney from conducting other private legal work outside the courtroom. Similarly, the language of the statute also does not prohibit a full-time state's attorney from engaging in civil or criminal practice in federal court.

If the Legislature intended to limit a full-time state's attorney's ability to engage in the private practice of law, it could have included that limitation in the statute. For comparison consider the statutory language limiting the Attorney General's ability to conduct private legal work. "The attorney general shall serve on a full-time basis and may not actively engage in the private practice of law." SDCL § 1-11-1.1. The Legislature prohibited the Attorney General from engaging in any private legal practice. In contrast, the Legislature has only prohibited full-time state's attorneys from representing private legal clients in proceedings before the civil and criminal courts of the State.

I must "assume that statutes mean what they say and that legislators have said what they meant." Reck v. S.D. Bd. of Pardons & Paroles, 2019 S.D. 42, ¶ 14, 932 N.W.2d 135, 140 (cleaned up). The language of SDCL § 7-16-19 does not prohibit a full-time state's attorney from providing legal counsel to private clients in matters that are not before the various courts of the State.

CONCLUSION:

I conclude that SDCL § 7-16-19 prohibits a full-time state's attorney from representing a private party in a civil or criminal matter in the courts of the State. The statute does not prohibit a full-time state's attorney from otherwise engaging in the private practice of law.

Sincerely,

Marty J. Jackley

ATTORNEY GENERAL

MJJ/EEH/SRB/dd